Skip to main content
Kaya Kaynak

Kaya Kaynak

Oct 31, 2026

6:43
You've
6:44
got to get that off.
6:44
We can have a Jack Harrow-Van Dyke conversation.
6:47
I'm open to that.
6:48
But I think that replacing someone of his quality, let's say, is very difficult.
6:53
And Esri Konta's come in and done that pretty seamlessly.
6:55
Like, Arsenal's defence hasn't looked rocky at all.

38 MINS LATER

45:04
And it's been genuinely interesting asking every kind of different fan who's come on here, like what they've, what they've
FKHOST
8:10
Who's grabbed your attention?
8:12
Yeah, I guess Manchester United is a place to start in the sense that I don't know that I thought it would be this bad this quickly.
8:20
I never thought Michael Carrick was the guy to get them back to where they were before.
8:25
I always thought maybe he'd be a bridge manager to kind of tide the ship.
8:29
Is that the word I'm looking for? To tide things over until next season, basically.
8:33
And from their perspective, hopefully... get them a european finish and keep it relatively non-toxic but then i think when i thought that i forgot the the group of players they have in that squad and what sort of difficult characters to put it generously most of them are i think um i think bruno fernandez has shown his his colors in in in recent weeks i thought the way he came out and criticized the manager's tactics uh you know saying that they weren't pressing enough when he i think is probably the worst off the ball player in the big six team in the premier league um i think there is you know a real hypocrisy to that i think the sancho martinez as well a guy who's barely been fit since he arrived at the club coming out and slating the recruitment i think you know there's so much wrong with that club and so much that they need to fix but i kind of hope they don't because it's very entertaining i i think you know And it kind of makes you value the Arsenal rebuild even more in a way.
9:30
You think, wow, what a good job we've done.
FKHOST
14:13
Sorry, Kai, you're in your flow.
26:21
And not even important, but let's start with your thoughts on the sort of poetic, justice of him having a chance right after coming off at halftime to come on and be one of the heroes in Germany.
26:32
Yeah, I think Mikel's reaction probably relates to the fact that his arm was around Ebre Teixeira and not like a couple of years ago it would have been Raheem Sterling he was bringing onto the pitch and I think in that scenario maybe he would have had his head more in his hands a bit and seemed to be a bit more concerned but I think Mikel does genuinely trust the squad and there's a reason we're seeing the subs used so much in a way that before Mikel was criticised for not using his subs enough but now I think because he genuinely trusts every member of his squad pretty much he's not afraid to use them.
27:00
And with Eze in particular, he's spoken in the past, Arteta, about how Eze has this propensity to produce big moments in big games.
27:09
He's not really someone who's afraid of the occasion.
27:12
He does tend to, I mean, consistency has been his issue at Arsenal, but you think about his best performances.
27:16
They have come in big, big games.
27:19
So the games against Spurs, the knockout against Bayer Leverkusen, and there's plenty more that spring to mind.

7 MINS LATER

34:14
I think he's looking like he's figuring some things out, you know?
42:35
Yeah.
42:36
Um, yeah, that is a really good sign, and I think last season it kind of felt at times like Martin Ødegaard was playing within himself, and he missed a lot of games due to injury, and I think him wanting to be present for Norway in the World Cup was a big part of that.
42:52
He is a huge deal in Norway.
42:53
He's, you know, their equivalent to David Beckham probably, as we, as we know.
42:57
And, and he, I don't think, felt that he could miss out on Norway's first World Cup since, I think, 1998.
43:03
And, you know, that, that squad had underachieved up until that point in not qualifying for major tournaments, and, and now they have, and they did really well at the World Cup.
43:11
And he was brilliant at the World Cup because I think we saw a player in Martin Ødegaard who finally looked like he was playing with freedom and not within himself and not fearful of Of injuring himself.

22 MINS LATER

65:19
[laughs]
speaker_0ADVERTISER
33:29
Terms and conditions apply.
33:31
So ambitious, yes.
33:33
The Vinnie Jr. and Julian Alvarez links and the fact that we were willing to spend hundreds of millions of pounds on players again, that's ambitious.
33:41
Smart, not so much for the reasons we've already outlined on this pod so far where we've said that There are instances where they were a bit slow to move, instances where they probably should have had better backup options.
33:54
And then fast, yeah, as I said, a bit slow on occasions, and it seems like that's kind of cost us to the point where we're scrambling around seeing who's left on the left-wing market in the final days of the window.
34:04
I think the frustration for me with Berta, I guess, and this isn't a criticism or inside knowledge or anything, it's more that...
34:15
So football transfers are conducted.

9 MINS LATER

FKHOST
43:19
But do you think this maybe puts any sort of doubt into his mind as to, is this the right club for me to commit to future-wise? Is this the direction of travel and ambition that I set for myself that the club is going to replicate that in all of its transfer activity or market activity? Because we do feel a bit deflated tonight.
5:40
Mm-hmm
5:40
... going into the game, PSG were such overwhelming favorites I think, given that they were the team who had vanquished Bayern Munich quite, you know, 5-4 in probably the best Champions League game any of us have ever seen, and then put them aside so handily in the semifinal second leg as well, and had looked so formidable last season and, and for so much of this season as well.
5:59
So when we had to play them, I think everyone was just like, "Well, you know, this is gonna have to go really right." And you look at a few of the players Arsenal had missing in that game, so- Uh, I think Ricardo Calafiori was injured, no Jurrien Timber, so both first choice fullbacks out of the game up against the best wide attack in the world in Kvaratskhelia, Dembele, Bakalibu, et cetera, et cetera.
6:20
So it was, yeah, it was gonna be a difficult one, and I think with the way Arsenal played in the Champions League final, they got a lot of criticism for it, and I understand from a neutral's perspective why it maybe wasn't the funnest game to watch.
6:31
But if Arsenal were gonna win that game, that was the way they were gonna do it, trying to go toe-to-toe on a, on an attacking, uh, sort of strategy with PSG was just never, ever gonna work.
6:41
They had to, you know, get in front, try and defend, hope for the best, and that's what they did.
6:46
And to be honest, if it wasn't for an error from Cristianso Mosquera, who was playing a Champions League final at the age of 21, uh, out of position as well, they probably would've been all right.

6 MINS LATER

speaker_6ADVERTISER
13:18
Visit LibertyShield.com today and use coupon code AIVPN25 to get 25% off at checkout
11:25
Mm.
11:25
So Newcastle have cards to play in this one, whereas i- in the Alexander Isak deal last summer, they didn't really have the same cards to play because he'd kind of reached an endpoint.
11:34
I know he was on a, a long contract, but, uh, they, they, they needed to, to move him on eventually, and I think everyone could see where it was going.
11:42
So I think if Arsenal want to do it, they probably need to s- A, submit a formal bid rather than doing the, the verbal through agents and intermediaries thing.
11:49
I know that's how transfers are conducted these days.
11:51
But I think they need to put in a bid that's probably closer to the, the player's value and maybe not try [chuckles]...
11:57
I know it's in Arsenal's interest to try and get him as, as cheap as possible, and Newcastle sell as high as possible.
12:24
Mm.
17:06
And, and I mean, do you think it had any impact on the game?
17:08
I don't think it changed the game.
17:09
I don't think it's why Arsenal lost by any stretch.
17:10
But I, I think just generally Kai Havertz was having a really good game in the number nine position, and I thought in the first half he was holding the ball relatively well.
17:19
Second half, he wasn't holding the ball as well.
17:21
But I just don't think Victor Gyökeres' strengths generally.
17:25
He was very good at it in the semifinal second leg against Atlético Madrid.

24 MINS LATER

41:40
Mm-hmm
2:42
... 50 minutes onwards, Kaya said, I think, four words for the rest of the game.
2:46
You know how there's a thing that Wayne Rooney apparently likes to sleep with a hairdryer on because he finds it quite comforting?
7:02
It was a foul, Kaya.
7:03
It was a foul, and I guess the, the conversation will be
13:54
Oh, yeah
13:55
... was another one, but I mean, that's, that was, that's been, that's relatively small in comparison.
13:59
But, um, yeah, so the excitement of seeing Bukayo Saka 'cause Bukayo Saka this season has not been himself.
14:07
He's been dealing with an Achilles problem, and I think probably in, in recent months, Arsenal's recent memory is of him kind of not looking very good in the Carabao Cup final.
14:15
I think a lot of people, um, would, are kind of upset by the performance there.
14:19
Now it's become apparent that that was kind of because he was battling with an injury and-

7 MINS LATER

21:35
Waiting to see almost, wasn't it?
21:36
Yeah, it was odd.
9:42
Just, just tell us why it's wrong.
9:44
Why it's wrong is because there is contact.
9:46
Eze goes down.
9:47
That's a penalty I think in almost every other Champions League game this season, and it's not a clear enough, obvious enough error for the VAR to then send Danny Makkelie over to the screen to change it.
9:58
And also, like Arteta said, if you have to look at it 13 times, that does suggest it's not very clear or obvious.
14:20
[laughs]
14:20
... that there was this, there's scope for that not being a penalty, right? You could definitely say.
14:24
Um, but they overturned that to f- to say that the referee on field had made a clear and obvious error and a, a big mistake.
7:19
So that was a very interesting decision he made there.
7:22
Yeah, definitely, just on the front three.
7:24
So we were asked to do a line-up that we would do if we were in charge on the Athletic, and the piece actually didn't end up going out in the end.
7:32
But I chose Victor Jokers up front, and I said I would have chosen him regardless because Atletico Madrid aren't the team we remember who came to the Emirates in the Europa League semi-finals in Arsene Wenger for last season, who sat behind the ball for 90 minutes and defended and sort of eased their way past the...
7:49
Arsenal on marginal gains there when we've done a video on Tifa about this and I've watched a lot of them recently and they're a team who are a lot more open they leave a lot of spaces and those are the kind of spaces that we saw Victor Jokeres thriving when he was at Sporting and also that he's thrived in in the Champions League this season the inter game in particular comes to mind and that's also why I thought Gabriel Martinelli was a good choice because He's great in this competition this season, weirdly, despite being pretty average in the Premier League.
8:16
I think he's got eight goals in the, sorry, six goals in the Champions League in 12 games or one goal in the Premier League in 28 games.
8:21
So that tells you why I think it was sensible to play him.

38 MINS LATER

45:55
And that generally, apart from Diego Simeone and all the Atletico Madrid fans, I think most people would say that process was really, really poor and not aligned with the rules as UEFA have laid them out.
9:35
Mm.
9:35
Those kind of guys.
9:36
They're, they're very different now, and that means that when they try and counter-attack you, they have loads of players in position ready to go.
9:43
And as we know, watching Arsenal every week, the biggest cheat code against the counter-attack is Declan Rice, who is just phenomenal and can do the job of two or even three players sometimes.
9:52
So maybe that's what Mikel was thinking in terms of dropping Rice a little bit deeper and, and Zubimendi is, is not as able to cover ground as quickly.
10:00
So it maybe made sense in that sense to have someone a little bit, who was kind of, like you say, splitting the center backs at times and dropping in really deep just in case the counter-attack.
10:08
But then what did surprise me was how good Rice was on the ball, and I think we all love Declan Rice for, like I said, those ability to, to eat up the ground and, and stop counter-attacks and, and make tackles and interceptions.

28 MINS LATER

38:12
Mm-hmm
27:02
[laughing]
27:02
The game we play on there is, is this a movie quote or something from a tea towel? You know, like a throwaway phrase that would just live on a tea towel.
27:09
I feel, feel like this one, "Life's what happens when you're busy making other plans," is the kind of thing that would be written on a tea towel.
27:14
But also John Lennon said it.
30:04
Yeah.
30:04
They're in the Copa del Rey final against Real Sociedad on Saturday.
30:07
It's their first Copa final in 13 years.
30:10
So they've kind of...
5:29
So someone just-- What's the noise sound like?
5:31
Someone passes it out for a throw, and, and he just-- All the-- You don't even notice it.
5:34
You just, you just hear psssh.

34 MINS LATER

39:05
Maybe he did, yeah
39:06
...
39:06
I think my Football Manager, uh, uh, time spent playing has confused me with real life there because I'm sure Scarlett ends up at, a team in Germany all the time.
8:37
International football, often it feels like picking someone who, you know, can do the basics, but also is a, is a sort of, um, iconic representation of the nation.
8:46
Yeah, I think so.
8:47
I think international football is just a completely different beast, isn't it, to the domestic game now? And I think what you need as a, a coach of a national team is to have, like, a few build-up ideas.
8:58
Uh, you know, ideas about what you're gonna do when you're defending high, low, and medium, and how you're gonna move between those things.
9:04
A bit of a different profile in every position, and then a few game changers.
9:07
And I think get that in place, and then it's, it's like man management, tournament manag- management.
9:12
I, I think that's it.

33 MINS LATER

41:46
... actually a huge swing.
9:22
Yeah.
9:22
And, and once Arsenal were-- the onus was on them to start taking the initiative again and, and playing out and wrestle back control, they were just never able to do it.
9:29
Like City just had this, this vice-like grip on the momentum of the game that, that Arsenal were never really able to seize back.
9:35
And the, the way City did it in terms of the sort of the, the four-two-four press, that line of four, it was, it was like watching almost like...
9:41
It felt like table football at times to me watching it and, you know, sort of the four going side to side, side to side, and Arsenal players just knocking it from side to side in- instead of just kind of trying to go forward, and that was quite frustrating to watch.
9:52
The, the lack of movement from the Arsenal team on, on the ball was, was really disappointing.
9:58
And I think the frustration, I think, for most Arsenal fans going into this game is it's kind of felt like a performance like that has a little bit in, been in the post and that kind of risk-averse approach in the Premier League this season has been good because it's, it's worked.

44 MINS LATER

54:39
Yeah
55:47
Well, yeah, well, yeah.
55:48
Is it, this is the same as like when we talk about politics where no one can imagine any future [laughing] that's different from now.
55:53
Yeah, there, there's something to that, I think.
55:55
So do you broadly agree with Arteta, his assertion on that? That, that-
28:44
I told you, don't get him started on watches.
28:46
Pep Guardiola's Barcelona team was maybe slightly different to what his approach became later on.
28:51
Um, but I think w- since then we've seen the collapse of that, of that Guardiola approach.
28:56
It used to be that he could force teams to do what he wanted them to do and, and get them into a low block, and teams have started pushing back against that through a number of ways.
29:03
We talk about the rise of man-to-man, uh, phases in, in o- opponents suppressing.
29:08
They're, they're, they're just saying, "You know, if we allow you to have the ball, you're gonna force us into that low block or break us down, and we don't wanna, um, we would rather take our chances being a bit more aggressive out of possession and, and trying to stop you do that than face the consequences of just letting you do it." But also the, the rising quality of the, the teams in the Premier League has meant that every team now has players that can hurt City in transition.
29:29
And so bring those two things together, and I think what we've seen is the, the, the Pep Guardiola consensus has collapsed, and it means that it's a bit more of a free-for-all out there in, in Premier League from a tactical point of view.

19 MINS LATER

48:50
[laughs]
30:04
I
30:05
mean, I have to be honest, I don't think it was a penalty.
30:09
I think if Arsenal had conceded a penalty similar to that, I'd have been very annoyed.
30:15
I think Maduike is really clever in the sense the second he feels it, he goes down.
30:18
And we spoke earlier about maybe Arsenal not being streetwise enough to take advantage of the Andric yellow card.
30:25
They were certainly streetwise enough to take advantage of what's a mistake from, I think it's Tillman who's an attacking player defending in the box who panics.
30:33
and goes to ground and it's naive from him to do something like that in a Champions League game with a referee who has shown himself to be quite trigger happy and you know what the second I saw Madawaka go to ground I was like this referee is going to give that and then it's just a case of you know will VAR overturn it and I think like you say once they see that contact from that reverse angle which I know a lot of people have been putting it on social media, saying Madaweke dived without showing that angle, which is probably quite disingenuous.

16 MINS LATER

46:36
When you have fullbacks in those positions and you also see your team struggle to create and to make chances, I see a connection there.
41:17
Oh, yeah
41:18
...some really important chances at the minute, which is kind of frustrating.
41:21
Um, and it works because those chances are created by smart movement that pulls players out of position.
41:26
Another way they do it is by, um, obviously the Premier League and, and Arteta spoke about this, and I think we'll speak about this a little bit more detail in a sec.
41:33
But it's become a lot more man-to-man, and the way you kind of deal with that is by shifting away from your marker and, and Ødegaard's so good at that in terms of just having that little dart away from, uh, whoever's in front of him and creating the space, like you said.
41:47
And, um, once you create the space, there's a lot more, um, easier ways to pass forward.
41:53
And I think Arsenal have, have lacked that in recent games.

12 MINS LATER

54:02
It's a good show as well, so people should go and listen.
11:30
[laughs]
11:30
Um, but I think now, now obviously Igor Tudor's gone so far the other way that like he's not acknowledging, like you say, a 22-year-old that he's kind of brought on and, and subbed off within 17 minutes.
11:40
It, it feels, it kind of feels like his reign is b- because the, the Tottenham managerial appointments seem to have a cycle where they'll come in and there'll be an immediateUh, uplift in this, you know, may be hard to believe given that it was four whole games ago, but when Igor Tudor came in, there were actually, like, people who thought that, you know, it gave Spurs a decent chance going to the North London Derby.
11:59
It was, it was a real sort of boost, I think, to morale because things had got so bad under Frank, and that went so quickly.
12:05
And normally it takes Spurs managers a few months to be going, "You know what? Things aren't right.
12:10
The structure of the club isn't right." This is sort of the mentality and all that kind of stuff that Anne just said, and I think Conte said in the past and Mourinho said in the past, and I think Pochettino said as well.
12:19
It took Tudor one game-

48 MINS LATER

60:41
But it's a fairly serious situation, Kaio, isn't it? What, what the hell's happened?
10:27
I really, really enjoyed that.
10:28
Uh, I suppose apart from Gabriel Jesus scoring five goals [chuckles] against Spurs, who he nearly signed for, that would be, that would be quite high up there, too.
10:34
But yeah, going into the game, obviously, the narrative around Arsenal is they're, they're kind of choking under the pressure.
10:39
City had won the day before, and the gap had closed to, uh, two points.
10:43
For the first time in a long time, I think the, the title is technically in City's hands.
10:46
It's also in Arsenal's hands, but obviously City are at home in that big head-to-head clash between the two.
10:51
So it kind of felt like Arsenal were, were faltering, and it's, it's not just a Wolves thing, it's kind of been since the turn of the year.
JJ Bull
JJ BullPANELIST
12:39
All the fans
27:01
Mm
27:01
... we mentioned, and this, that's a conversion of a piece by Guillermo and Mario.
27:05
Um, they mentioned that, uh, they- they mentioned that a source spoke to them saying that Xabi Alonso wanted a controlling midfielder, like the sort of Modric and Kroos, uh, template, to come in and, and play that really important role, and they, they haven't really found one.

34 MINS LATER

speaker_8ADVERTISER
61:30
Make sure to use our URL so they know we sent you.
61:33
[upbeat music] Hi, this is Matt from P1 with Matt and Tommy, and this episode is sponsored by eBay.
61:38
The cars you'll find on eBay are just different.
61:41
They come with a story that you can't wait to share, like this 1973 Dodge Charger on eBay that's been tucked away in an Arizona barn for over forty years, only fifty-five thousand miles, and somehow in great running order.
61:54
It even has a rare sunroof.
16:34
Sure.
16:35
So, I, we'll, we'll come on to City and Liverpool later, but I think you, you, you look at them and you don't see teams who are necessarily equipped to match the level of consistency that Arsenal have shown this season.
16:45
They, they have the depth that you mentioned there to, to deal with.
16:49
You know, if last season, if, if Gabriel had been out, and Gabriel was out for the last three months of the season and Arsenal struggled massively.
16:54
Jakub Kiwior came in and they got good results against Real Madrid.
16:58
But, um, in the league they really struggled and, uh, the season kind of became Champions League or nothing and, and it, it fell away, sadly, in the Champions League.
17:05
So, Martin Ødegaard's been out for a long time.

31 MINS LATER

48:15
Mm-hmm.

Scroll for more appearances

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.