Aug 17, 2026 · 45 min · 14 segments
**When a girl is abducted from a small town in western Washington, it takes years for her remains to finally be found in a remote woodland hours away. Investigators continue the long hunt for a…
She was 10 years old at the time and lived in the small town of McLary, Washington.
McLary is located in the western part of the state, about a half hour's drive west of Olympia, and was home to about 1,500 people at the time.
Lindsay lived there with her mom, Melissa, and her older brother by a couple of years, Josh.
The family of three had moved to McLary from Tennessee earlier that summer following the divorce of Lindsay's parents.
Melissa was from Washington State, so for her, it was moving home, and Lindsay was adapting well to the changes.
She had already made friends and could often be seen traversing the town with him on foot.
Lindsay's mom, Melissa, would later speak to Dateline about the move, saying, "...McClary felt like a nice, quiet, safe town.
Everything seemed to be smoothing over for us finally." Melissa had considered moving to a larger town, such as Olympia, but had ultimately settled on McLary because she believed it would be a safer place to raise children.
Lindsay was an outgoing, intelligent, and imaginative girl who loved to talk and who dreamed of one day becoming a professional writer or possibly a veterinarian.
When she wrote, she dotted her I's with little stars, and when she read, it was often a book from one of her two favorite series, Harry Potter or Twilight.
The Twilight books were all the rage at the time, and Lindsay likely identified with the protagonist, a girl whose parents were divorced and who moved thousands of miles to live in a small town in Washington state.
Fortunately for Lindsay, one of the friends she'd made in McLary had a pool and had invited her and her brother, Josh, over to swim.
They swam for hours throughout the day, periodically returning home briefly and then heading back out again.
That evening, Josh left for home before Lindsay did, at least in part because the two of them had gotten into a disagreement over Josh's bike, which she had borrowed earlier that day.
According to reporting for The Olympian, such a disagreement wasn't uncommon for them, but rather typical sibling stuff.
So by the time Lindsay left, it was late evening, approaching nighttime, around 9 p.m.
She was 10 years old at the time and lived in the small town of McLary, Washington.
McLary is located in the western part of the state, about a half hour's drive west of Olympia, and was home to about 1,500 people at the time.
Lindsay lived there with her mom, Melissa, and her older brother by a couple of years, Josh.
The family of three had moved to McLary from Tennessee earlier that summer following the divorce of Lindsay's parents.
Melissa was from Washington State, so for her, it was moving home, and Lindsay was adapting well to the changes.
She had already made friends and could often be seen traversing the town with him on foot.
Lindsay's mom, Melissa, would later speak to Dateline about the move, saying, "...McClary felt like a nice, quiet, safe town.
Everything seemed to be smoothing over for us finally." Melissa had considered moving to a larger town, such as Olympia, but had ultimately settled on McLary because she believed it would be a safer place to raise children.
Lindsay was an outgoing, intelligent, and imaginative girl who loved to talk and who dreamed of one day becoming a professional writer or possibly a veterinarian.
When she wrote, she dotted her I's with little stars, and when she read, it was often a book from one of her two favorite series, Harry Potter or Twilight.
The Twilight books were all the rage at the time, and Lindsay likely identified with the protagonist, a girl whose parents were divorced and who moved thousands of miles to live in a small town in Washington state.
Fortunately for Lindsay, one of the friends she'd made in McLary had a pool and had invited her and her brother, Josh, over to swim.
They swam for hours throughout the day, periodically returning home briefly and then heading back out again.
That evening, Josh left for home before Lindsay did, at least in part because the two of them had gotten into a disagreement over Josh's bike, which she had borrowed earlier that day.
According to reporting for The Olympian, such a disagreement wasn't uncommon for them, but rather typical sibling stuff.
So by the time Lindsay left, it was late evening, approaching nighttime, around 9 p.m.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.