Jul 28, 2026 · 52 min · 13 segments
In this week’s episode, Maya and Helen discuss the updated version of *Keeping children safe in education* (KCSIE), which places guidance for schools on dealing with trans issues within the statutory…
Um, where this started was, uh, a very small number of children being, uh, treated by doctors and turning up in school and saying, "Doctor says, uh, I can, I can socially transition" and schools, um, sort of going along with what the doctors, what the GIDS said and also, um, local LGBTQ groups coming up with their own guidance on this.
And then, um, the Equality and Human Rights Commission was, uh, given the task of coming up with guidance to schools because what schools were being told and thought was, it's the Equality Act that drives what we should do here because of the protected characteristic of gender reassignment.
So, uh, the Equality and Human Rights Commission, which doesn't know anything about safeguarding explicitly, says, "That's not our mandate", uh, did draft guidance on this in, uh, 2018, 2019, which was leaked and which was really not very good at all.
Um, it was based on the idea that you can, uh, fully socially transition children in school, and even allow them to be, uh, um, admitted into a school, you know, a girls school or a boys school of the wrong sex.
The job was taken over by the Department for Education, and they, uh, put out standalone guidance for gender questioning children for consultation, uh, which was better, but still too long, too complicated.
Uh, it, it asked schools to make what are basically very complex clinical decisions which they're not qualified to do.
Uh, and that then, uh, wasn't completed by the previous government, and then this government obviously took it on and integrated it into the safeguarding guidance, which is a big piece of statutory guidance that schools already, um, respond to each year.
Um, so that in itself is positive that it's, it's inside safeguarding, it's inside this piece of guidance which schools already know what to do with, and it's got safeguarding at the heart of it.
Um, we can talk about the good news and bad news in the guidance, but the clear thing is that schools in England, this is for all kinds of schools, state schools, private schools, uh, colleges as in, uh, sort of up to sixth form, um, will have to take on this guidance, will have to train their teachers, and it will be part of their Ofsted inspections from September.
Um, where this started was, uh, a very small number of children being, uh, treated by doctors and turning up in school and saying, "Doctor says, uh, I can, I can socially transition" and schools, um, sort of going along with what the doctors, what the GIDS said and also, um, local LGBTQ groups coming up with their own guidance on this.
And then, um, the Equality and Human Rights Commission was, uh, given the task of coming up with guidance to schools because what schools were being told and thought was, it's the Equality Act that drives what we should do here because of the protected characteristic of gender reassignment.
So, uh, the Equality and Human Rights Commission, which doesn't know anything about safeguarding explicitly, says, "That's not our mandate", uh, did draft guidance on this in, uh, 2018, 2019, which was leaked and which was really not very good at all.
Um, it was based on the idea that you can, uh, fully socially transition children in school, and even allow them to be, uh, um, admitted into a school, you know, a girls school or a boys school of the wrong sex.
The job was taken over by the Department for Education, and they, uh, put out standalone guidance for gender questioning children for consultation, uh, which was better, but still too long, too complicated.
Uh, it, it asked schools to make what are basically very complex clinical decisions which they're not qualified to do.
Uh, and that then, uh, wasn't completed by the previous government, and then this government obviously took it on and integrated it into the safeguarding guidance, which is a big piece of statutory guidance that schools already, um, respond to each year.
Um, so that in itself is positive that it's, it's inside safeguarding, it's inside this piece of guidance which schools already know what to do with, and it's got safeguarding at the heart of it.
Um, we can talk about the good news and bad news in the guidance, but the clear thing is that schools in England, this is for all kinds of schools, state schools, private schools, uh, colleges as in, uh, sort of up to sixth form, um, will have to take on this guidance, will have to train their teachers, and it will be part of their Ofsted inspections from September.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.