Listener sentiment
Listeners overwhelmingly praise Messed Up Movies (formerly the Film Alchemist) for its deep, accessible film analysis and the natural, bar-conversation chemistry between hosts Josh Griffey and Alex Dandino. Reviewers consistently highlight the show's balance of genuine insight and humor, its wide-ranging film selection from mainstream hits to obscure cult gems, and its themed programming like the annual 31 Days of Horror marathon. Many describe it as the rare movie podcast that feels like hanging out with knowledgeable, passionate friends. A recurring criticism in more recent reviews, however, centers on one host's tendency to talk over co-hosts and guests, shout, and dominate conversations — a pattern flagged independently by multiple listeners who otherwise enjoy the content. A smaller but notable contingent of recent reviewers also expresses frustration with political commentary bleeding into movie discussions, wishing the hosts would stay on topic. These critiques, concentrated in the last year or two, mark a slight shift from the near-universal acclaim the show enjoyed in its earlier years, though the majority of recent ratings remain enthusiastic.
Apple4.7 · 78
Summary generated Aug 22, 2026
