Skip to main content

Matt Hodgson

Oct 29, 2026

6:05
Certainly speak to the appeal for sure.
6:08
They're one and the same because in that particular context, because in the first instance, the application judge also gave a light credence to the process that was undertaken prior to the enactment of the bylaw, which was then reflected again at the appellate level.
6:23
What they were suggesting is that when a township or when a municipality itself undertakes extensive consultations with various stakeholders... and really carefully considers both the pros and cons of a particular regulatory approach that's being proposed, that effort, that essentially sort of democratic effort, is something that the court should consider.
6:43
not touch.
6:44
And that's reflected in the governing test, which was then adopted in the appellate decision, which is hour-by-hour from the Supreme Court.
6:52
We can get into that, but that wasn't available at the application hearing because that decision hadn't been released yet.
6:57
There was another test that was the overriding test, which was one from Clublink.

9 MINS LATER

15:38
Do you want to review that since we're talking about what municipal objectives might be and what's permissible? It seems pretty broad, but it would be really good to get a synopsis from you.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.