The Jones Act - Its Impact on DownStream with Colin Grabow, Cato Institute

The Jones Act: America's Self-Inflicted Economic Wound In this episode of the Energy Newsbeat Podcast, hosts Stu Turley and David Blackmon sit down with Colin Grabow, Associate Director of the Cato Institute's Herbert A. Stiefel Center for Trade Policy Studies, to examine one of America's most counterintuitive and costly laws: the Jones Act. Enacted in 1920 as the Merchant Marine Act, this legislation requires all goods transported by water within U.S. borders to use American-flagged, American-built, and American-crewed vessels. What was intended as a national security measure has instead become an economic anchor, artificially inflating shipping costs and forcing states to import energy from overseas rather than from nearby domestic sources. With the Trump administration's recent suspension of the Jones Act, Grabow presents compelling data showing that in just six months, more energy has been shipped domestically than in any single year over the past 25 years—a real-world experiment that validates decades of economic arguments against the law. The conversation reveals a troubling paradox: while the U.S. claims the Jones Act protects national security, American ships are regularly sent to Chinese shipyards for repairs, and the law has shrunk the merchant marine fleet from 257 ships in 1980 to just 92 today. Through concrete examples ranging from California's refinery crisis to Puerto Rico's energy shortages, this episode exposes how protectionist policies meant to help American workers and shipyards have instead harmed consumers, reduced economic efficiency, and undermined the very security they claim to protect. Check out the Cato Institute Jones Act Tracker: https://www.cato.org/jones-act-waiver-tracker#key-findings Connect with Colin Grabow on LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/colingrabow/ Check out David Blackmon's work on Substack: https://blackmon.substack.com/ Check out The Energy News Beat Substack: https://theenergynewsbeat.substack.com/ 1\. The Jones Act: Definition & Overview The podcast opens by explaining the Jones Act (Section 27 of the Merchant Marine Act of 1920), which requires that goods transported by water within the U.S. must use vessels that are U.S.-flagged, U.S.-built, at least 75% American-owned, and crewed by Americans. This foundational explanation sets up the entire discussion. 2\. Impact of the Jones Act Waiver on Energy Supply A major focus is the Trump administration's suspension of the Jones Act, which has dramatically increased domestic energy shipments: - California's refinery crisis: With refineries shutting down, the waiver enabled tankers to transport crude oil from Gulf Coast refineries through the Panama Canal to California—preventing a major supply crisis - Record-breaking shipments: In just 6 months, more crude oil, gasoline, and jet fuel were shipped than in any single year over the past 25 years - Cost savings: The waiver has saved consumers millions by enabling efficient domestic shipping 3\. Economic Inefficiency & Cost to Consumers The hosts discuss how the Jones Act artificially inflates shipping costs: - U.S.-built tankers cost $210-240 million vs. $52-53 million in Asia - Operating costs for U.S. ships are $8.5 million more per year than foreign-flagged vessels - This forces states like California and New England to import energy from overseas rather than from nearby U.S. sources 4\. National Security Paradoxes The conversation highlights contradictions in the national security argument: - The U.S. exports LNG globally but can't ship it domestically to states like New York and Massachusetts - Puerto Rico and Hawaii are forced to import energy from foreign sources despite U.S. production capacity - U.S. military builds warships in allied countries (Turkey, Japan, South Korea, Finland), yet commercial ships must be U.S.-built - American ships are regularly sent to Chinese shipyards for repairs and maintenance 5\. Merchant Marine Fleet Decline Colin Grabow presents data showing the Jones Act has failed to maintain a robust U.S. shipping fleet: - The fleet has shrunk from 257 ships in 1980 to just 92 today - U.S. shipyards produce only 2.6 ships per year on average vs. 40+ per year in South Korea - The law hasn't created jobs—it's reduced them 6\. Regional Energy Crises & Solutions The waiver has addressed multiple regional energy shortages: - California: 8+ million barrels of crude, 2.4 million barrels of diesel, 1.8 million barrels of jet fuel - Puerto Rico: Record propane shipments (2.89 million barrels in 6 months vs. historical averages) - New England: LNG and propane imports that were previously impossible - Mid-Atlantic: 12 million barrels of crude shipped to refineries 7\. Political & Lobbying Obstacles The hosts discuss why the Jones Act persists despite its costs: - Concentrated benefits vs. dispersed costs: Shipyard owners and operators lobby heavily to maintain the law, while consumers bear the costs - Congressional gridlock: Previous reform efforts (2006-2007) failed despite support from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and API - State interests: Louisiana opposes changes due to port economy dependence 8\. Hypocrisy & Contradictions The podcast highlights the absurdity of current policy: - Refineries in New York were buying Russian oil because it was cheaper than Texas oil due to Jones Act shipping costs - The U.S. is the world's leading LNG exporter but can't ship it domestically - Companies advocating for the Jones Act for "national security" send their ships to China for repairs 9\. Potential Solutions & Reform Colin Grabow proposes incremental reforms: - Allow Americans to buy foreign-built ships (aligning with policy for airlines and trucking) - Restrict to allied shipyards (NATO countries, Japan, South Korea) - Implement a second registry (like Norway's international registry) - Use direct subsidies instead of protectionism for national security needs 10\. Data-Driven Evidence & Future Research The Cato Institute's Jones Act Waiver Tracker provides concrete evidence: - 241 voyages, 190 unique vessels, 65 million barrels shipped - Plans to update 2018 and 2019 research papers on the Jones Act's economic and national security impacts - The waiver serves as a real-world experiment validating free-market predictions Overall Theme: The podcast argues that the Jones Act is a self-inflicted economic wound that harms consumers, reduces shipping efficiency, contradicts national security claims, and fails to maintain a competitive merchant marine—and that the current waiver proves reform is both necessary and beneficial. At Energy News Beat, we Make Appendices Great Again. Check out the World's Greatest Podcast Show Notes at EnergyNewsBeat.co or EnergyNewsBeat.com, and the Energy News Beat Substack at: https://theenergynewsbeat.substack.com/ A shout-out to Steve Reese and the Reese Energy Consulting group for sponsoring the Podcast https://reeseenergyconsulting.com/. Data2 if you have any business systems, can you trust A? Well, they have the patent on validation. . https://data2.zoholandingpage.com/energy And we have WellDatabase rolling, and we use their tools for the Energy News Beat weekly Rig Reports: https://welldatabase.com/ Also entering Sponsor Rey Trevino, Pecos Operating https://pecos.energy/