Oct 9, 2026 · 18 min · 8 segments
THE DEVIL ON DEATH ROW Episode Three: Twice Condemned For nearly thirty years, Christa Pike waited to die. She entered Tennessee’s death row at nineteen under a sentence of electrocution, but…
Branden MorganHost
A judge pronounces the words, newspapers print them the following morning, and our imagination naturally supplies the execution chamber somewhere just beyond the courthouse door.

Appeals, post-conviction proceedings, federal habeas litigation and challenges to execution procedures can consume decades.

meaning a prisoner may spend more of a lifetime under a death sentence than they ever lived before receiving it.

She was 18 when she murdered Conley Slimmer, 19 when she was sentenced to death, and 50 when Tennessee finally attempted to carry out that sentence.

During those intervening decades, the arguments surrounding her gradually shifted away from whether she had committed the crime she had and toward what the jury had known about the teenager who committed it.

Her post-conviction lawyers assembled a portrait far darker than the one presented during the original penalty phase.

They argued that Krista had endured severe sexual abuse, rape, neglect, and instability while growing up, experiences later connected by clinicians to post-traumatic stress disorder and other psychiatric diagnoses.

Her attorneys contended that trial counsel had failed to investigate and present enough of this mitigating evidence before jurors decided whether she should live or die.

Courts considered those arguments repeatedly without overturning her death sentence, and the state of Tennessee continued to maintain that the punishment imposed for Colleen's torture and murder was lawful.

The United States Supreme Court had prohibited executing people who were under 18 when they committed their crimes, but Krista had crossed that constitutional line by a matter of months.

Her lawyers argued that contemporary knowledge about adolescent brain development made the distinction particularly severe in her case, while Tennessee just answered with the law as it existed.

Pike was legally an adult when she murdered Colleen, and a jury had sentenced her accordingly.

A judge pronounces the words, newspapers print them the following morning, and our imagination naturally supplies the execution chamber somewhere just beyond the courthouse door.

Appeals, post-conviction proceedings, federal habeas litigation and challenges to execution procedures can consume decades.

meaning a prisoner may spend more of a lifetime under a death sentence than they ever lived before receiving it.

She was 18 when she murdered Conley Slimmer, 19 when she was sentenced to death, and 50 when Tennessee finally attempted to carry out that sentence.

During those intervening decades, the arguments surrounding her gradually shifted away from whether she had committed the crime she had and toward what the jury had known about the teenager who committed it.

Her post-conviction lawyers assembled a portrait far darker than the one presented during the original penalty phase.

They argued that Krista had endured severe sexual abuse, rape, neglect, and instability while growing up, experiences later connected by clinicians to post-traumatic stress disorder and other psychiatric diagnoses.

Her attorneys contended that trial counsel had failed to investigate and present enough of this mitigating evidence before jurors decided whether she should live or die.

Courts considered those arguments repeatedly without overturning her death sentence, and the state of Tennessee continued to maintain that the punishment imposed for Colleen's torture and murder was lawful.

The United States Supreme Court had prohibited executing people who were under 18 when they committed their crimes, but Krista had crossed that constitutional line by a matter of months.

Her lawyers argued that contemporary knowledge about adolescent brain development made the distinction particularly severe in her case, while Tennessee just answered with the law as it existed.

Pike was legally an adult when she murdered Colleen, and a jury had sentenced her accordingly.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.