9/20/2026 - Jerry Weinberger / Mincha Maftir Yom Kippur
Sep 20, 2026 · 3 min · 3 segments
Send us Fan Mail Mincha Maftir Yom Kippur
- Speakers
Jerry WeinbergerGuest
- Show signals
- SuitabilitySafeBiasNot politicalAudience≈13 followers
Sep 20, 2026 · 3 min · 3 segments
Send us Fan Mail Mincha Maftir Yom Kippur
Jerry WeinbergerGuest
Yei shlachar, yigamech ha-chira, if the leaning mincha on Yom Kippur is at Kedush HaTzayim of Yom Kippurim, similar to Shacharis, or is it at a Tana Sibur, similar to every other mincha at Tana Sibur where we lean and have Av Torah? And you're going to want to say that maybe the fact that this is a Haftorah proves that it is not of Yom Kippurim.
But what is the reason? Why are we landing Minkah on Yom Kippur? Is it because of or is it ? This Chakira, I think, reflects very well on the Yom HaKadosh Bar Shalom in Shulchan Aruch, or Chayim Tofer Eshchok Beis, where the Mechabit talks about, where we talk about the Mincha of Yom Kippur.
The Mechabit says that when you finish the Haferot of Yom Kippur, when you finish the Haferot by Mincha of Yom Kippur, Mafti Yina, for those who are paying the big bucks, you finish it with the, with the, with the Brach of Aleveida, Aleveida ending HaMekadosh Yom Kippurim.
The Ramah argues, it says, no, that you end off with the bracha of Magid David.
So clearly, the Mechava would hold, like those that say it's Al-Kadush HaTayayim, the Ramah would hold that it's clearly Al-Tanisibur.
And there are several last communities that could be, that we could attach to this.
First of all, there's a Chubas from Rehoboam Eger where he discusses if somebody is, if someone has to break his fast for medical reasons, let's say someone's never sick, he needs to break his fast.
Can he be oiled by Mincha? So now, if you hold that Al-Kadush Tz'ayyim, and that being said, by Shacharist, there's no Shaila.
So now, if you hold Kadush Tz'ayyim, then the guy who ate could still be Oyla Maftuyayna.
If you hold that Al-Tz'al-Sibur, then we hold that Oychloy Ein Al-Yosef, someone who eats, cannot go off, cannot be Oyla.
You say the Birkas HaTorah, and the actual laning of Yom HaRom is a different type of tune.
So, now, if you hold that it's Atsushita Yaim, you would lane with the same trump, and you would do the same tune for the Brachas, and you would use the same Yom HaRom trump.
If you hold that as Al-Tanatibor, then you would use the regular Trap that we use on a regular every day.
It seems that the Sephardim actually do use the Yantif Trap, and the Sephardim do end, like the Makkah says, they do end with the Baruch HaValavayitah, while the Ashkenazim, like the Ramah, use the regular Trap and end by Magandavid.
Yei shlachar, yigamech ha-chira, if the leaning mincha on Yom Kippur is at Kedush HaTzayim of Yom Kippurim, similar to Shacharis, or is it at a Tana Sibur, similar to every other mincha at Tana Sibur where we lean and have Av Torah? And you're going to want to say that maybe the fact that this is a Haftorah proves that it is not of Yom Kippurim.
But what is the reason? Why are we landing Minkah on Yom Kippur? Is it because of or is it ? This Chakira, I think, reflects very well on the Yom HaKadosh Bar Shalom in Shulchan Aruch, or Chayim Tofer Eshchok Beis, where the Mechabit talks about, where we talk about the Mincha of Yom Kippur.
The Mechabit says that when you finish the Haferot of Yom Kippur, when you finish the Haferot by Mincha of Yom Kippur, Mafti Yina, for those who are paying the big bucks, you finish it with the, with the, with the Brach of Aleveida, Aleveida ending HaMekadosh Yom Kippurim.
The Ramah argues, it says, no, that you end off with the bracha of Magid David.
So clearly, the Mechava would hold, like those that say it's Al-Kadush HaTayayim, the Ramah would hold that it's clearly Al-Tanisibur.
And there are several last communities that could be, that we could attach to this.
First of all, there's a Chubas from Rehoboam Eger where he discusses if somebody is, if someone has to break his fast for medical reasons, let's say someone's never sick, he needs to break his fast.
Can he be oiled by Mincha? So now, if you hold that Al-Kadush Tz'ayyim, and that being said, by Shacharist, there's no Shaila.
So now, if you hold Kadush Tz'ayyim, then the guy who ate could still be Oyla Maftuyayna.
If you hold that Al-Tz'al-Sibur, then we hold that Oychloy Ein Al-Yosef, someone who eats, cannot go off, cannot be Oyla.
You say the Birkas HaTorah, and the actual laning of Yom HaRom is a different type of tune.
So, now, if you hold that it's Atsushita Yaim, you would lane with the same trump, and you would do the same tune for the Brachas, and you would use the same Yom HaRom trump.
If you hold that as Al-Tanatibor, then you would use the regular Trap that we use on a regular every day.
It seems that the Sephardim actually do use the Yantif Trap, and the Sephardim do end, like the Makkah says, they do end with the Baruch HaValavayitah, while the Ashkenazim, like the Ramah, use the regular Trap and end by Magandavid.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.