Sep 23, 2026 · 55 min · 14 segments
Dr. Pegotty Cooper, co-founder of the Certified Divorce Coach Program and a Supreme Court of Florida-certified family mediator, joins Dr. Tara Perry to…
Pegotty CooperGuest
Tara PerryHost
So I-- The-- From the moment I heard-- So, uh, let me tell you why I'd practiced for three years, 'cause that is also an, kind of an important thing, and it's what really made me realize how important emotions are in all of this.

This was prior to-- This was three years prior to the incident in my house, and I got a call from a family member that said, um, our sister, uh, had, uh, disappeared, and, uh, her car was gone, and her son was dead in the driveway.

The police came and said her body was found under the high-tension wires, and she'd been raped and shot five times.

Um, and what had happened was, uh, a neighbor who lived across the street, ironically across the street, uh, had come into her house with a rope and a gun.

I just kept thinking, "What could she have done? What could she have done?" What was so-- W- That, that young fellow who we, uh, had understood had, had been a former student of hers, and she was a substitute teacher, so he'd been a s-substitute student, [chuckles] basically.

And, um, it, it turns out that what he had, uh-- And now this didn't come to light until forty years later.

But what happened when he finally admitted that he'd done it, which was at his third parole hearing, he hadn't ever acknowledged it, that he had, had done it, said, "She'd said something nasty to me that hurt my feelings." He was also a very low intelligent person.

He was just finished his-- This happened on the day that he finished his junior year in high school.

I went over-- I just wanted, I just wanted to scare her, so I took a rope and a gun." And the parole board, of course, said, "What did you expect to do with a rope and a gun?" There's, you know.

And so I kept thinking when I learned that he'd just gone into her house, you know, several years earlier in the first trial, I thought, "What could she have done? What could she have done differently?" And I kept thinking about that.

How could she have validated him? How could she have soothed him? Maybe, uh, you know, c- uh, acknowledged him, yes, you know, like, acknowledged what he was feeling, all of that kind of thing, because something must have gotten this young man really riled up.

But in his final parole hearing, his most recent one, he said, "My dad beat me.

He always told me how stupid I was, and I was sexually assaulted by a neighbor boy next door.

He was stuck with all of that hurt and that violation and, and he just couldn't see that there was absolutely nothing that this young, this young mother who'd always wanted to be a mother, kind of newcomer to town, had wanted to make it a home for herself and her husband.

So I-- The-- From the moment I heard-- So, uh, let me tell you why I'd practiced for three years, 'cause that is also an, kind of an important thing, and it's what really made me realize how important emotions are in all of this.

This was prior to-- This was three years prior to the incident in my house, and I got a call from a family member that said, um, our sister, uh, had, uh, disappeared, and, uh, her car was gone, and her son was dead in the driveway.

The police came and said her body was found under the high-tension wires, and she'd been raped and shot five times.

Um, and what had happened was, uh, a neighbor who lived across the street, ironically across the street, uh, had come into her house with a rope and a gun.

I just kept thinking, "What could she have done? What could she have done?" What was so-- W- That, that young fellow who we, uh, had understood had, had been a former student of hers, and she was a substitute teacher, so he'd been a s-substitute student, [chuckles] basically.

And, um, it, it turns out that what he had, uh-- And now this didn't come to light until forty years later.

But what happened when he finally admitted that he'd done it, which was at his third parole hearing, he hadn't ever acknowledged it, that he had, had done it, said, "She'd said something nasty to me that hurt my feelings." He was also a very low intelligent person.

He was just finished his-- This happened on the day that he finished his junior year in high school.

I went over-- I just wanted, I just wanted to scare her, so I took a rope and a gun." And the parole board, of course, said, "What did you expect to do with a rope and a gun?" There's, you know.

And so I kept thinking when I learned that he'd just gone into her house, you know, several years earlier in the first trial, I thought, "What could she have done? What could she have done differently?" And I kept thinking about that.

How could she have validated him? How could she have soothed him? Maybe, uh, you know, c- uh, acknowledged him, yes, you know, like, acknowledged what he was feeling, all of that kind of thing, because something must have gotten this young man really riled up.

But in his final parole hearing, his most recent one, he said, "My dad beat me.

He always told me how stupid I was, and I was sexually assaulted by a neighbor boy next door.

He was stuck with all of that hurt and that violation and, and he just couldn't see that there was absolutely nothing that this young, this young mother who'd always wanted to be a mother, kind of newcomer to town, had wanted to make it a home for herself and her husband.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.