Economic Club of Canada | Where the Economy Comes Together
Sep 17, 2026 · 50 min · 12 segments
On September 16, the Economic Club of Canada hosted Advancing Women’s Mental Health, featuring Dr. Ariel Dalfen (BRIA), Sarah Downey (CAMH), Amii Stephenson (Maple), and Dr. Simone Vigod (University…
Sarah DowneyGuestAriel DalfenGuestAmii StephensonGuestStephanie GadwaHostI'm going to start off the conversation, if I may, with... kind of taking a look at the current state of women's mental health.
And maybe I will start with putting a question to our doctors on the panel today.
I'm wondering if you, maybe I'll get you to start, Dr. Dawson.
What are some of the most pressing issues today in women's mental health? Do we have all afternoon?
In all seriousness, I'll start by naming a few that I think are quite prominent.
Just as a little bit of background, when we think about any mental health issue as psychiatrists, we use a model called the biopsychosocial model.
model to understand biological factors that are contributing, psychological, like internal ways of thinking, mindset, and then social factors.
And I think it's easiest to understand mental health problems from that lens and means that mental health issues are quite complicated.
So if I name a few things that are quite pressing, I think about different mental health problems across the different life stages.
So focusing on people going through their menstrual cycles and having mental health and hormone changes, going through fertility and pregnancy and postpartum and menopause, when hormones and life changes and stressors all come together at once.
That's a big problem and a big under-treated, under-understood area in many ways.
And then we look at broader issues like trauma, gender-based violence, still very big, pressing issues that contribute to mental health issues.
And then things like what we were just talking about at the table, like caregiver burnout, caregiver parenting, caring for aging parents, That type of stress, those are quite pressing issues.
And there are probably many, many more, but I'll leave it to some of my colleagues to pick that up.
Dr. Dugard, I'm wondering if you wanted to jump in there in terms of the most pressing issues for women's mental health.
Sure, and I think about it in a similar frame to Ariel in the sense that from the time when women get their periods to the time when they go through menopause, certain conditions like mood disorders and anxiety disorders are actually twice as common as they are in men.
So there are things that are different by sex and gender across the lifespan with respect to what kinds of things people are affected by.
but also the way you metabolize drugs if you have a female body versus a male body.
Things may go through slower, you may not need as high doses, that sort of thing.
So you've got these things that are different by gender across lifespan, and then of course, as Ariel said, you've got the things that are maybe unique for people who have female biologics, like around the time of menstrual cycle, pregnancy, and the perimenopause.
But, you know, you've probably heard this before in other contexts, but when I think about women's mental health and I think about the research that, you know, that's been done, is most of the work, you know, traditionally when you're trying to see it as a medication work or something, Well, if it was done in a man or like a 180-pound man, right, like it might not work the same in a woman.
And then when we see things like, oh, women get more side effects from medications that you use for mental health, and then you think to yourself, well, wait a minute, nobody's ever tested to see if maybe that's not the right dose or that's not the best medication biologically.
And one of the things we were talking about when we were planning for this panel was that it was not until 1993 that the Food and Drug Administration and the US government mandated that sex and gender be looked at and women be included in clinical trials.
I'm going to start off the conversation, if I may, with... kind of taking a look at the current state of women's mental health.
And maybe I will start with putting a question to our doctors on the panel today.
I'm wondering if you, maybe I'll get you to start, Dr. Dawson.
What are some of the most pressing issues today in women's mental health? Do we have all afternoon?
In all seriousness, I'll start by naming a few that I think are quite prominent.
Just as a little bit of background, when we think about any mental health issue as psychiatrists, we use a model called the biopsychosocial model.
model to understand biological factors that are contributing, psychological, like internal ways of thinking, mindset, and then social factors.
And I think it's easiest to understand mental health problems from that lens and means that mental health issues are quite complicated.
So if I name a few things that are quite pressing, I think about different mental health problems across the different life stages.
So focusing on people going through their menstrual cycles and having mental health and hormone changes, going through fertility and pregnancy and postpartum and menopause, when hormones and life changes and stressors all come together at once.
That's a big problem and a big under-treated, under-understood area in many ways.
And then we look at broader issues like trauma, gender-based violence, still very big, pressing issues that contribute to mental health issues.
And then things like what we were just talking about at the table, like caregiver burnout, caregiver parenting, caring for aging parents, That type of stress, those are quite pressing issues.
And there are probably many, many more, but I'll leave it to some of my colleagues to pick that up.
Dr. Dugard, I'm wondering if you wanted to jump in there in terms of the most pressing issues for women's mental health.
Sure, and I think about it in a similar frame to Ariel in the sense that from the time when women get their periods to the time when they go through menopause, certain conditions like mood disorders and anxiety disorders are actually twice as common as they are in men.
So there are things that are different by sex and gender across the lifespan with respect to what kinds of things people are affected by.
but also the way you metabolize drugs if you have a female body versus a male body.
Things may go through slower, you may not need as high doses, that sort of thing.
So you've got these things that are different by gender across lifespan, and then of course, as Ariel said, you've got the things that are maybe unique for people who have female biologics, like around the time of menstrual cycle, pregnancy, and the perimenopause.
But, you know, you've probably heard this before in other contexts, but when I think about women's mental health and I think about the research that, you know, that's been done, is most of the work, you know, traditionally when you're trying to see it as a medication work or something, Well, if it was done in a man or like a 180-pound man, right, like it might not work the same in a woman.
And then when we see things like, oh, women get more side effects from medications that you use for mental health, and then you think to yourself, well, wait a minute, nobody's ever tested to see if maybe that's not the right dose or that's not the best medication biologically.
And one of the things we were talking about when we were planning for this panel was that it was not until 1993 that the Food and Drug Administration and the US government mandated that sex and gender be looked at and women be included in clinical trials.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.