Aussie FIRE | Financial Independence Retire Early
Sep 4, 2026 · 42 min · 10 segments
Is the Aussie share market still worth it? Should a new investor wait for the next crash? And how much tech exposure is too much? Dave and Hayden open the listener mailbag and tackle three questions…
absolutely so i'll go ahead and read the first email so it goes the last few weeks i've been looking at the lackluster performance of vas and wondering is this still the best long-term strategy for future income the recent dividend has me questioning and looking at possible alternatives reits are interesting and vhy is yielding quite well in growth and dividends compared with vas i'm Looking at alternatives to the VAS VGS mix seems natural in the current climate.
Cash may even outperform VAS this year.
Thoughts, Hayden?
I mean, I like the question, right? Like, because it's very rare that, like, we've seen this trend quite often.
where things that have been good for the short or medium term maybe haven't been good for the long term or certain things have outperformed other things over different decades.
And naturally, a lot of ETF investors like you and I have only been doing it for 10 or 20 years, I would say.
I'd say it's fair to say most young people investing in ETFs have probably only been doing it for under 10 years.
So, In that time, there's been a lot of fairly comfortable truths, I guess.
And I do think it's an interesting question because there's nothing to say that certain ETFs that have been popular should and will be popular forever or will continue to return the things they return.
But you were telling me about this in terms of VAS isn't necessarily the highest performing Australian focused investment ETF when you look at it sometimes too.
Well, what do you mean by that,
highest performing? Oh, in terms of when you were comparing it to VHY?
Yeah.
So, it's actually quite interesting.
So, when we got this question, I went back and I had a look at the numbers.
And VHY, which for anyone who's not familiar with that, is basically Vanguard's high yield index.
And so...
It's a little bit like VAS where it's just focused solely on Australian shares, but it's a collection of, I believe, maybe between 50 and 70 stocks that have been screened and they seem to pass this filter for being higher than average yield.
So the ETFs put together based on that specific rule on whether it's predicted to have a high forecast yield for the coming year or two years or whatever the specific rule happens to be.
And it turns out that it's actually outperformed VAS over five years and over 10 years.
So the numbers are VHY has done 11.6% per annum and VAS has done 7.9 over five years.
So that's actually quite a significant difference.
And then over 10 years, VHY has done 10.4% per annum and VAS has done 9% per annum.
So it's quite interesting because the portfolios themselves and the top 10 stocks in the portfolio, which make up a significant weighting in that ETF, those stocks are actually quite similar because a lot of the stocks in the Aussie index by nature are kind of large cap dividend paying companies that are fairly boring.
That's part of the reason why people like to invest elsewhere in the first place, but What VHY does is essentially double down on those large dividend-paying companies.
absolutely so i'll go ahead and read the first email so it goes the last few weeks i've been looking at the lackluster performance of vas and wondering is this still the best long-term strategy for future income the recent dividend has me questioning and looking at possible alternatives reits are interesting and vhy is yielding quite well in growth and dividends compared with vas i'm Looking at alternatives to the VAS VGS mix seems natural in the current climate.
Cash may even outperform VAS this year.
Thoughts, Hayden?
I mean, I like the question, right? Like, because it's very rare that, like, we've seen this trend quite often.
where things that have been good for the short or medium term maybe haven't been good for the long term or certain things have outperformed other things over different decades.
And naturally, a lot of ETF investors like you and I have only been doing it for 10 or 20 years, I would say.
I'd say it's fair to say most young people investing in ETFs have probably only been doing it for under 10 years.
So, In that time, there's been a lot of fairly comfortable truths, I guess.
And I do think it's an interesting question because there's nothing to say that certain ETFs that have been popular should and will be popular forever or will continue to return the things they return.
But you were telling me about this in terms of VAS isn't necessarily the highest performing Australian focused investment ETF when you look at it sometimes too.
Well, what do you mean by that,
highest performing? Oh, in terms of when you were comparing it to VHY?
Yeah.
So, it's actually quite interesting.
So, when we got this question, I went back and I had a look at the numbers.
And VHY, which for anyone who's not familiar with that, is basically Vanguard's high yield index.
And so...
It's a little bit like VAS where it's just focused solely on Australian shares, but it's a collection of, I believe, maybe between 50 and 70 stocks that have been screened and they seem to pass this filter for being higher than average yield.
So the ETFs put together based on that specific rule on whether it's predicted to have a high forecast yield for the coming year or two years or whatever the specific rule happens to be.
And it turns out that it's actually outperformed VAS over five years and over 10 years.
So the numbers are VHY has done 11.6% per annum and VAS has done 7.9 over five years.
So that's actually quite a significant difference.
And then over 10 years, VHY has done 10.4% per annum and VAS has done 9% per annum.
So it's quite interesting because the portfolios themselves and the top 10 stocks in the portfolio, which make up a significant weighting in that ETF, those stocks are actually quite similar because a lot of the stocks in the Aussie index by nature are kind of large cap dividend paying companies that are fairly boring.
That's part of the reason why people like to invest elsewhere in the first place, but What VHY does is essentially double down on those large dividend-paying companies.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.