Skip to main content
Maya Forstater

Maya Forstater

Internet personalityWikipedia

Search complete. 16 mentions across 9 episodes found for "Maya Forstater".

Nov 17, 2026

Natalie WynnHOST
5:28
I like hammering things.
Natalie WynnHOST
5:31
The real story begins in December 2019, when Joanne tweeted the hashtag, I stand with Maya, referencing Maya Forstater.
Natalie WynnHOST
5:39
Maya Forstater is an English consultant who lost her contract with the nonprofit she worked for after she did transphobic tweets.
Natalie WynnHOST
5:46
And Maya has been kind enough to compile them all for us in her thread titled, Allegedly Transphobic Tweets.
Natalie WynnHOST
5:53
Wow.
Natalie WynnHOST
8:20
If Joanne had said Maya had been fired for claiming that a person born male could never be a woman and a person born female could never be a man, that would have been more accurate.
Natalie WynnHOST
8:31
But it would also sound contentious and obviously anti-trans.
Natalie WynnHOST
8:35
Sex is real is a euphemism designed to present Maya Forstater's transphobia as a simple statement of fact.
Akua ReindorfGUEST
0:41
After the Cass Report in particular, there is no excuse not to know about it.
Maya ForstaterHOST
0:49
Hello, I'm Maya Forstater, CEO of Sex Matters.
Maya ForstaterHOST
0:53
And today on the pod, I'm delighted to have Akra Reindorf as a guest.
Maya ForstaterHOST
0:58
Akra, many of you will know, is a KC, a barrister at Cloisters.
Savage Minds

Savage Minds

Robert Wintemute

Nov 11 · 1 Mention

Robert WintemuteGUEST
14:01
And that's really when the gender critical movement took off.
Robert WintemuteGUEST
14:06
Maya Forstater tweeted about this and said, well, she didn't really think men can become women.
Robert WintemuteGUEST
14:14
And her coworkers thought this was horribly transphobic complaint and she lost her job.
Robert WintemuteGUEST
14:22
um a year later she lost the first round of her employment tribunal case jk rowling tweeted about it etc and the battle was um was on but um if you go back to stonewall in 2018 they made t-shirts which no longer appear on the website, that said, trans women are women, get over it, and trans men are men, get over it.
Connie ShawHOST
2:39
Also the rights of gay people, gay men and lesbians to freedom of association with people just of the same sex as them.
Connie ShawHOST
2:47
And obviously one of the huge things that led up to Maya Forstater, your colleague and CEO of Sex Matters, setting up the organisation.
Connie ShawHOST
2:54
was the fact that she had won her employment tribunal case that meant that gender critical beliefs the belief that sex is binary and that there's only two and you can't change it is a belief that's protected under the equality act now when it comes to the conversion practices bill there are concerns that this bill will undo all of that progress what do you think that's
Helen JoyceGUEST
3:17
absolutely
Helen JoyceGUEST
62:55
So we have been bolstering and fighting back in various ways.
Helen JoyceGUEST
63:00
I think the headline ones would be Forstater, my colleague Maya Forstater, the precedent setting ruling that you can talk about the fact that there are two sexes and sex can't change and you will not be allowed to lose your job for that.
Helen JoyceGUEST
63:13
That's vital.
Helen JoyceGUEST
63:14
Then the next big one was, of course, for Women's Scotland.

6 MINS LATER

Helen JoyceGUEST
68:54
And that will mean not saying to that girl, she's not non-binary, not saying to her, that she's actually female.
Helen JoyceGUEST
69:00
They've won everything.
Helen JoyceGUEST
69:01
They've overturned Forstater.
Helen JoyceGUEST
69:03
They've overturned For Women Scotland because that's not actually about families.
Tanya de GrunwaldHOST
16:14
They have also been talking to the employees who are affected by the fact that they're changing their policies or clarifying things.
Tanya de GrunwaldHOST
16:24
So one of the things that Neil Morrison, the HR director, said to me on an original call with Maya Forstater back in, I think it was May 2025, was that you would have to speak to the trans-identifying people who are directly impacted by you correcting whatever you've been doing if you've been getting it wrong.
Neil MorrisonSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
16:44
You know, on a topic like this, you've got to think about everyone and how you make everyone feel safe rather than just particular groups.
Tanya de GrunwaldHOST
16:54
And you would just deal with individual people with actual concerns about, say, for example, which facilities they're going to use, you deal with them individually, would you, rather than sort of in a group?
Jo PhoenixGUEST
49:45
Met all these amazing people.
Jo PhoenixGUEST
49:47
I met Maya Forstater at that point.
Jo PhoenixGUEST
49:49
Well, I met her from afar.
Jo BrewHOST
49:51
And Alice Sullivan was there, I guess.

8 MINS LATER

Jo PhoenixGUEST
57:23
Um, you know, and, uh, And then I had the idea of actually listing every single gender critical employment tribunal, judicial review, high court review since 2021 that I could find.
Jo PhoenixGUEST
57:41
So we start the book with me going, yeah, I don't know if I'd ever do it again.
Jo PhoenixGUEST
57:48
But then there's people like J.K. Rowling and Alison Bailey and Maya Forstater.
Jo PhoenixGUEST
57:52
And then there is literally 30 pages of summarising all the gender-critical employment tribunals, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
Zoe HollowoodGUEST
24:42
And they overturned it and they overturned it brilliantly with a really, really liberal piece saying, you know, liberals shouldn't be in there, should not be in the business of policing people's thoughts or their beliefs or, you know, their freedom of expression on perfectly lawful views.
Zoe HollowoodGUEST
24:57
Because Forstater had happened by this point.
Zoe HollowoodGUEST
25:01
So unfortunately, that senior adjudicator was removed from her post because clearly the trans activists who were controlling the complaint system were very unhappy that they had such a liberal who wanted to obey the law.
Zoe HollowoodGUEST
25:13
So what
Zoe HollowoodGUEST
25:42
So it made the discussion within the Lib Dems really, really hard because people could instantly say, you've broken the code of conduct, you've broken the definition of transphobia, I'm going to the complaints.
Zoe HollowoodGUEST
25:54
And there were women who were facing complaints over two years old because the complaint system just didn't know how to deal with the appeals.
Zoe HollowoodGUEST
26:03
They knew after Forstater that they couldn't keep expelling people, but no one really wanted to make the decision.
Zoe HollowoodGUEST
26:12
So you just had this massive chilling effect.
Neale HanveyGUEST
15:45
But the effect of this legislation, if it came into law, would be to roll back every success that we've had resisting this legislation completely.
Neale HanveyGUEST
15:56
And that's from the Forstater judgment right through to the For Women Scotland victory in the UK Supreme Court.
Neale HanveyGUEST
16:03
None of that would matter because the scope of this legislation is deliberately drafted in such a broad way that it will capture any Now that could mean, I think somebody joked to me before we came on stage, that could mean the raising of an eyebrow.
Neale HanveyGUEST
16:19
But it really, you know, it's very difficult to know what would be in scope and what wouldn't be in scope.
Neale HanveyGUEST
17:23
It doesn't always work, Neil.
Neale HanveyGUEST
17:26
So, you know, but there will be the possible outcome that children will use this as a weapon against their parents to push boundaries with catastrophic effects.
Neale HanveyGUEST
17:39
Now, in terms of the wins to date, we know that gender critical views after Forstater is a protected belief.
Neale HanveyGUEST
17:51
What this bill risks changing or inflicting on that belief is it's not that you are not allowed to hold that belief, it's how you manifest it.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.