May 26, 2026 · 32 min · 11 segments
We talk a lot about learning from failure. But what about success? It might be quietly doing more damage than you think. In this episode of the Church Staff Book Club, Jonathan Malm and Jason Young…
Hmm.
That's good.
So when we put them together, can they hang out in the same world? And that's what this chapter talks about.
Mm-hmm.
I agreed with everything, but I'm like, what are we really talking about here?
Hmm.
And I think that's maybe our, our problem with this book, that we really...
If we're really gonna, like, get the meat out of this book, if we're gonna, like, take all the wing bone, the wing meat off the bone, right?
[laughs]
Like [laughs] that's the goal.
If we're really gonna, like, get all the, the meat off of it, we gotta, we gotta really figure out what we're talking about, like what sort of failures we're talking about, what sort of successes we're talking about.
I mean, honestly, as I was reading this, this is one of my, this is one of my theories about writing in general, is that sometimes the people with the greatest success in life are not the ones who should write the book.
Mm.
Because a lot of times when you have a ton of success, and this is kind of what he talked about, you don't evaluate why something worked.
So, you know, this person, the person who launched this revolutionary small groups approach at his church, right? Like, it just, it blew up the church overnight, right? It was incredibly successful, and so he'll tell you what he did, but he won't necessarily explain well why it worked.
Mm.
Or why it might need to be different at your church.
"Hey, just follow this, follow this approach and it's gonna work for you." And, and I think-
Mm
...
so often in our churches, we read a book and you're like, dude, this person had incredible results.
Hmm.
That's good.
So when we put them together, can they hang out in the same world? And that's what this chapter talks about.
Mm-hmm.
I agreed with everything, but I'm like, what are we really talking about here?
Hmm.
And I think that's maybe our, our problem with this book, that we really...
If we're really gonna, like, get the meat out of this book, if we're gonna, like, take all the wing bone, the wing meat off the bone, right?
[laughs]
Like [laughs] that's the goal.
If we're really gonna, like, get all the, the meat off of it, we gotta, we gotta really figure out what we're talking about, like what sort of failures we're talking about, what sort of successes we're talking about.
I mean, honestly, as I was reading this, this is one of my, this is one of my theories about writing in general, is that sometimes the people with the greatest success in life are not the ones who should write the book.
Mm.
Because a lot of times when you have a ton of success, and this is kind of what he talked about, you don't evaluate why something worked.
So, you know, this person, the person who launched this revolutionary small groups approach at his church, right? Like, it just, it blew up the church overnight, right? It was incredibly successful, and so he'll tell you what he did, but he won't necessarily explain well why it worked.
Mm.
Or why it might need to be different at your church.
"Hey, just follow this, follow this approach and it's gonna work for you." And, and I think-
Mm
...
so often in our churches, we read a book and you're like, dude, this person had incredible results.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.