Listener sentiment
Listener enthusiasm for Diabolical Lies remains overwhelmingly strong, with the great majority of recent reviewers describing the show as intellectually transformative and awarding top marks. Hosts Katie and Caro continue to draw praise for rigorous, source-backed research, sharp humor, and an on-air chemistry that makes dense cultural and political analysis feel like a conversation with your smartest, funniest friends — a recurring comparison listeners make to the You're Wrong About and Maintenance Phase universe. The feminist, anti-capitalist lens and the ad-free subscription model that redistributes revenue to social causes remain frequently cited draws, and many listeners describe binge-listening the entire back catalog after discovering the show through TikTok, Substack, or word-of-mouth. The most consistent friction point is the paywall: several listeners express frustration when free episodes cut off mid-sentence with the remainder behind a subscriber barrier, though paid subscribers overwhelmingly feel the content is worth every cent. A small number of dissenting voices raise concerns about occasional gaps in cultural competency, insensitive phrasing, specific episode takes they found narrow or unfair, and a conversational style that can veer into what some perceive as aimless banter — but these remain individual grievances against a backdrop of near-universal acclaim.
Apple4.7 · 315
Summary generated Sep 25, 2026
