Listener sentiment
3 Yards Per Carry has built a devoted following over several years as one of the most informative Miami Dolphins podcasts, with listeners consistently praising the hosts' insider knowledge, scouting analysis, and chemistry. Simon is widely regarded as the show's analytical anchor, and newer content like the Simon-and-Kyle draft podcast has been enthusiastically received. However, recent reviews through 2025 and 2026 show a noticeable dip in sentiment, driven by several recurring frustrations. Host Alfredo remains a persistent flashpoint: multiple reviewers across years describe him as abrasive and overly negative, and recent ratings specifically call out his behavior on the paid Discord — including banning members who disagree with him and posting while intoxicated. Excessive negativity about the team, frequent WWE and wrestling tangents that alienate football-focused listeners, and a steeper paywall on the Discord community have also drawn recent criticism. Audio quality issues, particularly Simon being difficult to hear, are a long-standing complaint that persists across the full review history. The show still earns strong marks from its core audience, but the recent window reveals growing tension between the dedicated fan base and the hosts' off-field behavior and editorial direction.
Apple3.9 · 113
Summary generated Aug 9, 2026
