Oct 15, 2026 · 34 min · 12 segments
How can educators distinguish expected language differences from signs of a language disorder? In this episode, Dr. Ellen Kester explores how contrastive analysis helps teachers understand the…
Are you able to walk us through an example of how a teacher's understanding of a student's home language system might affect the instructional decisions that a teacher makes when they're trying to help a student learn how to read?
There is a Z letter, so it's there orthographically, but there's no phoneme that is za.
So a child is going through and reading, and they say, "Su." So it's a teaching opportunity where we can talk about the difference between an S and a Z, and that in English, we put voice on that sound.
We can use it that way and certainly not penalize students, and I think that's, that's one of the most important things for us to think about, is that we don't wanna say right or wrong, right? Uh, when we're looking at what a child produces, and I think that this has been so problematic for our bilingual, multilingual children, is that- Kids are penalized for errors that make complete sense given their home language.
And so I, I would love to see teachers really take this strength-based perspective and say, "Oh, yes, they're doing this, but that's okay.
That's showing me that they're using their home language system in this learning of English." So I think that that's the approach that we need to take, is really looking at those patterns and being sure that we are not penalizing our students for those.
I appreciate you highlighting that alongside building our knowledge on how language systems are similar or different, we also really need to carry an assets-based lens.
So as teachers are working with their students, what are some common language differences you see in multilingual classrooms, ones that may get labeled as errors but are actually typical and expected for our students who are multilingual?
So we might see a child change the word order or use flexible word order when using English.
Are you able to walk us through an example of how a teacher's understanding of a student's home language system might affect the instructional decisions that a teacher makes when they're trying to help a student learn how to read?
There is a Z letter, so it's there orthographically, but there's no phoneme that is za.
So a child is going through and reading, and they say, "Su." So it's a teaching opportunity where we can talk about the difference between an S and a Z, and that in English, we put voice on that sound.
We can use it that way and certainly not penalize students, and I think that's, that's one of the most important things for us to think about, is that we don't wanna say right or wrong, right? Uh, when we're looking at what a child produces, and I think that this has been so problematic for our bilingual, multilingual children, is that- Kids are penalized for errors that make complete sense given their home language.
And so I, I would love to see teachers really take this strength-based perspective and say, "Oh, yes, they're doing this, but that's okay.
That's showing me that they're using their home language system in this learning of English." So I think that that's the approach that we need to take, is really looking at those patterns and being sure that we are not penalizing our students for those.
I appreciate you highlighting that alongside building our knowledge on how language systems are similar or different, we also really need to carry an assets-based lens.
So as teachers are working with their students, what are some common language differences you see in multilingual classrooms, ones that may get labeled as errors but are actually typical and expected for our students who are multilingual?
So we might see a child change the word order or use flexible word order when using English.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.