Oct 29, 2026 · 27 min · 10 segments
Short term rentals (STRs) have put residents and investors at odds all over Canada, but Tiny Township in Ontario recently took center stage. The Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal from an…
Areta LloydHost
Matt Hodgson, it's so nice to have you here today to talk about a truly divisive issue, short-term rentals.
Yes, I believe so in terms of the regulation of short-term rentals and likely as licensing bylaws apply to municipalities broadly.

Growing up, it was known as quite the party destination for those of us in southern Ontario.

Over the years, but especially during the pandemic, people bought up cottages and quite often their financing plan included short-term rentals.

However, those are a hot potato for so many reasons, including that they deplete the housing supply and impact affordability.
And I think with that license, that framework imposed certain requirements on the owners of those properties that weren't originally subject to any regulation at all.
And so I think just the fact that there was some regulatory framework in itself that was being applied to a previously unregulated area is what those residents or those property owners received.
The bylaw itself imposed, it categorized that short-term rental is anything that's being rented for 20 days or less and imposed certain restrictions on the ability to rent for certain periods of time during the summer season, the busy season, and then some other restrictions in the off season.
However, that fee would likely pale in comparison to what a property owner would get for a rental on Georgian Bay in tiny, which does have some of the best beaches in Ontario, for

Some of them were quite unhappy, and they formed an association, the Tiny Township Association of Responsible Short-Term Rental Owners.

Matt, can you take us through the original application? And were you on for that lower court hearing?
I was on for the Superior Court application, which was an application brought under Section 273 of the Menace Black to wash the bylaw for illegality.

Matt Hodgson, it's so nice to have you here today to talk about a truly divisive issue, short-term rentals.
Yes, I believe so in terms of the regulation of short-term rentals and likely as licensing bylaws apply to municipalities broadly.

Growing up, it was known as quite the party destination for those of us in southern Ontario.

Over the years, but especially during the pandemic, people bought up cottages and quite often their financing plan included short-term rentals.

However, those are a hot potato for so many reasons, including that they deplete the housing supply and impact affordability.
And I think with that license, that framework imposed certain requirements on the owners of those properties that weren't originally subject to any regulation at all.
And so I think just the fact that there was some regulatory framework in itself that was being applied to a previously unregulated area is what those residents or those property owners received.
The bylaw itself imposed, it categorized that short-term rental is anything that's being rented for 20 days or less and imposed certain restrictions on the ability to rent for certain periods of time during the summer season, the busy season, and then some other restrictions in the off season.
However, that fee would likely pale in comparison to what a property owner would get for a rental on Georgian Bay in tiny, which does have some of the best beaches in Ontario, for

Some of them were quite unhappy, and they formed an association, the Tiny Township Association of Responsible Short-Term Rental Owners.

Matt, can you take us through the original application? And were you on for that lower court hearing?
I was on for the Superior Court application, which was an application brought under Section 273 of the Menace Black to wash the bylaw for illegality.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.