Skip to main content
Mandy Matney

Mandy Matney

Sep 29, 2026

53:28
[laughs]
53:28
I, no, I'm with you, man.
53:29
Like I was furious too the more that we discovered about Mica.
53:35
Like I, again, we saw similarities to Murdoch, but that was the f- when we started digging into the dad, we were just really seeing, like this is a generational thing.
53:45
These are Southern men that have never been held to account, and they teach their sons to, that they will never be held to account.
53:51
And the generational alleged abuse that we uncovered, um, it was so heartbreaking but also so important, like for people to realize of like, uh, looking, like you said, looking at JP's mother and father's divorce records and the abuse that she alleged but did not have the necessary, the words, um...
54:19
It was very similar to Mica's.

38 MINS LATER

92:32
Is Brittany Snow gonna play you again in, in the, in the Micah case? Like, are we gonna do a part two? Because m- my thought too is that would you be open to telling a story in the way they did with the Hulu series with this series?
14:28
That's just my initial thought in terms of, you know, they are quite rare to see cyberstalking specifically, and of course, the maximum sentence here is five years, which people say, "Oh, well, that's not very much." But in my view, they've gone for something that's concrete, that they've got the receipts for, that they can evidence without really opinion mattering around it, if that makes sense.
14:53
I would agree that it's extremely validating, and I was surprised by it.
14:59
I was shocked to see the FBI pursue a charge like this because it is something that it's a crime that, we have said this over and over, mostly affects women and mostly threatens women.
15:11
And it is just very rare for any police agencies to take those types of crimes seriously.
15:18
And yeah, the indictment is validating because it is full of things that women have gone to police for in the past and just been told, "Sorry, can't do anything." And the key here is to, and the frustrating part, Laura, is that I think the worst part about this case and investigating it was listening to Micah's 911 calls where she was clearly begging for help.
15:46
She was clearly desperate.
15:47
She was clearly terrified of her estranged husband.

33 MINS LATER

48:55
If they get it right.
44:41
Perhaps you can say something about that, Mandy, and just that period of time, and then the mental health facility that she was put in by him, because these two things quickly followed each other, I believe, in terms of a time sequencing.
44:56
Yeah, the timeline is a little confusing, but it sounds like everything pretty much erupted in their relationship around November 2022.
45:04
Yeah.
45:06
They got into a very heated argument that ended up being over something very silly.
45:14
I guess JP really liked to take gummies, like weed gummies, I don't know, some sort of gummies.
45:20
And he would get kind of weird and ask Micah weird questions.
45:24
And this night in particular, he asked her over and over and over again questions.

27 MINS LATER

72:34
And that law needs to be on the statute book.
8:18
But how did you end up being deposed in the lawsuit that Mallory Beach's family, and quite rightly have, against Parkers?
8:28
So that's another confusing part of this case.
8:31
This is the second lawsuit against Parkers from the Beach family.
8:36
The first one was settled in 2023 to the tune of $15 million.
8:42
And that lawsuit was very weird, and I started following that lawsuit in 2019.
8:49
I have been on this case for a very, very long time, and I started reporting on Greg Parker and his...
8:57
I thought it was odd behavior for a gas station owner that there was lots, lots of evidence that his gas station illegally sold the alcohol to Paul Murdaugh, uh, that was consumed the night that Mallory Beach died in the tragic boat crash in February 2019.

41 MINS LATER

49:54
And I'll leave it there on that first part of going back to the timeline and just looking at how these two timelines intersect and also along with other haters who are there, who have just latched onto this and are using this to create more waves, more hatred, and more pile-ons, which means for me, they're on the wrong side of things because we should all be invested in truth and integrity and people doing things for the right reasons.

Unknown podcast

Katie Phang

May 26 · 27m

10:34
Uh-huh.
10:35
Right, and then, and one juror said at one point that she was influenced by that and that, that that convinced her of, that Alex, that, that influenced her verdict.
10:48
But then she backtracked that and said, "Actually, I was pressured by the other jurors." So but what the Supreme Court is saying that, is that it does not matter, basically, if the jurors were influenced by her saying that, and they are basically saying that they've heard enough that it's enough to get him a new trial.
11:11
So no matter, no matter if it influenced them or not, it seems like Becky did say something inappropriate even though most of them say that she didn't.
11:19
Um, it's enough for a new trial.
11:22
I would be interested in your opinion on that, um, because Justice Toll, a year and a half ago, had a completely different opinion.
11:30
She said because she, because they weren't influenced, um, it doesn't matter what Becky said, and she doesn't deserve a new trial.
15:02
You're like, "What?"
9:34
Uh-huh.
9:34
Right.
9:35
And the, and one juror said at one point that she was influenced by that and that, that that convinced her of that Alex, that c- that influenced her verdict, but then she backtracked that and said, "Actually, I was pressured by the other jurors." So but what the Supreme Court is saying that, is that it does not matter, basically, if the jurors were influenced by her saying that, and they are basically saying that they've heard enough that it's enough to get him a new trial.
10:10
So no matter, no matter if it influenced them or not, it seems like Becky did say something inappropriate even though most of them say that she didn't.
10:19
Um, it's enough for a new trial.
10:21
I would be interested in your opinion on that, um, because Justice Toll, a year and a half ago, had a completely different opinion.
10:30
She said because she, because they weren't influenced, um, it doesn't matter what Becky said, and she doesn't deserve a new trial.
14:01
You're like, "What?"
54:26
So what is going on exactly?
54:30
Well, thank you for that, and I appreciate that.
54:34
This could take hours, so I will be as short as possible.
54:39
I could go on and on and on about all this craziness.
54:42
But, yes, I have unfortunately been wrapped up in legal warfare for six months now with, of all people, Greg Parker and his attorneys who represented Alex Murdoch's co-conspirators.
55:00
So this legal warfare that involves the second Beach case, so the Mallory Beach case, for just a recap of everybody, and when I started covering this case, this was like ground zero of everything, was this lawsuit where Mark Tinsley, on behalf of the Beach family, sued Alex Murdoch, Buster Murdoch, the...
55:26
Alex Murdoch's father, whose house they were at that night, another restaurant that they were at that night, and a gas station called Parker's Gas Station.
58:30
completely contrary to any sort of way you have presented yourself since you have been in the public eye.
59:12
I just want to say before I even talk about this, that I am so disgusted at the way that you have been treated by publicly um by people that are supposed to be upholding the law by people that are you know should be exemplary in their moral you know uh behaviors i just um with like my jaw is on the ground at some of the things that have been said to you um so what is going
59:44
on exactly Well, thank you for that, and I appreciate that.
59:49
This could take hours, so I will be as short as possible.
59:54
I could go on and on and on about all this craziness.
59:57
But, yes, I have unfortunately been wrapped up in legal warfare for six months now with, of all people, Greg Parker and his attorneys who represented Alex Murdoch's co-conspirators.
60:15
So this legal warfare that involves the second Beach case, so the Mallory Beach case, for just a recap of everybody, and when I started covering this case, this was like ground zero of everything, was this lawsuit where Mark Tinsley, on behalf of the Beach family, sued Alex Murdoch, Buster Murdoch, the...
60:41
Alex Murdoch's father, whose house they were at that night, another restaurant that they were at that night, and a gas station called Parker's Gas Station.
63:47
any sort of you have presented yourself since you have been in the public eye.
5:19
And I mean, did you really, did you initially think when he was convicted that this was a possibility, that they would overturn it?
5:25
No.
5:26
Honestly, I really didn't.
5:27
And I haven't, I haven't been asked that question, and I, I really thought that everything was so solid in the tri- I mean, the trial was six weeks long.
5:37
It was very extensive.
5:39
Um, Creighton Waters did a fantastic job, and I thought Judge Newman did a fantastic job.
5:45
This doesn't happen often, but at that point I was proud of the South Carolina justice system and I was, um, really thought everything was solid.

48 MINS LATER

53:27
Mm-hmm
5:17
[laughs]
5:17
Yeah.
5:18
I s- discovered a wool hamper on accident.
5:21
So I started digging and started talking to people in the Murdaughs' hometown, and they started saying things like, "Well, did you hear about their maid, Gloria Satterfield? She fell and it w- that was a weird death, and there's something there.
5:34
You should look into that.
5:35
And then there's this kid, Stephen Smith, who was found in the road dead in 2015, and the Murdaugh name has come up a lot in that story too, and that's another murder that took place in the small town." And so Liz and I, my best friend, and she also worked at the Packet with me at the time, the newspaper, we just became obsessed and we started digging and digging, and we couldn't stop, and-We made one of those murder board things, and we started, I- and this was back in 2019, and we were like, "This could be a documentary.
6:08
This is way more interesting than the stuff Netflix is covering.

9 MINS LATER

15:01
Can you tell us, Mandy, have there been any developments in the case of Stephen Smith since his body was exhumed? And also, I know bad interviewing technique, but also any developments, are they likely to happen in Gloria Satterfield's case as well?
7:45
I mean,
7:46
yes, I am a typical millennial girly.
7:48
Like I grew up watching John Tucker must die and pitch perfect and all of her hits.
7:54
And I'm obsessed with her.
7:56
And I, what, and also this, this, We found all of this out before The Hunting Wives came out and she like blew up again, which I'm so happy that she did.
8:06
She has the career that she deserves right now.
8:10
And I just absolutely love her and could not imagine a better person to play me.

52 MINS LATER

60:44
Like this boy is his father's son.
7:28
I mean,
7:29
yes, I am a typical millennial girly.
7:31
Like I grew up watching John Tucker must die and pitch perfect and all of her hits.
7:37
And I'm obsessed with her.
7:39
And I, what, and also this, this, We found all of this out before The Hunting Wives came out and she like blew up again, which I'm so happy that she did.
7:50
She has the career that she deserves right now.
7:53
And I just absolutely love her and could not imagine a better person to play me.

52 MINS LATER

59:44
He's becoming his father, like this boy is his father's son.
7:46
I mean,
7:46
yes, I am a typical millennial girly.
7:49
Like I grew up watching John Tucker must die and pitch perfect and all of her hits.
7:54
And I'm obsessed with her.
7:57
And I, what, and also this, this, We found all of this out before The Hunting Wives came out and she like blew up again, which I'm so happy that she did.
8:07
She has the career that she deserves right now.
8:10
And I just absolutely love her and could not imagine a better person to play me.

58 MINS LATER

66:21
Like this boy is his father's son.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.