Sep 28, 2026 · 1 hr 23 min · 16 segments
“You almost feel stupid buying the product as a one-time customer.” Why do some subscription brands retain customers and stack LTV while others lose them? Matt Bertulli (CEO, Pela & Lomi) and Cody…
Aidan ThibodeauxGuestMatt BertulliHost
Bernard MeyerGuest
Cody PlofkerHostSo boys, the reason that we got you guys on, since neither one of us has built a subscription first brand before, we thought this would be an opportunity to have you guys on and kind of school us a little bit.
brands, we've got a product, it's a sleep supplement, we're selling it as a daily, it's very, it's built for subscription.
And we want to, obviously, like our goal is as many subscribers as possible, like as many quality subscribers as possible.
And Bernard, I kind of want to I want you to like, help us think through communication.
So maybe Aiden, take us away, let's start with the very basics of what we should be thinking about.

And what I will say is, like, one, having access to all of this data makes you realize, like, one thing, and that's there is no silver bullet, if I could talk to that.

When it comes to everything in subscriptions, and that's why if you spend a bunch of time on Twitter, like we all do, everybody's going to tell you, I test everything, and I can just tell you, having come from, like, the messaging world before I got into all of this, like, subscriptions are no different.

And what I mean by that is like, we have brands come in and it's like, I would say not just keep it stupid simple, but don't get lazy too.

Everybody sees like, hey, Skio, Recharge, whatever platform you're on, we've all done a good job kind of building out the features that make this stuff easy.

But if you don't have a large subscriber group, they're not going to do anything for you.

So if you think about this, like I would say simple, stupid basics or as all of our podcasts, people like to talk about first principles.

It's like, hey, you guys are a brand new brand, right? What I would prescribe and what anybody in this space is going to prescribe is going to be completely different if you're a brand with, let's say, 50 or 100,000 subscribers, right? Because then we're going to go through, diagnose, you might have some sort of great offer and you're bleeding out in a different way.
So boys, the reason that we got you guys on, since neither one of us has built a subscription first brand before, we thought this would be an opportunity to have you guys on and kind of school us a little bit.
brands, we've got a product, it's a sleep supplement, we're selling it as a daily, it's very, it's built for subscription.
And we want to, obviously, like our goal is as many subscribers as possible, like as many quality subscribers as possible.
And Bernard, I kind of want to I want you to like, help us think through communication.
So maybe Aiden, take us away, let's start with the very basics of what we should be thinking about.

And what I will say is, like, one, having access to all of this data makes you realize, like, one thing, and that's there is no silver bullet, if I could talk to that.

When it comes to everything in subscriptions, and that's why if you spend a bunch of time on Twitter, like we all do, everybody's going to tell you, I test everything, and I can just tell you, having come from, like, the messaging world before I got into all of this, like, subscriptions are no different.

And what I mean by that is like, we have brands come in and it's like, I would say not just keep it stupid simple, but don't get lazy too.

Everybody sees like, hey, Skio, Recharge, whatever platform you're on, we've all done a good job kind of building out the features that make this stuff easy.

But if you don't have a large subscriber group, they're not going to do anything for you.

So if you think about this, like I would say simple, stupid basics or as all of our podcasts, people like to talk about first principles.

It's like, hey, you guys are a brand new brand, right? What I would prescribe and what anybody in this space is going to prescribe is going to be completely different if you're a brand with, let's say, 50 or 100,000 subscribers, right? Because then we're going to go through, diagnose, you might have some sort of great offer and you're bleeding out in a different way.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.