Aug 13, 2026 · 14 min · 5 segments
NYC therapist and host of boy meets therapy podcast Dustin answers questions from viewers submitted via Instagram. This week, we look at the romanticization of someone who doesn't feel the same way…
Dustin OliverHost
So here's the first question: How do I stop romanticizing someone who told me he doesn't feel the same way? Okay, so what-- This is-- First of all, I'm sorry that he doesn't feel the same way.

And I think it's particularly frustrating as a gay person because I think so often it's, like, har- or it's, like, even rare for us to find someone that we really like, and we're like, "Hey, I actually really like this guy." Um, and I feel like there's always something going on, right? It's always like, "Well, he doesn't like me back," or it's always, "The guy that likes me, I'm not into him." I feel like there's always these little kooky situations that happen, and so I wanna acknowledge and say I'm sorry.

Turning on my therapy brain, though this is not a therapy session, uh, I want to know, like, romanticizing, he doesn't feel the same way.

One of the things that I would be curious about is what you are romanticizing about him.

Is it the idea of a future with him? Is it the idea of a relationship? Is it the idea of a sex life? Is it the idea of partnership or companionship with him? What is going on? Obviously, I'm assuming this is a romantic context, uh, because literally the question implies that.

But what exactly? Like, what exactly were we romanticizing about the relationship? What was it that really got me thinking, "Huh, I'm really into this guy, and now I'm romanticizing"? What is the object of the romanticization? Is it, uh, holidays together? Is it living together? Is it doing fun things together, or is it just having a companion in general? Is it being in a relationship? Because sometimes I feel like you can find that if we separate the individual from the romanticization, the romanticization is still there.

So this person is just filling in this space for these needs that we have of companionship, of, you know...

I see-- Actually, I was on the subway the other day, and I saw this cute little, these cute gay couple, and I was like, I, I did, I didn't get jealous of them, but I definitely was like, "That's so cute." And I definitely was like, "Oh, I wanna..." This-- So they were both on the subway, and one of the guys just put his hand on the other guy's thigh, and they were just kind of lightly talking, and it was so fucking cute.

And I remember thinking, "I want some guy's hand on my thigh right now that I like and blah, blah, blah." Anyway, so my mind kind of went there.

So I was kind of, like, romanticizing their relationship without knowing anything about them.

So when it comes to this individual that you're romanticizing, I wanna know what about them you're romanticizing.

Also, I'm interested in this as well because plenty of times we have crushes on people that don't like us back.

Sometimes I hear from people that when a crush likes them back, they lose interest.

And so I'm kinda curious about- I don't know any of your relational patterns or anything else, but one of the thing that was kind of-- one of the things that was sticking out to me in my head was, what is your relationship with being liked in the past and liking other people? What is reciprocation like for you? Are you-- Like, is that something that you're, that you're turned on by? Is that something that you're comfortable with? When I say comfortable with, I mean, sometimes people, they really, once they a- achieve the affection of people, they're like, "Oh, well, now I have it.

So here's the first question: How do I stop romanticizing someone who told me he doesn't feel the same way? Okay, so what-- This is-- First of all, I'm sorry that he doesn't feel the same way.

And I think it's particularly frustrating as a gay person because I think so often it's, like, har- or it's, like, even rare for us to find someone that we really like, and we're like, "Hey, I actually really like this guy." Um, and I feel like there's always something going on, right? It's always like, "Well, he doesn't like me back," or it's always, "The guy that likes me, I'm not into him." I feel like there's always these little kooky situations that happen, and so I wanna acknowledge and say I'm sorry.

Turning on my therapy brain, though this is not a therapy session, uh, I want to know, like, romanticizing, he doesn't feel the same way.

One of the things that I would be curious about is what you are romanticizing about him.

Is it the idea of a future with him? Is it the idea of a relationship? Is it the idea of a sex life? Is it the idea of partnership or companionship with him? What is going on? Obviously, I'm assuming this is a romantic context, uh, because literally the question implies that.

But what exactly? Like, what exactly were we romanticizing about the relationship? What was it that really got me thinking, "Huh, I'm really into this guy, and now I'm romanticizing"? What is the object of the romanticization? Is it, uh, holidays together? Is it living together? Is it doing fun things together, or is it just having a companion in general? Is it being in a relationship? Because sometimes I feel like you can find that if we separate the individual from the romanticization, the romanticization is still there.

So this person is just filling in this space for these needs that we have of companionship, of, you know...

I see-- Actually, I was on the subway the other day, and I saw this cute little, these cute gay couple, and I was like, I, I did, I didn't get jealous of them, but I definitely was like, "That's so cute." And I definitely was like, "Oh, I wanna..." This-- So they were both on the subway, and one of the guys just put his hand on the other guy's thigh, and they were just kind of lightly talking, and it was so fucking cute.

And I remember thinking, "I want some guy's hand on my thigh right now that I like and blah, blah, blah." Anyway, so my mind kind of went there.

So I was kind of, like, romanticizing their relationship without knowing anything about them.

So when it comes to this individual that you're romanticizing, I wanna know what about them you're romanticizing.

Also, I'm interested in this as well because plenty of times we have crushes on people that don't like us back.

Sometimes I hear from people that when a crush likes them back, they lose interest.

And so I'm kinda curious about- I don't know any of your relational patterns or anything else, but one of the thing that was kind of-- one of the things that was sticking out to me in my head was, what is your relationship with being liked in the past and liking other people? What is reciprocation like for you? Are you-- Like, is that something that you're, that you're turned on by? Is that something that you're comfortable with? When I say comfortable with, I mean, sometimes people, they really, once they a- achieve the affection of people, they're like, "Oh, well, now I have it.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.