Listener sentiment
RedHanded's ratings remain sharply polarized into the latest window, with devoted fans continuing to heap praise on Hannah and Suruthi's chemistry, thorough research, and irreverent dark humour — several describe it as their favourite podcast and many pushed back directly against the show's critics. The most pointed recent criticism concerns tone: a cluster of low ratings accuses the hosts of laughing at or joking about victims, including a child's murder, with a Mexico serial-killer episode singled out as arrogant and belittling. The Lindsay Clancy trial coverage remains a live flashpoint — praised by some as a rare factual, level-headed account amid online misinformation, while others repeat accusations that the hosts presented contested claims as fact and mishandled discussion of antidepressants and mental health. A longer-running grievance persists among former fans: a perceived drift toward opinion-heavy, centre-right social commentary and "not all men" rhetoric, which several long-time listeners cite as the reason they unfollowed. Format complaints continue as an undercurrent too — too many lightweight "shorthand" episodes rather than full deep dives, and repetitive ad breaks. The divide itself remains the story: a loyal core holds firm while alienation among veterans shows no sign of easing.
Apple3.5 · 2,051
Summary generated Nov 19, 2026