Nov 16, 2026 · 26 min · 8 segments
I started this series of Yarn Library wanting to understand more about knitting and the people who make it their living. After all those conversations, I think I have more questions than answers. We…
Adam CleevelyHost
Are we making knitting too easy? Now, this is a really interesting question for me that's come up repeatedly in different ways with people like Patty Lyons, Chantal Miyagishima, Zandy Peters, have all expressed views in different ways on that fundamental question of what should a pattern contain? There's a huge drive in the pattern design world to transition from a world where we had patterns explained in a kind of coded, dense language into a very fulsome explanation of exactly how to make what you've got in front of you.

Now, I've experienced this myself because when I've created designs, and I'm thinking particularly about my talker's hat, the one with the spiral on it, and Dominique, which is this beautiful big design with the shading on it, Those designs for me actually condensed down to a really tiny size in my notebook.

But when it came to be able to explain them to basically any knitter, I went into pages and pages of explanations and diagrams so that they were as approachable as possible.

Now, some knitters really appreciate that, but some don't, and that doesn't work for some people.

And as Patty pointed out, I'm going to quote here from the episode, by trying to merge a knitting class and a pattern, you get a diluted version of each thing.

And that made me think a lot about what I'm trying to do when I do create a design and when I do communicate it.

If you want to make a brilliant knitting pattern for an advanced knitter, actually, what you need to do is maybe present more of the puzzle.

And that's something Zandy Peters talked a lot about, was that you sometimes are creating a puzzle.

Some people, on the other hand, need the encouragement and want to be shown step by step.

And it probably comes down to a bit of a choice by a designer about who they're trying to help the most.

But it is interesting to me as someone experimenting with design about how involved you get in that process of trying to help other people's education.

Now, I've really taken that on board in terms of trying to build my own understanding about what I should be doing to help people.

So it's a design that I struggled with for a couple of months in terms of articulating exactly how I wanted it to be.

It's got 24 different cable stitches used within it and a bunch of other things as well.

and I am halfway through making it, and I have made so many mistakes, which, because it's a sample, I have to go back and correct.

Now, the thing is, as a pattern, I fully intend to release that, hopefully, as a hard pattern.

I'm going to take a step away from what I've done historically, where I try and explain everything to everyone, and this is just something which I'm going to accept is a hard thing to make, and therefore, I want to make it difficult and a puzzle for people to be able to make and i'm really interested to see how that goes i'm interested whether people buy it whether they can make it whether they choose to make it but you know for me this is all experimentation and it's all learning so i'm really interested in the feedback of that now i'm only halfway through it i'm loving it because it's such a challenge but But I can't wait to see how that does get consumed by people as a result.

And there was another piece of information in there which I thought was really interesting from Chantal and Anna, if you've listened to those episodes.

But both of them alluded to this idea that actually you may not even know the mistakes that you're making or may not know the techniques that you want to use.

Are we making knitting too easy? Now, this is a really interesting question for me that's come up repeatedly in different ways with people like Patty Lyons, Chantal Miyagishima, Zandy Peters, have all expressed views in different ways on that fundamental question of what should a pattern contain? There's a huge drive in the pattern design world to transition from a world where we had patterns explained in a kind of coded, dense language into a very fulsome explanation of exactly how to make what you've got in front of you.

Now, I've experienced this myself because when I've created designs, and I'm thinking particularly about my talker's hat, the one with the spiral on it, and Dominique, which is this beautiful big design with the shading on it, Those designs for me actually condensed down to a really tiny size in my notebook.

But when it came to be able to explain them to basically any knitter, I went into pages and pages of explanations and diagrams so that they were as approachable as possible.

Now, some knitters really appreciate that, but some don't, and that doesn't work for some people.

And as Patty pointed out, I'm going to quote here from the episode, by trying to merge a knitting class and a pattern, you get a diluted version of each thing.

And that made me think a lot about what I'm trying to do when I do create a design and when I do communicate it.

If you want to make a brilliant knitting pattern for an advanced knitter, actually, what you need to do is maybe present more of the puzzle.

And that's something Zandy Peters talked a lot about, was that you sometimes are creating a puzzle.

Some people, on the other hand, need the encouragement and want to be shown step by step.

And it probably comes down to a bit of a choice by a designer about who they're trying to help the most.

But it is interesting to me as someone experimenting with design about how involved you get in that process of trying to help other people's education.

Now, I've really taken that on board in terms of trying to build my own understanding about what I should be doing to help people.

So it's a design that I struggled with for a couple of months in terms of articulating exactly how I wanted it to be.

It's got 24 different cable stitches used within it and a bunch of other things as well.

and I am halfway through making it, and I have made so many mistakes, which, because it's a sample, I have to go back and correct.

Now, the thing is, as a pattern, I fully intend to release that, hopefully, as a hard pattern.

I'm going to take a step away from what I've done historically, where I try and explain everything to everyone, and this is just something which I'm going to accept is a hard thing to make, and therefore, I want to make it difficult and a puzzle for people to be able to make and i'm really interested to see how that goes i'm interested whether people buy it whether they can make it whether they choose to make it but you know for me this is all experimentation and it's all learning so i'm really interested in the feedback of that now i'm only halfway through it i'm loving it because it's such a challenge but But I can't wait to see how that does get consumed by people as a result.

And there was another piece of information in there which I thought was really interesting from Chantal and Anna, if you've listened to those episodes.

But both of them alluded to this idea that actually you may not even know the mistakes that you're making or may not know the techniques that you want to use.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.