- Speakers
Darren PlatzkyHostPanelistPanelistPanelistPanelistPanelistPanelist
Darren PlatzkyHostPanelistPanelistPanelistPanelistPanelistPanelist
Is a Yisrael shepherd Ne'eman or a coin shepherd not Ne'eman? Is a coin for a coin not Ne'eman? And we saw Tanakama, we saw Rabbi Shriven Gamliel.
Shriven Gamliel said, Ne'eman huachavari, that a coin is Ne'eman if he's the shepherd for his friend, to give an opinion on his friends.
The question is now, what does it mean when we say Yishrael, a coin, a shepherd of Yishrael, or a shepherd of a coin? So the Gemara gave a couple of different opinions.
We had the writer said, that both Rabbi Yochanan and Rabbi Lazar said like this, Ro'eh Yisrael, that's an Israeli shepherd, a shepherd of Yisrael, for Kohanim.
Okay? And then we had, so we had Yisrael, who's a shepherd for Kohanim, and then we had a Kohen, who's a shepherd for Yisrael, and we had Kohen, who's a shepherd for Kohen, and basically Rabbi Rokhanan and Rabbi Lazar each explained in a slightly different way.
And to go over very, very quickly, I made a summary over here, so I'll go through it outside the Gemara.
one of them said one way, and one of them said, we don't know who's saying who, whether it's Rabbi Yochanan or Rabbi Lazar, but one of them is saying as follows, one of them is saying like this, that the Yisrael, if he's the Yisrael, and he's a shepherd for Kohanim, we trust him.
Because the Yisrael is for the Kohen, we don't think that he's going to have a problem, going to want to help the Kohen in any way, because he's thinking to himself, he's not going to benefit from it anyhow.
Is a Yisrael shepherd Ne'eman or a coin shepherd not Ne'eman? Is a coin for a coin not Ne'eman? And we saw Tanakama, we saw Rabbi Shriven Gamliel.
Shriven Gamliel said, Ne'eman huachavari, that a coin is Ne'eman if he's the shepherd for his friend, to give an opinion on his friends.
The question is now, what does it mean when we say Yishrael, a coin, a shepherd of Yishrael, or a shepherd of a coin? So the Gemara gave a couple of different opinions.
We had the writer said, that both Rabbi Yochanan and Rabbi Lazar said like this, Ro'eh Yisrael, that's an Israeli shepherd, a shepherd of Yisrael, for Kohanim.
Okay? And then we had, so we had Yisrael, who's a shepherd for Kohanim, and then we had a Kohen, who's a shepherd for Yisrael, and we had Kohen, who's a shepherd for Kohen, and basically Rabbi Rokhanan and Rabbi Lazar each explained in a slightly different way.
And to go over very, very quickly, I made a summary over here, so I'll go through it outside the Gemara.
one of them said one way, and one of them said, we don't know who's saying who, whether it's Rabbi Yochanan or Rabbi Lazar, but one of them is saying as follows, one of them is saying like this, that the Yisrael, if he's the Yisrael, and he's a shepherd for Kohanim, we trust him.
Because the Yisrael is for the Kohen, we don't think that he's going to have a problem, going to want to help the Kohen in any way, because he's thinking to himself, he's not going to benefit from it anyhow.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.