Listener sentiment
Listener sentiment for "It's A Mimic!" is overwhelmingly positive, with reviewers consistently praising the three hosts' deep tabletop RPG knowledge, natural chemistry, and irreverent humor that makes each episode feel like eavesdropping on a conversation among friends. The podcast is repeatedly singled out as an invaluable resource for new and experienced Dungeon Masters alike, with particular appreciation for its monster breakdowns, campaign-building guidance, and practical "how to use this in your game" advice. Several listeners note that the show helped them level up their DMing skills and even inspired their players to try running games themselves. The hosts' willingness to branch beyond D&D — notably into Legend of the Five Rings — has also drawn gratitude from niche RPG audiences starved for content. The lone critical review, posted in late 2024, expresses disappointment with a perceived shift in tone and cast changes (including a co-host departure and a new addition the reviewer felt lacked relevant experience), contending the show's quality declined after its first year. That criticism stands as an outlier, however, against a backdrop of sustained enthusiasm; the most recent review, from late 2025, remains positive.
Apple4.9 · 19
Summary generated Jul 22, 2026
