Listener sentiment
Listener sentiment on Crime Scene remains deeply divided, with the most recent reviews continuing a critical drift that the prior summary already flagged. The most persistent complaint — Cooper Moll's habitual "Right?" verbal filler — surfaces again across multiple recent ratings, with several listeners saying it undermines the hosts' credibility and makes episodes hard to finish. A newer thread has emerged around name pronunciation: a recent episode's repeated mispronunciation of victim Jodi Huisentruit's last name drew sharp criticism, though at least one reviewer appreciated the hosts issuing a corrected version promptly. Broader frustrations with the dual-host conversational format persist — Jonathan Hirsch is called out for restating Cooper's points, plugging his other shows mid-episode, and speaking in a halting, self-serious cadence — while seasoned true-crime fans continue to find the case coverage too shallow for anyone already familiar with the genre. Audio production issues (host dialogue too quiet, ads jarringly loud) and ad frequency remain recurring grievances. On the positive side, a loyal audience still finds the show bingeable, praising the case selection, research, and the hosts' professional yet personable balance — suggesting the divide continues to track tolerance for the chatty two-host approach rather than the underlying reporting quality.
Apple3.4 · 427
Summary generated Sep 5, 2026
