616 | How Should You Give Money to Your Kids? | 529s, UTMAs, Trump Accounts & More

Most parents rush to open 529 plans for newborns, convinced they're building their child's future. But here's what financial experts won't tell you: that decision might be destroying more value than it creates. The accounts marketed most aggressively to new parents often provide minimal benefit while eliminating the flexibility you'll actually need. ## Topics Discussed **Introduction and Episode Framework** (00:00:00) Brad Barrett sets the stage with Sean Mullaney and Cody Garrett for a discussion on gifting to children, account options, and the critical importance of maintaining optionality in financial planning. **Motivations for Saving for Children** (00:03:15) Cody Garrett presents ChooseFI community research revealing four primary motivations: giving children more options, helping them avoid debt struggles, protecting from hardship, and developing healthy money habits. **Parental Financial Sufficiency First** (00:10:30) The oxygen mask principle—parents must secure their own financial stability before transferring wealth to children. Parental financial instability creates burden for adult children. **Three Objections to Early Transfers** (00:15:45) Sean Mullaney outlines three major objections: profile mismatch between parent and child needs, destruction of option value, and the superiority of the step-up in basis alternative at death. **Gift Tax and Estate Tax Framework** (00:22:00) Discussion of the annual gift tax exclusion ($19,000 per recipient), lifetime exclusion ($15 million), and how the step-up in basis works to eliminate capital gains tax at death. **529 Plans Deep Dive** (00:28:30) Cody Garrett explains 529 mechanics, qualified expenses, restricted use, and flexibility options. Sean Mullaney identifies optimal profiles: financially successful parents of teens, grandparents, or state tax benefit scenarios. **Trump Accounts Overview** (00:42:15) Sean Mullaney details the new Trump accounts: $1,000 government seed for 2025-2028 births, $5,000 annual contribution limit, domestic equity index requirement, and conversion to traditional IRA at age 18. **UTMA/UGMA Custodial Accounts** (00:52:00) Cody Garrett explains custodial brokerage accounts, the kiddie tax, asset transfer at age of majority, and alternative strategies using parent-owned accounts with identifiers for tracking. **Custodial Roth IRAs and Earned Income** (01:02:30) Discussion of Roth IRA contributions for children with earned income, the importance of legitimate work arrangements, and FAFSA implications of Roth withdrawals. **Summary and Order of Operations** (01:08:45) Cody Garrett summarizes the proper order: understand motivations first, assess sufficiency second, then explore mechanics. Start with the assumption of 'no' rather than optimizing toward 'yes.' ## Notable Quotes "The greatest financial gift you can give your child is your own financial stability." — Sean Mullaney "We don't want the product to lead the plan." — Cody Garrett "The best tax planning is both free and inevitable - the step up in basis at death." — Sean Mullaney "Minor children have no need for financial assets and can't even use them. My toddler goddaughter can't go to the grocery store and buy groceries with one thousand dollars." — Sean Mullaney "If you can have more options, you would always rather that than fewer, especially if the option that got you fewer options didn't really give you any significant benefit." — Brad Barrett ## Key Takeaways - Assess your own financial sufficiency before considering any transfers to children—ensure your retirement is fully funded and you won't become a burden to adult children - If you have a child born between 2025-2028, open a Trump account to claim the $1,000 government seed contribution, even if you don't plan to fund it further - For children age 18+, verify account ownership transfer procedures at your brokerage if you hold UTMA/UGMA accounts—set up new logins and transfer procedures - Consider using parent-owned taxable brokerage accounts with naming identifiers (e.g., 'Child's Name Account') rather than custodial accounts to maintain flexibility and control - If residing in states with 529 deduction benefits (like South Carolina's unlimited deduction), evaluate a flow-through strategy: contribute to 529 in summer, withdraw for education expenses in fall - Review FAFSA implications before opening any child-owned accounts—child assets are assessed at 20% vs parent assets at 5.64% for financial aid calculations - For teenagers with earned income, consider funding their Roth IRA only if your family is already financially successful—don't create artificial employment arrangements solely for tax benefits ## Resources and Links Tax Planning to and Through Early Retirement by Sean Mullaney and Cody Garrett Trump Accounts Official Information FI Tax Guy - Sean Mullaney's blog Cody Garrett LinkedIn Profile * * * **Support the Show** We work hard to keep ChooseFI ad-free for a clean listening experience. The easiest way to support us is to use our Top Recommended Cards page when signing up for your next travel rewards credit card.