Halloween Pop-up Channel - Powered by "Ghost - Scary Stories"
Oct 2, 2026 · 19 min · 8 segments
Claire drives to Sarah Mitchell's hometown and meets her mother, Margaret—a woman who has spent forty years knowing her daughter was murdered and unable to prove it. She learns that Sarah had a…
I didn't confront my father that night.
I should have.
I should have demanded answers, called the police, done something righteous and correct.
But I sat in that office long after he shuffled back to bed, surrounded by evidence of a murder that had happened before I was old enough to remember, and I couldn't make myself move.
My father was a killer.
Not alone.
There had been six of them.
Six men who'd made a decision in a moment of panic and spent the rest of their lives paying for it.
But he was part of it.
He'd kept Sarah in that basement.
He'd been there when she died.
He'd helped bury her in the backyard, in a grave so shallow that nothing would grow above it.
And someone had been hunting them ever since.
I stayed awake until dawn, reading and re-reading Sarah's diary, studying the newspaper clippings, trying to construct a timeline that made sense.
The deaths had started in 1992, five years after Sarah disappeared.
Bill Thornton, the hunting accident.
Then nothing for six years until Tom Sheffield burned in the warehouse fire.
Then Richard in the river, Marcus in his home, Peter beaten to death.
Twenty-seven years, five deaths.
Each one spaced years apart, long enough for the fear to fade, long enough for the survivors to convince themselves it was over.
It was never over.
When the sun came up, I made a decision.
I needed to know more about Sarah Mitchell.
I needed to understand who she was, where she came from, whether she had family who might still be looking for her, whether she had family who might be capable of this.
I didn't confront my father that night.
I should have.
I should have demanded answers, called the police, done something righteous and correct.
But I sat in that office long after he shuffled back to bed, surrounded by evidence of a murder that had happened before I was old enough to remember, and I couldn't make myself move.
My father was a killer.
Not alone.
There had been six of them.
Six men who'd made a decision in a moment of panic and spent the rest of their lives paying for it.
But he was part of it.
He'd kept Sarah in that basement.
He'd been there when she died.
He'd helped bury her in the backyard, in a grave so shallow that nothing would grow above it.
And someone had been hunting them ever since.
I stayed awake until dawn, reading and re-reading Sarah's diary, studying the newspaper clippings, trying to construct a timeline that made sense.
The deaths had started in 1992, five years after Sarah disappeared.
Bill Thornton, the hunting accident.
Then nothing for six years until Tom Sheffield burned in the warehouse fire.
Then Richard in the river, Marcus in his home, Peter beaten to death.
Twenty-seven years, five deaths.
Each one spaced years apart, long enough for the fear to fade, long enough for the survivors to convince themselves it was over.
It was never over.
When the sun came up, I made a decision.
I needed to know more about Sarah Mitchell.
I needed to understand who she was, where she came from, whether she had family who might still be looking for her, whether she had family who might be capable of this.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.