Skip to main content
Philippe Sands

Philippe Sands

British-French writer and lawyer

Nov 20, 2026

26:33
First of all, Philippe, why the Gambia? Why did they bring this case? And number two, talk about the significance, again, of this being the first country that has been convicted of genocide and what that ultimately means.
26:53
Well, it's lovely to be back on with you after a gap of about 15 years, Amy.
26:59
The Rohingya case was brought by the Gambia basically on the initial instance of a single individual, Bartambadu, who was the attorney general of the Gambia, who went on a visit to Cox's Bazaar, the place that's just been described, spoke to a lot of the people who had fled Myanmar, heard stories, and because he had been Previously, a prosecutor in the Rwanda criminal tribunal in The Hague and Arusha understood that the stories that he was being told told a story of genocide.
27:28
He persuaded the government of the Gambia, of which he was a member, to bring a case to the International Court of Justice.
27:34
One of the reasons that happened was.
27:36
It's because both Myanmar and Gambia were parties to the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide.
27:43
And the Gambia is predominantly a Muslim country concerned about the mistreatment of a Muslim community in Myanmar.
29:12
They are charging Israel with genocide for what's happened in Gaza.
26:33
First of all, Philippe, why the Gambia? Why did they bring this case? And number two, talk about the significance, again, of this being the first country that has been convicted of genocide and what that ultimately means.
26:53
Well, it's lovely to be back on with you after a gap of about 15 years, Amy.
26:59
The Rohingya case was brought by the Gambia basically on the initial instance of a single individual, Bartambadu, who was the attorney general of the Gambia, who went on a visit to Cox's Bazaar, the place that's just been described, spoke to a lot of the people who had fled Myanmar, heard stories, and because he had been Previously, a prosecutor in the Rwanda criminal tribunal in The Hague and Arusha understood that the stories that he was being told told a story of genocide.
27:28
He persuaded the government of the Gambia, of which he was a member, to bring a case to the International Court of Justice.
27:34
One of the reasons that happened was.
27:36
It's because both Myanmar and Gambia were parties to the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide.
27:43
And the Gambia is predominantly a Muslim country concerned about the mistreatment of a Muslim community in Myanmar.
29:12
They are charging Israel with genocide for what's happened in Gaza.
26:33
First of all, Philippe, why the Gambia? Why did they bring this case? And number two, talk about the significance, again, of this being the first country that has been convicted of genocide and what that ultimately means.
26:53
Well, it's lovely to be back on with you after a gap of about 15 years, Amy.
26:59
The Rohingya case was brought by the Gambia basically on the initial instance of a single individual, Bartambadu, who was the attorney general of the Gambia, who went on a visit to Cox's Bazaar, the place that's just been described, spoke to a lot of the people who had fled Myanmar, heard stories, and because he had been Previously, a prosecutor in the Rwanda criminal tribunal in The Hague, in Arusha, understood that the stories that he was being told told a story of genocide.
27:28
He persuaded the government of the Gambia, of which he was a member, to bring a case to the International Court of Justice.
27:34
One of the reasons that happened It's because both Myanmar and Gambia were parties to the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide.
27:43
And the Gambia is predominantly a Muslim country concerned about the mistreatment of a Muslim community in Myanmar.
27:51
So that was the basis on which, in 2019, the case began.
29:12
They are charging Israel with genocide for what's happened in Gaza.
26:33
First of all, Philippe, why the Gambia? Why did they bring this case? And number two, talk about the significance, again, of this being the first country that has been convicted of genocide and what that ultimately means.
26:53
Well, it's lovely to be back on with you after a gap of about 15 years, Amy.
26:59
The Rohingya case was brought by the Gambia basically on the initial instance of a single individual, Bartambadu, who was the attorney general of the Gambia, who went on a visit to Cox's Bazaar, the place that's just been described, spoke to a lot of the people who had fled Myanmar, heard stories, and because he had been Previously, a prosecutor in the Rwanda criminal tribunal in The Hague and Arusha understood that the stories that he was being told told a story of genocide.
27:28
He persuaded the government of the Gambia, of which he was a member, to bring a case to the International Court of Justice.
27:34
One of the reasons that happened was.
27:36
It's because both Myanmar and Gambia were parties to the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of Genocide.
27:43
And the Gambia is predominantly a Muslim country concerned about the mistreatment of a Muslim community in Myanmar.
29:12
They are charging Israel with genocide for what's happened in Gaza.
33:49
I mean,
33:50
if you go back to the period of National Socialism, read a book, an extraordinary book by Sebastian Hafner, the historian, who was there in 1933 and describes it brilliantly.
34:02
takeover of the legal order.
34:05
And that was why in 1945, ironically enough, led by the United States, we created a sort of new global legal order called international law, which basically said there are limits placed on the sovereignty of the state to protect the dignity of the individual, to protect the dignity of groups.
34:25
And an architecture was put in place that including rules and institutions and courts.
34:33
And what the United States is now leading the world in doing, it's sort of ironic, is destroying the order that it created.
34:45
And so I think where we are right now, and it is a very tough time, I'm not starry-eyed at all, there is a struggle that is underway.

15 MINS LATER

49:27
Who carries the moral responsibility of bearing witness?
16:30
And yet so much more of the world seems to be exercised about what's happening in Gaza and pays very little attention to what's happening in Africa.
16:38
How come? Absolutely.
16:40
I mean, I think tens of thousands of people have probably died in Iran since the beginning of this year as part of a put down of peaceful demonstrations, individuals wanting to express and protect their rights.
16:53
That gets almost no attention internationally.
16:56
And you're bound to ask yourself the question, why does Iran? Israel, Palestine, Gaza get so much attention.
17:03
And there are a number of theories about why that happens.
17:06
There may be some people who particularly care about that issue.

10 MINS LATER

27:00
I
7:55
How much do you think the lawyers are to blame or the institutions of justice for not standing up to him?
8:02
Hugely.
8:03
I mean, I really loved the book.
8:05
I sort of beelined first for the lawyers, and there are quite a few of them in the book.
8:12
The worst is Carp from the law firm Paul Weiss, which has, as you described, an incredible reputation.
8:20
history.
8:21
And to see the law firms immediately capitulate, not all of them did, you can say more about that, Jacob, but some very major law firms capitulated more or less instantly and signed up to these pro bono deals where they do $40 million of pro bono work on MAGA-type projects.

29 MINS LATER

38:05
Philip, do you think there's any way, you talked about it being ruptured, quoting Carney, do you think there's any way back from this? How does the world order re-establish itself? Can we get back to a rule of law?
24:11
And the system you created is likely to survive the test of time because it was so well conceived.
24:19
Well, that's very generous.
24:21
There were two other publications by the time mine came about.
24:25
One was in French and was more slender, shall we say, by Alexander Charles Kiss from the University of Strasbourg.
24:33
And that really was the first book on international environmental law.
24:37
And then about a year before my book came out, my colleagues and friends Patricia Burney and Alan Boyle wrote a book called International Law and the Environment.
24:50
And it has a different structure from mine, but I was able to draw upon it and be influenced by it.

1 HR 9 MINS LATER

94:14
Do you think these memberships gave you impetus for your writing?
24:11
And the system you created is likely to survive the test of time because it was so well conceived.
24:19
Well, that's very generous.
24:21
There were two other publications by the time mine came about.
24:25
One was in French and was more slender, shall we say, by Alexander Charles Kiss from the University of Strasbourg.
24:33
And that really was the first book on international environmental law.
24:37
And then about a year before my book came out, my colleagues and friends Patricia Burney and Alan Boyle wrote a book called International Law and the Environment.
24:50
And it has a different structure from mine, but I was able to draw upon it and be influenced by it.

1 HR 9 MINS LATER

94:14
Do you think these memberships gave you impetus for your writing?
30:29
I
30:29
knew nothing about anything.
30:33
But I'd done this LLM and so I knew how to do footnotes and things.
30:36
And I'd been very well trained on that kind of stuff.
30:39
And so David was happy.
30:41
As a visiting scholar enrolled, I could go to all the classes.
30:46
I could, you know, meet teachers, meet LLM students, meet JD students and be part of the community.

22 MINS LATER

52:26
And also another big event in your life was your marriage.
JaniceHOST
30:29
I
30:29
knew nothing about anything.
30:33
But I'd done this LLM and so I knew how to do footnotes and things.
30:36
And I'd been very well trained on that kind of stuff.
30:39
And so David was happy.
30:41
As a visiting scholar enrolled, I could go to all the classes.
30:46
I could, you know, meet teachers, meet LLM students, meet JD students and be part of the community.

22 MINS LATER

JaniceHOST
52:26
And also another big event in your life was your marriage.
9:26
showboating, do you think?
9:27
Well, I think that Mr. Khan does like a bit of publicity.
9:32
And I think a different type of individual would have handled these complex, controversial, difficult matters in a different way.
9:40
And in a sense, I think it might be said he's the author of his own misfortunes by having taken such a public stance in the way that he has.
9:49
But I think the bottom line of it is now that The states have got to move as fast as they reasonably can, get a new prosecutor in post, and then decide what to do.
9:59
And of course, the first thing a prosecutor is going to have in their in-tray is what to do with existing arrest warrants and indictments.
10:06
And frankly, it's going to be very difficult to go backwards.
10:30
Yeah, it goes to its credibility, doesn't it? I just wanted to ask you briefly and finally, if you can, has the court lived up to what you were hoping for when you drafted that preamble to the Rome statute all those years ago?
9:57
Why is the US not a member of the International Criminal Court?
10:01
The US is not a member of the International Criminal Court because I think any president who is inclined to support it knows that they would never get through the US Senate a ratification of the statute, and so no president has proposed it.
10:16
When it was adopted in 1998, um, the United States played a very active part in its negotiation, and so they fashioned a statute that was the most acceptable, I suppose, to the president at the time, that was Bill Clinton.
10:30
In fact, a few, a few months afterwards, Bill Clinton attended a, a seminar at New York University, uh, and I happened to be there.
10:38
And at, at the reception afterwards, I did ask him what his concerns were with the statute of the International Criminal Court, and it was really rather remarkable.
10:46
He knew particular provisions by heart, and he said, "Well, I got a problem, you know, Article X, Article Y." It was really, really very, very striking.
10:54
But the bottom line of it was basically there is a s- has always been a strong strand of opinion in the United States that does not like the idea of international courts exercising jurisdiction either over Americans or in relation to US interests.
14:08
But how has the US posture to the court evolved since the days of Bill Clinton?
speaker_7UNKNOWN
13:24
[laughs]
13:26
[upbeat music] How did this book begin? There are many starting points, but basically, I think the real starting point is the summer of 2014.
13:35
I'm in a small village in Austria called Hagenberg, the home of Horst Wächter.
13:43
You will know Horst if you listen to the BBC pod- uh, series, The Ratline, or, or the book.
13:49
He is the son of Otto and Charlotte Wächter.
13:52
Otto Wächter, a major Nazi governor in German occupied Poland, based in the city of Lviv, hunted after the war for the murder of hundreds of thousands of Poles and Jews and Roma.
14:06
Escapes.
speaker_7UNKNOWN
14:56
[laughs]
speaker_4NARRATOR
5:27
The Indian Ocean.
5:27
But it's part of Africa.
5:29
It's a curious situation.
5:31
And there's been an issue about whether Mauritius really did include the Chagos Archipelago, but there's no question, this was dealt with by the International Court, that every three months a magistrate would go from Port Louis in Mauritius and do his duties, his magisterial duties, uh, on the Chagos Archipelago.
5:49
It was administered, the enslaved people were administered from there, and so on and so forth.
5:53
There's really no question it was part of Mauritius.
5:56
Then we come to decolonization after the United Nations is created.And the people of Mauritius want their independence.

25 MINS LATER

31:26
Why was the, why was the carve-out done by way of a lease as opposed to, uh, a carve-out of sovereign territory, as happened in Cyprus, for example?
8:04
Can you just tell me the story?
8:06
In 1941, there was a meeting off the coast of Newfoundland, which was then a British colony, between the British prime minister, Winston Churchill, and the US then president, Franklin Delano Roosevelt.
8:21
And they signed a one-page piece of paper.
8:23
It's really worth going to look it up if your listeners are interested.
8:25
One page? It's one page.
8:27
It's called the Atlantic Charter.
8:29
And it's basically a vision statement of the world as they would like it to be.

16 MINS LATER

24:49
Do you have a message for those people?
19:11
Do you see it that way?
19:12
It's very-- You've picked up.
19:14
It's, it, it's makes for a lot of passions, a lot of controversy, a lot of anger, and a lot of upset.
19:22
Um, on the South African side, you know, for long and complex historical reasons, there's a sense that what is happening to the Palestinians is outrageous, and they want to find a way to go to an international court to argue that and to express their outrage and to make it stop happening, and the only way they can do that, because the only international treaty that gives you access to the International Court of Justice is the Genocide Convention.
19:48
So if you want to get to court, you've got to call it genocide.
19:51
On the converse side, there's outrage on the Israeli side that a, a state that emerged from the embers of the Holocaust, a genocide, is now being accused of genocide.
20:06
And so stepping back and without expressing a view as to what the International Court of Justice will ultimately do, and we don't know what the court will do.
21:58
Do you have a message for those people?
24:13
Do you see it that way?
24:15
It's very-- You've picked up.
24:17
It's, it, it-Makes for a lot of passions, a lot of controversy, a lot of anger, and a lot of upset.
24:25
Um, on the South African side, you know, for long and complex historical reasons, there's a sense that what is happening to the Palestinians is outrageous, and they want to find a way to go to an international court to argue that and to express their outrage and to make it stop happening.
24:44
And the only way they can do that, because the only international treaty that gives you access to the International Court of Justice is the Genocide Convention.
24:51
So if you want to get to court, you've got to call it genocide.
24:54
On the converse side, there's outrage on the Israeli side that a, a, a state that emerged from the embers of the Holocaust, a genocide, is now being accused of genocide.
27:01
Do you have a message for those people?
136:55
Yes.
136:56
Um, but then I'm going to surprise you, because who changes everything in September 2022, but none other than Prime Minister Liz Truss, who unleashes a negotiation with Mauritius to resolve, uh, this long-standing problem.
137:10
Actually, a pretty sensible decision, and she's supported, um, by her Foreign Secretary, James Cleverly, and that is then taken over by Rishi Sunak.
137:20
And finally, by the summer of 2024, you've got a very nearly completed draft treaty, uh, ninety percent complete.
137:27
Uh, then there's an election, uh, and then the Labour government basically wraps it up.
137:32
So it's a sort of Tory treaty, to be honest, which is why all these accounts of, uh, you know, Mrs Cleverly and others complaining about this-
142:14
Yeah.
142:14
The Mauritius doesn't require British nationals yet to have visas, but presumably, if the UK starts having visas for Mauritians, then, uh, that will soon, that will soon change.
20:19
mansion on the hill that
20:21
is there with a value system, a court system, the rule of law, a constitution, something that we've always been taught to aspire to.
20:30
And what we're seeing now is the scales, in a sense, falling from our eyes as we confront the actual possibility that the United States could by force take control of a part of the territory that is within the NATO alliance.
20:53
I mean, it beggars belief.
20:55
And this is giving rise to some conversations that are extremely problematic.
21:00
I mean, one of the other countries that has come out very strongly against this, and it's complex, and I'm choosing my words carefully, is China.
21:09
China is looking at what's going on now.

21 MINS LATER

41:56
Well, why don't you outline some of them for us?
8:42
I come to a very clear
8:43
conclusion with no doubts, and I'll come to that in a moment.
8:46
But just on Bruce Chatwin, since it is of interest also in Australia.
8:51
You brought him up.
8:53
I brought them up because, well, I went down to Punta Arenas with a copy of In Patagonia in hand, looking to find the characters or their descendants that he wrote about that he claimed to have met in Punta Arenas.
9:06
It turned out that half of them never existed.
9:08
They were pure invention.

29 MINS LATER

38:03
Well,
8:42
I come to a very clear
8:43
conclusion with no doubts, and I'll come to that in a moment.
8:46
But just on Bruce Chatwin, since it is of interest also in Australia.
8:51
You brought him up.
8:53
I brought them up because, well, I went down to Punta Arenas with a copy of In Patagonia in hand, looking to find the characters or their descendants that he wrote about that he claimed to have met in Punta Arenas.
9:06
It turned out that half of them never existed.
9:08
They were pure invention.

29 MINS LATER

38:03
Well,
4:31
Right.
4:31
Um, there are negotiations within the framework of the United Nations at the regional level within a body called the International Law Commission, for example, to negotiate the creation of a permanent international court that would have global jurisdiction over everything.
4:51
But in short, notwithstanding the conflicts that take place, the wars that take place, whether it's Suez, whether it's Vietnam or other things, nothing happens.
5:02
There are no developments.
5:05
There are diminishing numbers of criminal proceedings in relation to the war years across Europe and elsewhere.
5:13
And the big change really only comes in the 1990s.
5:18
What happens in the 1990s is we have horrendous conflicts in, amongst other places, the former Yugoslavia and in Rwanda, and mass killings occur in both places.

22 MINS LATER

28:00
But why should we care? Why does it matter today?
11:38
Right.
11:38
Um, I think the date was the 16th of October, as far as I recall.
11:43
It took place very early in the morning in the courtyard of the Palace of Justice in Nuremberg, where they would previously have taken their exercises.
11:54
It happened one after the other.
11:57
We have accounts of what each of them said.
12:00
As they approached their death, uh, we have the accounts of the chaplain, we have the accounts of what is said whilst actually standing with the noose around their neck.
12:10
Some went quietly, some went defiantly, uh, some shouted, some said nothing.

8 MINS LATER

19:47
Is that kind of the end of it in terms of the trial process for the Second World War, excluding things going on outside of Germany?
10:09
Mm
10:09
... really very, very shocking.
10:12
A-and that had a particular effect because the propaganda value of the trial meant that although the room was darkened, the prosecution had installed large lights on the ceiling and switched these on whilst the defendants were watching the films of the concentration camps.
10:35
And so you are able to see the defendants looking really rather shocked at vast mounds of corpses.
10:44
I mean, terrible images that we're, that we're now familiar with.
10:50
And that was all done in the first weeks.
10:52
I mean, I spoke to, um, a lady who was the daughter of the chief judge, Sir Geoffrey Lawrence.

24 MINS LATER

35:00
Was it solely down to these judges, and how were they supposed to work?

Scroll for more appearances

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.