Chananya KramerHost
Deit Tanya, because the brisa says, miser behemishel yasaymim, maychranay say, they may sell it.

Because those parts are not the edible parts, therefore they lack that kedusha, and you're allowed to sell them.

And the chedusha, the brisa, is you're allowed to actually inflate that cost and be mavlaya, the bosser within it.

And then we're saying you have to use havlah, which sounds like there is a limitation on the sale of it.

That's when you're allowed to use the Havla, when you're doing it for Yassimim.

It sounds like a non-Yassim, which could actually be a Yassim, but the Yassim's all grown up right now, so we don't give him halachas of a Yassim.

What's the difference between this, Bryce, and the Mishnah in Masech Tesukah that says, If you buy a lulav in Esrog during the Shemitah year, when you're not allowed to do business with Perishviyas, and the person who's purchasing is an Amaretz, so nice and light Esrog, but Matanah, give him the Esrog as a Matanah, because he can't pay for it, because he can't do business with Eshviyastika, Perish.


So why wouldn't you also be allowed to do it with a Meister Behema that's owned by the grown-up Yoseim? And for the Gemara, it's v'chilik.

So that's all a biased understanding of the Bresa that we're talking about the Maiser Behemah of Yesayimim.

Deit Tanya, because the brisa says, miser behemishel yasaymim, maychranay say, they may sell it.

Because those parts are not the edible parts, therefore they lack that kedusha, and you're allowed to sell them.

And the chedusha, the brisa, is you're allowed to actually inflate that cost and be mavlaya, the bosser within it.

And then we're saying you have to use havlah, which sounds like there is a limitation on the sale of it.

That's when you're allowed to use the Havla, when you're doing it for Yassimim.

It sounds like a non-Yassim, which could actually be a Yassim, but the Yassim's all grown up right now, so we don't give him halachas of a Yassim.

What's the difference between this, Bryce, and the Mishnah in Masech Tesukah that says, If you buy a lulav in Esrog during the Shemitah year, when you're not allowed to do business with Perishviyas, and the person who's purchasing is an Amaretz, so nice and light Esrog, but Matanah, give him the Esrog as a Matanah, because he can't pay for it, because he can't do business with Eshviyastika, Perish.


So why wouldn't you also be allowed to do it with a Meister Behema that's owned by the grown-up Yoseim? And for the Gemara, it's v'chilik.

So that's all a biased understanding of the Bresa that we're talking about the Maiser Behemah of Yesayimim.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.