Skip to main content
Michael Kirby

Michael Kirby

Jurist and former Justice of the High Court of Australia

Nov 5, 2026

8:55
And do you think international law has power in the modern age?
9:00
I think it does, actually.
9:02
I've been criticised by some people for being too optimistic about this policy.
9:09
But this is the world we live in, and the world we live in is an international world.
9:15
It's a world with international technology and international problems.
9:22
And unless you write humanity off and say, well, we've just got all these problems and they're too difficult, nothing will be done.
9:29
I don't know about you, but I often look at home at night at the YouTube information on planets.

9 MINS LATER

18:28
The courts have become too political.
3:33
I was interested in how that also shaped your views on the bench in terms of your approach to people in general as a humanitarian.
3:43
I think the fact that I had wonderful teachers and that I was in a public school and therefore wasn't being pressured all the time by a particular religious viewpoint was quite important.
3:59
I did go to the local Methodist church for Sunday school and I did go to the local Anglican church But it wasn't a huge thing in my life.
4:13
More important were the teachers and the principle of secularism, which is so important in public schools.
4:21
You had people of different economic situation and different religious background.
4:28
It was the war years when I started at North Strathfield Public School.
4:34
I could remember that there were pids who came to the school without shoes.

22 MINS LATER

26:19
And that's the question of whether Australia, the way we limit the right to protest and how you feel about that.
14:25
Homosexual law reform was one of those battles, and former High Court Justice Michael Kirby was watching closely.
14:34
I think Don Dunstan showed considerable courage because he was an elected politician.
14:41
He wasn't an academic or a law reformer for whom these things were theoretical.
14:47
He was putting forward points of view and advocating changes in the law.
14:53
which is always a difficult thing to secure, but especially on a matter as sensitive as the criminal law against gays.
15:03
So I thought he was courageous.
15:06
He was rational, persuasive, dignified and eloquent.
19:22
And in Dunstan, he'd recognised someone willing to challenge that.
13:31
A young Michael Kirby was nervously sitting in Ilmar Tamalo's living room, waiting for a group of legal academics to finish their tea and cakes so they could begin discussing a paper he'd written about the doctrine of Soviet leaders at that time.
13:45
And I have a copy of it here, by the sheerest of chance.
13:50
Ilmar, with his command of German and of Russian, had translated tens, maybe even hundreds of papers which were made up of the speeches of Soviet leaders.
14:06
And my essay was Dialectics and Law by Michael D. Kirby Sidney.
14:13
And it was my effort to to analyse and synthesise this huge mountain of essays that had been produced by Ilmar Tamalo in his room at the Sydney Law School.
16:51
Students were to study under him one subject.
16:55
And here in the midst of us was this group of people, most of whom were from poorer and mysterious countries of Europe, such as Estonia.
17:09
And the bridge was provided by Julius Stone, whose family had come from Lithuania, but who'd spent, I think, all of his life in England and then later became dean of law in Auckland, England.
Rosalind DixonMODERATOR
34:41
Oh,
34:41
no, no, no.
34:44
But, well, he was a bit, he had a bit both ways.
34:49
But if you notice how both of the originalists on the panel have retreated as far as they can.
34:57
Oh, no, no, I'm not a real originalist or it doesn't count me in.
35:03
And they find all sorts of other excuses to get away from it.
35:08
It is true that all judges that I've sat with start with the Constitution.

46 MINS LATER

Rosalind DixonMODERATOR
81:33
Can you think of a decision where you would have voted differently as a legislator than as a judge? Can you show us an example of where your approach was constrained by virtue of your interpretive approach rather than your general orientation to values?
10:30
[laughs]
10:30
But I think we've just gotta be a little bit patient.
10:34
And Orbán shows that not only was this a political movement, but it was a popular movement.
10:41
It was a lot of people, and the Hungarians don't have such a glorious history that you could write that off.
10:49
That was unusual, and that was wonderful.
10:52
And we've got to look to the countries in which lawyers have taken cases to courts, and courts have overruled some of the laws o- against, uh, gay people.
11:04
Um, and there are a sprinkling of countries, but sadly, there's also more than a sprinkling of countries in Africa and in the Caribbean and in Eastern Europe who are particularly nasty to gay people.

10 MINS LATER

21:35
I think I just detect that there is a broader mood going on that is far deeper than the way that we're describing it in this conversation.
12:19
People, you know, living on rodents, lizards, grass, and yet nothing the world has done in relation to North Korea, isolation, sanctions, uh, trying to freeze them out of all sorts of scenarios, ha-has done much at all.
12:35
In fairness, there have been a few tiny improvements.
12:39
For example, they never allowed us in the Commission of Inquiry in.
12:43
They'd never allowed the High Commissioner for Human Rights in.
12:48
They didn't allow the United Nations generally in.
12:51
But they did ultimately allow that there was a need to improve the way they dealt with disabled people.
13:00
Pyongyang was to be the most magical city in the world.
15:20
Do you detect an attitude within South Korea that maybe the whole issue of North Korea is less urgent than it was?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.