Jul 15, 2026 · 27 min · 12 segments
9 Days, When is a Siyum Appropriate
Eliezer GewirtzmanHostSo the Shulchan Aruch then continues in Sif Yud, "Yesh misha'omeish aanagim sh'eilecha basar beyamim ha'nezikim uchalin b'tav shul sh'nistas uva'am basar." That the Mechaber says that if-- according to, to the sheet this, that hold that it's asur, which according to Sefardim on a year like this is already, they actually have a Shavuot Shechal B'Tishri B'av almost as long as us.
And us that do it for Rosh Chodesh, the halacha is they, they, that, uh, that it's, it's mutar to eat at hav shul sh'nistas uva'am basar.
Meaning, if you have a food that had meat cooked in it, but you're not actually eating the meat, we'll get back to this.
V'asurim b'basar oif, that I'll not eat chicken, u'basar m'luach, and you're not allowed to eat salted meat.
So what we're saying over here is that not only is there an isur on the meat, but there's an isur on chicken.
In case you wanna know why you're not happy, it takes more than three days to get the meat to your plate.
But our kapaim stating over here that afar pike, when it comes to the nine days, even that kind of meat and chicken is all asur.
The Mishnah Berurah though does point out that if let's say you have an adam chorev who can't eat milk, or an isha meneikes who finds it hard for a child to-- who can't eat milk because let's say her child is allergic to milk, and through her drinking milk it affects the child.
But she'ete Mishnah Berurah, and this is the point that I'm bringing out, is that he should avoid not eating real meat.
In other words, such a woman is better off eating chicken than eating meat.
Meaning so although we put all of them in the same darga of isur, but when it comes to a time where we have a shas atrakh, we have to realize that there are things that are more asur and less asur, and therefore be'etzem she should be eating chicken as opposed to real meat.
So the Shulchan Aruch then continues in Sif Yud, "Yesh misha'omeish aanagim sh'eilecha basar beyamim ha'nezikim uchalin b'tav shul sh'nistas uva'am basar." That the Mechaber says that if-- according to, to the sheet this, that hold that it's asur, which according to Sefardim on a year like this is already, they actually have a Shavuot Shechal B'Tishri B'av almost as long as us.
And us that do it for Rosh Chodesh, the halacha is they, they, that, uh, that it's, it's mutar to eat at hav shul sh'nistas uva'am basar.
Meaning, if you have a food that had meat cooked in it, but you're not actually eating the meat, we'll get back to this.
V'asurim b'basar oif, that I'll not eat chicken, u'basar m'luach, and you're not allowed to eat salted meat.
So what we're saying over here is that not only is there an isur on the meat, but there's an isur on chicken.
In case you wanna know why you're not happy, it takes more than three days to get the meat to your plate.
But our kapaim stating over here that afar pike, when it comes to the nine days, even that kind of meat and chicken is all asur.
The Mishnah Berurah though does point out that if let's say you have an adam chorev who can't eat milk, or an isha meneikes who finds it hard for a child to-- who can't eat milk because let's say her child is allergic to milk, and through her drinking milk it affects the child.
But she'ete Mishnah Berurah, and this is the point that I'm bringing out, is that he should avoid not eating real meat.
In other words, such a woman is better off eating chicken than eating meat.
Meaning so although we put all of them in the same darga of isur, but when it comes to a time where we have a shas atrakh, we have to realize that there are things that are more asur and less asur, and therefore be'etzem she should be eating chicken as opposed to real meat.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.