Skip to main content
Steven J. Menashi

Steven J. Menashi

American lawyer and jurist

Sep 29, 2026

6:52
Then
6:53
the third issue is something that I had raised briefly in the original essay, but talk a little bit more in this essay, which is Barbara talks a lot about the three territorial fictions about ambassadors invading soldiers and Indian tribes.
7:12
But there is also a pretty well-established territorial fiction involving aliens who are detained at the border and then paroled into the country pending the determination of admissibility.
7:23
It's pretty well established, and the distinction runs throughout immigration law, that those folks have not affected an entry into the country and are not treated for legal or constitutional purposes as if they have entered the country.
7:38
And so the question is, how does the birthright rule apply to them? So if the court were to say that they do get birthright citizenship, it would destabilize a lot of what we have in immigration law, which is that a parole pending a determination of admissibility is not an entry.
8:00
And it might affect the degree to which the government is willing to parole aliens for humanitarian reasons into the country.
8:07
But on the other hand, if they were to recognize it, it might destabilize the picture that Barbara tried to paint of a kind of simple territorial rule.

40 MINS LATER

Tiago De Almeida GraffMODERATOR
48:41
What would ultimately a resolution look like in the end, in your eyes? Maybe if I start with the judge.
Aaron NielsenMODERATOR
5:47
So we'll start, I guess, with you, Judge Menasche.
5:51
Well, thanks very much.
5:52
That was very gracious, and I'm delighted to be here.
5:56
It's good to be back at Scalia Law School, sort of, in this hotel, but I'm delighted to be part of it.
6:04
In terms of how you approach statutory interpretation questions, I kind of thought it would be less interesting to just say we're all textualists who start with the text and focus on it, so I thought maybe I'd sort of point out some areas where there might be disagreements even among textualists, but I have a I have a view.
6:21
So one of them is, so of course you do start with the text, and the text is what is controlling, you know, but context also matters a lot, right? So there's, Sam Bray wrote an article I really like about the mischief rule, about what the mischief is that the legislature was trying to get at.
6:36
I think that that is a legitimate thing for somebody to think about in understanding the meaning of a text, you know, the mischief against which it was directed.

9 MINS LATER

15:54
And that seems to me entirely correct and consistent with the text and structure of the Constitution.
15:53
And, and that seems to me entirely correct and consistent with the text and structure of the Constitution.
16:00
Yeah, I mean, in a way, you know, it's a pretty...
16:02
A modest decision.
16:03
It didn't say it's unconstitutional for Congress to make delegations to, to agencies.
16:09
It just said Chevron relied on this presumption that whenever there's an ambiguity in a statute, it...
16:14
That itself is a delegation that Congress wouldn't have wanted the ambiguity resolved by the agency, and that's just an unjustified, uh, presumption, right? So the Congress said in the APA the courts decide questions of law, that is a question of law, and so the default rule is maybe Congress should decide that question.
16:30
I mean, the way I had always thought about, um, Chevron deference is that there's sort of two basic kinds of cases.

28 MINS LATER

Aaron NielsenMODERATOR
44:51
Um, since Loper Bright said courts should use their best judgment in interpreting statutes, why should courts continue to apply the major questions doctrine?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.