Sep 11, 2026 · 23 min · 6 segments
Sherman “Tiger” Joyce, President of the American Tort Reform Association, discusses the rise of “regulation by litigation,” how policy should be developed and enacted by elected lawmakers and not…
Renee GiacchinoHost
So August, which we just finished, is typically a very quiet time in Washington, D.C.
We generally have a lot of businesses and other operations, things quiet a little bit, people going on vacations and so forth, and it just seemed like we didn't really have that letdown, which is good in some ways, but I think some of the activity level is just so high and the matters and priorities that we are looking to pursue are very active.
And I think the challenges are quite significant and a lot going on in the world of litigation and litigation reform.

Your organization is the nation's first organization exclusively dedicated to reforming the civil justice system.

But we have seen over the last couple of years, maybe even decade or so, and it's something I know that you guys also follow very, very closely and are very engaged in, and that is that we are seeing... legislation by regulation, if that's a fair way to classify it.
And if I were to correct anything, I would say it goes back even a little further.
I think probably the first prime example of this, Renee, was when the states settled litigation against the tobacco industry in the late 1990s.
And I think when you look at what the states did and what the litigation accomplished, it's pretty safe to say that it all could and from our perspective, should have been accomplished if it were to be accomplished by elected officials who are responsible to all of us.
But instead, you have this sweeping reform and change that was made through the court system using legal theories.
And from our standpoint, we are of the view, I should say my organization is of the view, that the courts exist to resolve disputes and to resolve constitutional questions.
And when you go back to the reading of the work of the framers, the courts were meant to be kind of the least invasive of the branches of government.
They are, especially looking at the federal judges, they're appointed for life so that they can make the hard decisions on what the law does or doesn't provide.
But I think when you see whether it's the tobacco litigation going back into the late 1990s or now, you're seeing the litigation involving social media companies.
We look at this and think, OK, well, you're talking about broader public policy.
You're talking about, you know, obviously a vibrant and important part of our economy.

So August, which we just finished, is typically a very quiet time in Washington, D.C.
We generally have a lot of businesses and other operations, things quiet a little bit, people going on vacations and so forth, and it just seemed like we didn't really have that letdown, which is good in some ways, but I think some of the activity level is just so high and the matters and priorities that we are looking to pursue are very active.
And I think the challenges are quite significant and a lot going on in the world of litigation and litigation reform.

Your organization is the nation's first organization exclusively dedicated to reforming the civil justice system.

But we have seen over the last couple of years, maybe even decade or so, and it's something I know that you guys also follow very, very closely and are very engaged in, and that is that we are seeing... legislation by regulation, if that's a fair way to classify it.
And if I were to correct anything, I would say it goes back even a little further.
I think probably the first prime example of this, Renee, was when the states settled litigation against the tobacco industry in the late 1990s.
And I think when you look at what the states did and what the litigation accomplished, it's pretty safe to say that it all could and from our perspective, should have been accomplished if it were to be accomplished by elected officials who are responsible to all of us.
But instead, you have this sweeping reform and change that was made through the court system using legal theories.
And from our standpoint, we are of the view, I should say my organization is of the view, that the courts exist to resolve disputes and to resolve constitutional questions.
And when you go back to the reading of the work of the framers, the courts were meant to be kind of the least invasive of the branches of government.
They are, especially looking at the federal judges, they're appointed for life so that they can make the hard decisions on what the law does or doesn't provide.
But I think when you see whether it's the tobacco litigation going back into the late 1990s or now, you're seeing the litigation involving social media companies.
We look at this and think, OK, well, you're talking about broader public policy.
You're talking about, you know, obviously a vibrant and important part of our economy.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.