Listener sentiment
Recent listener sentiment on Crime Scene is genuinely mixed, with the divide largely tracking whether reviewers enjoy the two-host conversational format or find it gets in the way of the storytelling. Enthusiastic fans praise the show's deep research, compelling case selection, and binge-worthy production, crediting hosts Jonathan Hirsch and Cooper Moll with a professional balance of personality and respect for victims. A substantial contingent, however, is frustrated by the back-and-forth banter, describing it as forced, filler-heavy, and at times callous in tone given the seriousness of the crimes covered; several reviewers feel the co-host contributes little beyond chiming in with reactions. Audio production is a recurring, independent complaint — listeners consistently report that host dialogue is too quiet while ad breaks are jarringly loud, and a distracting background tapping noise has surfaced in the most recent episodes. Ad frequency and abrupt mid-sentence placements also draw repeated criticism. The show clearly has a loyal audience that finds it addictive and well-crafted, but the format and production issues are costing it goodwill among true-crime listeners who want tighter, more focused reporting.
Apple3.5 · 416
Summary generated Jul 8, 2026
