Sep 4, 2026 · 1 hr 52 min · 12 segments
Pat Flynn and Ethan Muse explore the doctrine of divine simplicity, the motivation behind it, and how it can be defended from objections. Time codes…
Ethan MuseGuest
Pat FlynnHost
Anything else you want to say about that? Or should we just get into the actual? I just want to

I mean, to conversations that we've had with our mutual friend, Joe Schmid, you know, but I do want to comment for just for a second on basically this idea of self explanation, right? Or reflexive explanation.

Now, a lot of people don't like that terminology or it grates against their intuition for how explanation should be used.

But I think once we cash it out, basically we'll see first we can give an equivalent formulation of the thought that's being expressed that doesn't require you to say self-explanation if you don't like that or you don't believe in reflexive explanation.

But also there is a real sense in which there's something apt or fitting about the term, you know, when applied to God, which is really just what we're saying here is you can actually, with respect to any entity out in the world that is a particular way, there are particular features of the entity that that you identify that make it cry out for explanation, right? To where there's the demand explanation.

They're explanation demanding features of entities that you can literally identify what they are and the kinds of them that they are.


You can ask why questions about God, right? But the answers to them will be trivial, right? To where leaving them unanswered or just giving circular responses to them will not have...

There will be no explanatory deficit that's left over as a residue when you pose that question, right? And so you see, one thing is...

Being such that you supply an adequate answer to all explanatory questions that are posed about you, you can call that self-explanation if you want, right? Without implying that, like, there's a metaphysical self-dependence, like a self-grounding or something like, you know? Yeah, yeah, yeah, right.

If you use self-explanation in those terms, which is just that you, the intelligible content of your nature, supplies an adequate answer to any conceivable explanatory question that can be posed about you, That is literally negative rather than positive, right? It's negative, which is it's you're lacking all the features that cry out for explanation.

So good, yeah, and I think you can make further progress on this point once you do bring in – and we're not going to bring in the full Thomistic machinery here, but if God just is the fullness of being, there comes a point in this metaphysics where we literally do say that existence exists, and it is God.

There's a great article by Christophe Desraies in Religious Studies defending the paradigm theory of existence where when we're talking about something exists – It's really shorthand for meaning one of two things, because I would talk about existence as such or things participating in existence, being caused to exist, and so on and so forth.

Anything else you want to say about that? Or should we just get into the actual? I just want to

I mean, to conversations that we've had with our mutual friend, Joe Schmid, you know, but I do want to comment for just for a second on basically this idea of self explanation, right? Or reflexive explanation.

Now, a lot of people don't like that terminology or it grates against their intuition for how explanation should be used.

But I think once we cash it out, basically we'll see first we can give an equivalent formulation of the thought that's being expressed that doesn't require you to say self-explanation if you don't like that or you don't believe in reflexive explanation.

But also there is a real sense in which there's something apt or fitting about the term, you know, when applied to God, which is really just what we're saying here is you can actually, with respect to any entity out in the world that is a particular way, there are particular features of the entity that that you identify that make it cry out for explanation, right? To where there's the demand explanation.

They're explanation demanding features of entities that you can literally identify what they are and the kinds of them that they are.


You can ask why questions about God, right? But the answers to them will be trivial, right? To where leaving them unanswered or just giving circular responses to them will not have...

There will be no explanatory deficit that's left over as a residue when you pose that question, right? And so you see, one thing is...

Being such that you supply an adequate answer to all explanatory questions that are posed about you, you can call that self-explanation if you want, right? Without implying that, like, there's a metaphysical self-dependence, like a self-grounding or something like, you know? Yeah, yeah, yeah, right.

If you use self-explanation in those terms, which is just that you, the intelligible content of your nature, supplies an adequate answer to any conceivable explanatory question that can be posed about you, That is literally negative rather than positive, right? It's negative, which is it's you're lacking all the features that cry out for explanation.

So good, yeah, and I think you can make further progress on this point once you do bring in – and we're not going to bring in the full Thomistic machinery here, but if God just is the fullness of being, there comes a point in this metaphysics where we literally do say that existence exists, and it is God.

There's a great article by Christophe Desraies in Religious Studies defending the paradigm theory of existence where when we're talking about something exists – It's really shorthand for meaning one of two things, because I would talk about existence as such or things participating in existence, being caused to exist, and so on and so forth.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.