Skip to main content
John Brewin

John Brewin

Nov 12, 2026

6:36
So perhaps you need to be totally immune to how Carrick was treated these last few days.
6:43
Well, there's always been this idea, haven't there, that Manchester United are the biggest club certainly in Britain and what you but there will always be someone that thinks they can turn it around that can and you have to have that self confidence don't you and I don't think Potts is lacking in confidence having said that he went to Chelsea and spent a season there a job that In the rearview mirror, it looks like he did okay there, but I went to a few games where Pochettino was manager and he was not interested in that job.
7:14
He was disengaged.
7:17
I was looking over a report I did from Brentford and the first quote that I pulled from it was him asking, it was my birthday today, are you going to wish me happy returns? When they just lost to...
7:29
lost to Brentford and was being booed by the fans.
7:33
It's not a happy day for me, but maybe you can cheer me up.
7:36
And it's like...

10 MINS LATER

17:32
look, that's quirky and interesting when things are going well, but when things start going badly, where's the lemonade? Where's your aura now, Potch? You know, this stuff, it can go either way.
38:08
Do you think he's going to make it? Yeah.
38:12
The raw materials are there, aren't they? But he remains very, very raw.
38:18
And I think what Jonathan's talking about there is he needed to start scoring.
38:23
Also, the difficulty tariff, particularly that second goal, you can't score those goals all the time.
38:30
It's more a question of him missing easier chances.
38:33
I saw Forrest at Ipswich.
38:35
I saw them against Coventry.

26 MINS LATER

64:56
Brighton were the better side, though?
38:35
Do you think he's going to make it?
38:38
The raw materials are there, aren't they? But he remains very, very raw.
38:44
And I think what Jonathan's talking about there is...
38:47
he needed to start scoring.
38:49
Also, the difficulty tariff, particularly that second goal, you can't score those goals all the time.
38:57
It's more a question of him missing easier chances.
39:00
I saw Forrest at Ipswich, I saw them against Coventry.

26 MINS LATER

65:22
Brighton were the better side, though?
32:23
How do you think Carrick has handled this frenzy of the last two, three weeks?
32:30
I think dignity would be one way of saying it, certainly dignified.
32:36
We saw a flash of him being frustrated of his own personal thoughts when he lashed out at Bruno in Como.
32:46
And I think that was deserved, you know, if a player... digs you out like that you know that's a breaking of the code isn't it when a player breaks the code and Carrick is in many ways the traditional English football man you know when you think of the clubs that he came from West Ham you know played at Tottenham and then went to Manchester United obviously served under Alex Fergus and David Moyes all these type of managers they're very traditional in their approach there is a behind the dressing room wall you ball out your teammates you let them know what you think Listen, there's a whole industry of those stories from those days.
33:24
I think you did a very lengthy discussion with the lads, one of which I've watched a couple of times, actually, you know, the United Days.
33:32
But we didn't hear about that until years later.
33:35
For that to be broken at this point, well, this is an ongoing process.

24 MINS LATER

Ashton YoungSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
57:35
know,
6:57
They're going to sack the manager first.
7:00
Yeah, when a club has that increasingly long list of managers getting sacked, then the players think they're protected.
7:09
There is a word out there that as part of the big Sir Jim Ratcliffe's attempted overhaul of the club, a few of those players know that their time is up.
7:21
It's a team, actually, that has grown a little bit old together.
7:24
Lissandro, the previous manager, Miss Grient was one of those defenders that was part of the 4-0 defeat at Brentford, which was supposed to be the end of Ten Hag in only a second game.
7:39
And the dressing room is not happy with what's going on above Michael Carrick, which Lissandro made clear last week, which actually further reduces Carrick's authority because Carrick was the caretaker given the job, but it appears to me as though the players are treating him still as a caretaker rather than the boss at this point.
8:02
His authority within the club is not particularly strong.

6 MINS LATER

14:07
yeah,
28:32
But I just wonder, is that true or have they kind of been swept away in the journey?
28:38
Well, I suppose there's a few things going on there.
28:42
I know that the City fans have felt that the soul of the club has been at least damaged by the ownership pushing towards a model that's followed at many other clubs, which is, you know, the more corporate element of things, you know, tourists in the ground.
28:58
I was at Old Trafford on Saturday and, you know, the mega store was doing serious business and that's where the money is made still, you know, even for a fading giant like that.
29:09
And, yeah, I think within City fans, certainly of my age, there perhaps is a bit of romanticising of trips to Lincoln and Macclesfield and all the rest of it.
29:22
But...
29:24
Having been swept along on this journey, I remember actually going to the 2011 FA Cup final and meeting a good friend of mine who's a City fan and his friends who had this look of disbelief after many years.

24 MINS LATER

53:37
would you say it's obviously too harsh to say they're self-driving cars anyone can get a tune out of that's such a well-run football operation but do you see some sort of star quality in Herzler for example or Keith Andrews?
56:58
up
56:58
again.
56:59
Maybe that one still cuts deep with Gav, I'm not sure.
57:04
But Keith continues to...
57:06
I mean, I actually went to the John Bruin fixture the other week, which was Brentford at Bournemouth.
57:14
And...
57:16
My impression of Brentford that day was just how powerful a team they are.

8 MINS LATER

64:57
Yeah,
57:20
up
57:20
again.
57:22
Maybe that one still cuts deep with Gav, I'm not sure.
57:27
But Keith continues to...
57:29
I actually went to the Ur John Brewin fixture the other week, which was Brentford at Bournemouth.
57:36
And...
57:39
My impression of Brentford that day was just how powerful a team they are.

8 MINS LATER

65:19
Yeah,
8:45
you know can you see him being sacked in the three week international break if they do lose
8:51
no No, because I don't, because that would be an admission of failure by the INEOS regime, which I don't think they readily accept failure.
9:02
They've done it before.
9:05
Well, they did it with Amarim, but they took the time to arrive at that scenario, didn't they? I mean, yeah, it's a fair point.
9:12
It's a fair point that there was a point where Sir Jim Ratcliffe was saying Amarim is here for the full term of his contract, and within a few weeks, Amarim was gone.
9:25
I would suggest, though, that Michael Carrick is not going to rock the boat in quite the same way as Ruben Amarim did, or Ruben Amarim is still doing it AC Milan, from what I can gather.
9:36
Yeah, I mean, that performance against Brighton in the Carabao Cup, I mean, you think back to Amarim's defeat at Grimsby, which was on penalty, so that can happen.
10:53
But that is bizarre though, isn't it?
4:20
That was an Irish three at the back.
4:21
Yeah, exactly.
4:22
[laughs] Well, yeah.
4:23
It, it, and it ju- When there's no outball...
4:26
And the thing is, I've seen England play that game before, and it doesn't often work, and it, it...
4:32
The weird thing is that Thomas Tuchel, no, it's not weird.
4:35
He was brought in.

13 MINS LATER

17:50
Yeah, yeah.
0:58
John, what do you make of it? Is Jeremy Doku in the right or in the wrong?
1:04
He's in the right, isn't he, surely, uh, as a family man attending the, the birth of his first child.
1:11
Uh, no man, or woman in particular, [laughs] no woman will miss it, but no man should miss that, really, should they, uh, unless there's extenuating circumstances.
1:21
We, we forget sometimes, don't we, that football is actually their job.
1:26
Now, if you are a normal employee, uh, in the UK, you, uh, you get one to two weeks' paternity leave.
1:33
Uh, and I don't think a footballer should be any different.
1:37
And I suppose you've gotta consider the esprit de corps within the Belgian camp.
3:00
Someone has texted John and said, "Is the World Cup, Cup," rather, "not an extenuating circumstance? Once in a lifetime for many, he could go on to have multiple children." It's quite a, it's quite an interesting take on it.
8:40
However...
8:41
I kind of don't
13:25
Football writer John Bruin joined End of Call and Off the Ball Breakfast and said this English side could falter.
13:30
Selecting his squad, he chose the players that had done well for him.
13:35
And there are a few strange selections in there.
13:38
If it comes apart for England, and it will come apart for England, that's my expectation, there will be selections like Jordan Henderson, Dan Byrne, John Stones... that really have to prove themselves to get through this Jordan Henderson hasn't played that much football really for Brentford towards the second half of the season but he's brought in as the good tourist again a cricketing term he's brought in because it is said and this is what I understand him and Jude Bellingham have a good relationship because it's about getting the best from someone like Jude Bellingham.
14:09
I don't think at any point he was not going to select Bellingham.
14:11
Bellingham is such a good player that you can't really leave him at home, but it's managing that situation and Henderson is one of those people that can deal with Bellingham.
57:24
What about City then, John? How much of a hole is Pep Guardiola gonna leave behind and can it be filled by Maresca?
57:29
Well, a huge hole, uh, quite obviously.
57:32
Um, listening, [chuckles] speaking to a couple, I actually have quite a lot of friends who are City fans and the talk of tears being shed and the, the emotions that they've all felt and, uh, you know, having to say goodbye to Bernardo Silva, John Stones, as well as Pep Guardiola, um, that's a big hole, uh, in, in the team that's dominated English football for the best sort of- It is a lot, it's a lot of, um, it's a lot of talent to walk out the door, uh, you know, in the same two minutes.
57:58
Yeah, absolutely, yeah.
57:59
And, and, and, um, yeah, Bernardo is a player that I really do have ultimate respect for.
58:05
I think he's absolutely fantastic and, well, not underrated because everyone knows how good he is, but, you know, when you see how often he's there when City have been at their very best.
58:17
Uh, and, and, and Stones will be the same until this season.

23 MINS LATER

81:05
What about Carrick then? What about United next season, John?
57:52
It's a lot of, um, it's a lot of talent to walk out the door, uh, you know, in the same two minutes.
57:58
Yeah, absolutely, yeah.
57:59
And, and, and, um, you know, uh, Bernardo i- is a player that I, I really do have a ultimate respect for.
58:05
I think he's absolutely fantastic and, well, uh, u- not underrated, because everyone knows how good he is, but, you know, y- you, when you see how often he's there when City have been at their very best.
58:17
Uh, and, a- and, and Stones will be the same until this season.
58:20
I mean, we...
58:20
He, he's going to the W- World Cup, [laughs] uh, but we're t- uh, but we're told, uh, Pep Guardiola saw no place for him in the team, which, you know, may ask questions of Thomas Tuchel, but that's one for, for, for Ed ahead.

24 MINS LATER

82:34
Were you as annoyed with that as Roy Keane seems to have been?
6:15
[laughs] Do you think Matt Busby's teams didn't respect the ball?
6:20
Think of it in, in, in, in Busby's terms and, and Busby is...
6:24
When I think of, and Jonathan talks of the golden age of managers, I think of Busby as the first of those.
6:31
And let me share some personal recollections of the great man, which are when I was at school, and I was probably eight or so, in school assembly they read out, would you call it a sermon, on the tale of Matt Busby, this sort of, his strength through faith.
6:47
And he, in the area that I grew up in, you know, in Manchester hinterlands, just beyond, he was a sort of demigod figure.
6:54
And I, on my first ever visit to Old Trafford through my dad's connections at Manchester Airport, ended up in the directors' box at Manchester United, sat on the next table to Sir Matt Busby and his son drinking a cup of tea.
7:09
And you are in the presence of someone who was a community leader in the way that Brian Clough was in the East Midlands, the way, uh, maybe Don Revie was, and the way that Bill Shankly certainly was.

16 MINS LATER

23:04
Harry Catterick.
5:25
That was the one that exactly the one that popped in my head when you said that.
5:28
Yeah, I mean, that was amazing.
5:29
One where I had to phone a desk and say, I think you're going to need an extra quotes piece.
5:34
And Rosena was pretty similar in that.
5:38
And Peter's right.
5:40
He couldn't really offer anything else.
5:41
And he is an intelligent guy.

6 MINS LATER

11:40
It's the default outcome.
5:12
That, that was the one that, exactly the one that popped in my head when you said that.
5:15
Yeah, I mean, that, that was amazing, one where I had to phone the desk and say, "I think you're gonna need an extra quotes piece." [laughs] You know.
5:21
And, uh, uh, Rosello was pretty similar i-in that.
5:26
And Peter's right, he couldn't really offer anything else, and he is an intelligent guy.
5:31
I was, I was actually at the huddle one as well, uh, when he was talking about... [chuckles] I mean, that, occasionally, you, you, you'd sit through, uh, Liam's press conferences and just think, "Mate, what are you talking about here?" And, and he's such a, an earnest guy.
5:46
Mm.
5:46
And he was really...
5:49
I, I don't necessarily blame him for what's gone wrong.
speaker_19HOST
62:37
Yes
62:37
...they, they draw, but they do, they're involved in entertaining games all the time.
62:42
It's kind of interesting.
62:43
Like, I mean, they-- Iraola, I think, is out of contract at the end of the season, right? So what do you think is gonna happen there? I mean, he's, he's obviously, I assume, he's a football coach.
62:51
He must be ambitious.
62:52
He must be looking beyond Bournemouth.
62:54
I mean, everyone else, you know, Richard Hughes and Surbani and Hyson and Kerkez, everyone's gone on to bigger and better things.

21 MINS LATER

84:05
Right.
64:01
Yes
64:02
...they, they draw.
64:03
But they do, they're involved in entertaining games all the time.
64:06
It's kind of interesting.
64:07
Like, I mean, I-- Iraola, I think, is out of contract at the end of the season, right? So what do you think is gonna happen there? I mean, he's, he's obviously, I assume, he's a football coach.
64:15
He must be ambitious.
64:17
He must be looking beyond Bournemouth.

21 MINS LATER

Donald TrumpSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
85:30
Right.
49:05
Mm.
49:06
It's, it, it's planned to the, to the Nth degree.
49:09
The one thing I would say is, uh, you know, when I go to a Premier League game every week, uh, I-The last five, 10 minutes, and I was at Bournemouth, uh, Sunderland at the weekend, are absolutely chaotic because these plans tend to come apart.
49:23
They can't last over 90 minutes.
49:25
They don't last, there was 12 minutes of time added on there.
49:28
They don't last.
49:28
It, it just becomes chaos, and, uh, it, it, th- football strategies in that way aren't sustainable.

9 MINS LATER

58:43
[laughs]
24:41
era don't mind them Miguel so let's talk Michael Carrick who is head coach interestingly John not interim head coach just head coach what do we read into that
24:54
Well, I suppose everyone's an interim head coach, aren't they, at Manchester United these days? So you may as well get rid of that interim part of it.
25:03
I was thinking the other day, actually, who was the first interim manager? And I think it was Rafa when he was at Chelsea.
25:11
Perhaps Joe Kinnear when he went to Newcastle.
25:15
Was that 2009-ish, something like that? Anyway, yes, Michael Carrick.
25:23
Well, Manchester United are back in the holding pattern that we're all familiar with.
25:27
And one that, again, casting back, I remember it was a game against Hull where...

24 MINS LATER

50:01
I think they perfectly captured the dynamic at this club.
82:02
I mean, what about the McLaren team that won the League Cup? Was that 2004 that they won it?
82:11
the Middlesbrough Arsenal game which stands out to me is I think was the first game ever on the Premiership which is the ITV's and it was Stevie Mac had just taken over and they got completely gubbed by Arsenal, and it was, you know, given some sort of glib debtism, you know, well, you expected more of this, you know, one of these...

15 MINS LATER

97:48
Do you need this to pull level?
97:50
Well, I've been to this game as well.
97:52
Or...
97:53
I probably sat next to Jonathan Wilson.
97:55
So, West Brom were last in the Premier League.
97:58
They were relegated the Pardew season, weren't they, when they had that trip to Barcelona and a taxi went missing, which I think was the 2017-18 season.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.