Skip to main content

Dan McDonnell

Soccer Correspondent for the Irish Independent and regular panelist on the Indo Sport podcast and LOI Central.

Nov 11, 2026

2:14
How would you assess this campaign from a footballing point of view thus far?
2:17
Yeah, it's probably, you could say, probably even par in some ways.
2:21
You know, it's been, like in the last month, you had probably the worst performance under Hamer, which was Kosovo away, you could argue, and then the best, the quote-unquote away game against Israel in Debrecen.
2:35
And then what followed after...
2:37
Well, I think the approach of management has been to attribute the bad points of what happened afterwards to the strain of the window, which may or may not be true.
2:46
You can't prove it.
2:48
It's leaning heavily on the psychological because it was a really good half against Austria and then a really bad half.
6:21
What have you heard about the last window?
1:03
What were your main takeaways from the occasion?
1:06
Yeah, look, it's still a great occasion on Cup Final Day.
1:09
Sometimes it's hard for the final to live up to the...
1:15
the enthusiasm around it.
1:16
And look, that is finals everywhere.
1:18
It can be the World Cup final.
1:19
It can be any final.
5:27
And kind of the main message from Mark Connolly in the post-match was just how they want to kick on now and not let, you know, we know they want it in 2022 and just to build on.
2:07
Saturday papers were very good yesterday, particularly in the end, though, Dan, he can talk about it more than me, but a really good piece of Power Cam and going down to his parents' house, was there something?
2:15
Yeah, like I went down to Power Cam, like I think, I don't know if Dave Snait had a piece of Michael Duffy, I was going to mention that as well.
2:20
I was sort of messaging this day going, typically he went to the Derry captain's house and I went to the Waterford captain's house, but the thing about the cup and Paul would notice is that The league has obviously got a lot more professional in recent years, which is great.
2:34
But there is still, to me, there is still an accessibility there, which is important.
2:40
And around cup final time, for me, it's a great time that you can actually get the scope to go and do like a proper profile piece with someone in the league and if you get your request in early enough and if you happen to know them over a period of time you actually do get the chance to I talk about doing the book and the unique thing about it is actually getting to be in someone's house and see what they are really like yeah away from the, you know, the stilted engagements with like other handlers and people in the room.
3:05
So I got to go to, you know, Paragaman's house and we went through, you know, 10 photos.
3:08
I asked him actually, could you pick 10 photos from your career to tell the story of your career? What's your favorites? And he really, like, he was like, oh, that's sort of different.

6 MINS LATER

9:41
I think...
15:13
I mean, was he getting up out of the table going, no, I don't want to, give me five minutes kind of thing?
15:16
Yeah, well, I, like in my head, I was like, this isn't, like you do obviously, the book, it appears in the second chapter of the book, but like I felt I needed to spend a couple of months around James before we could really, I wanted to deal with, it was easier to deal with some of the football stuff first and then build up to a position of comfort.
15:35
But like, this is where I would feel real, I feel real sympathy for James around how the, the therapy thing has taken off and has sort of been cemented and like people just sometimes just don't want to know the context and it's like a political slur this thing is fixed in time and a lot of people their association with James now is oh he said this and look that is the way of the world that's the world that we live in Often at times we're doing the book, I was like, you know, some of this stuff is going to be screenshotted.
16:02
We just know like, this is, this is what happens.
16:04
Like we were sort of joking about some of the aggregation sites.
16:08
I'm like, well, that's going to be there.
16:09
You know, I couldn't have a visit just particular one, but like there was a, like there was a particular day where I felt this was the time to do it.

19 MINS LATER

35:31
And how would you describe that person?
13:35
Dumb thing to do
13:35
...
13:35
I know it's a bit like the, look at the, and this terrible thing of what about-ry.
13:40
I'm not trying to draw equivocations or whatever.
13:42
But, like, the, uh, so it's like the Suárez T-shirts at Liverpool keep getting brought up every so often.
13:48
Like, Carragher will say something, and then someone will produce that.
13:51
Because that is another classic example of people in a crisis situation saying, "Well, here's what we do as a dressing room at this club," not thinking of the longer term consequence.

8 MINS LATER

22:01
But you wanna see, you wanna see him play.
5:50
But if this camp results in Jack Moylan being a player of international class and Rocco Vata moving from where he was, wasn't capped for 18 months because a lot of injuries to come through they're the pluses for me but the game itself was forgettable people watched or didn't watch this reasons this match for reasons nobody's going to want to re-watch this or have it to keep the tape of it it was poor quality it was it reminded me of a champion of a grudge match reminded me of Swansea City against Cardiff City or you know a local derby in League One very very a lot of crunching tackles no real quality from either team
6:22
Yeah, I just find it hard, though, to be too hard.
6:25
I'm not saying that you are being, like, I'd find it hard to be too harsh on Ireland for it.
6:29
Like, it's funny, again, this online world that we live in that I know you wrote about, like, I see it, like, after the game tonight, like, negative comments towards the Irish players, really strong ones in that world, and it's like... hang on here, this pendulum is just swinging far too much.
6:43
I do think that extenuating circumstances are a real factor, and even the fourth game of a camp, and as Hamer even referenced, the inability to almost, he said he used the word motivate because of the backdrop, which is unusual, and I think Irish players were very conscious, I think, of, of being disciplined, like Malumby was clearly being, as much as their coach disputed it afterwards, there was definitely an attempt to sort of target Malumby.
7:07
You know, like the amount of fouls he shipped in the first half.
7:09
And you could sense that probably Irish players were on their guard to not react.
9:38
I think
5:34
That probably is a fine for the FAI, but in terms of the overall context of the week and the group and the potential for the night, I think they'd be reasonably happy.
5:42
Yeah, I mean, I assume some of the FBI will be fearing, obviously, the strongest sanctions possible for that stuff, of course, because, you know, we portray UEFA as the ones who are the draconian measures, maybe they might be reasonable and assess on its merits, you know.
5:56
Yeah, look, I actually found, I don't know, I actually found it the hardest piece to write of the week, ironically enough, just in the sense that There was, to me, a mad feeling of anti-climax at the end.
6:07
There was actually more unease in the stadium, you have to say, in the last 15 minutes than there was at any point prior to that.
6:14
I think at one point the punters were irate over who it was that played a backward pass when they were trying to build play.
6:22
The crowd were really angsty and it was like, this is the familiar type of unease that you feel around the games.
6:30
It was a strange one because there's no doubt that if Ireland had won the game, you know, there would have been a sort of that degree of like defiance afterwards or that sense of this is unreal.
10:43
To go from that to, you know, conceding twice in the space of four minutes and absolutely, I know Finnazaz had a late chance, went over the bar, but to go from that to... to hanging on for a draw, is it the fatigue,
8:40
Yeah.
8:40
He met Gavin Bazunu at his club for an hour in August, right? The, that timeframe was mentioned.
8:47
Now, obviously, to put that out in the public domain, again, there's no, you have to read between the messaging of, of words.
8:53
You have to read between the lines.
8:54
An hour sounds like a very wide-ranging conversation.
8:57
Going to his club almost suggests, like, you went for a, uh, for a meeting, and that, of course, like, no, no, no concerns were raised within this time about the Israel game.
9:06
Now, I've since been able to establish, and others have, that that was a, not an hour-long conversation.

17 MINS LATER

25:50
What are you expecting in terms of reaction from the crowd?
5:13
I'm not sure if it quite was.
5:14
Well, it was a bit of a mic drop moment, I think.
5:17
I was looking back to Saturday, the press conference in Debrecen, which is a very significant part of this whole thing now, really, as much as it is, because that was a sort of a crisis management conference and a lot of things were said.
5:30
I'm just looking back at Hamer's quote when he was asked about, did you not tell us you had spoken to all the players that were called up? Sorry, players.
5:38
Goalkeepers are people too.
5:39
Did you not tell us you had spoken to all the players called up? And Hamer said, I called all outfield players.
5:45
It's not my connection to talk to the goalkeepers.

20 MINS LATER

25:44
What are you expecting in terms of reaction from the crowd?
26:46
Well, I was struck by, you know, not that the emails we get in are representative of everyone, but we do have a cross-section of listeners, and there was a good few emails in saying that they did feel the players were getting criticism that was disproportionate to what they were doing, um, which I did find interesting that a f- a g- a good few people emailed in with that view.
27:04
Yeah.
27:05
Yeah, and I think that sentiment will be out there.
27:07
And look, personally, and everyone has their own take on it, um, I definitely think, look, I don't think players are really equipped for the scenarios that they are put through.
27:19
Um, I, I think probably some of the discomfort around Saturday, which was, um, like an extraordinary day, like an extraordinary day, and there was just so much going on.
27:30
I, I think that there, there was a n- natural sense that, look, like the w- like Gavin Bazunu, like the Brian Kerr line about Gavin Bazunu being shunned, and I think that was effectively accurate on Saturday.
27:44
I'm not sure if it was accurate by Sunday, um, but a- as everyone sort of processed what was going on, I think there's a sense of, you know, people probably see things through the eyes of, "Well, h- how might I look now?" And, and there's a natural mechanism that kicks in then.

8 MINS LATER

36:02
What was it like in the stadium? What was it like covering that game? What was the atmosphere like just being in the ground?
1:36
Dan, firstly, what were your thoughts?
1:38
Yeah, like definitely like sort of an unsettling evening still and I appreciate, look, there'll be a wide range of opinions of people who listen and watch this and will have views about what we should talk about and listen, I respect that, you know, and almost like a sort of an element of plot twist when you have this sort of extraordinary performance from the Irish team after, you know, what Hamer, Halgrimson described, sort of described along the lines of the worst preparation you could imagine and real sort of strange feelings around the whole thing because you can't allow that to change, in my opinion, like to change your views around the event that you held beforehand.
2:20
Does that mean like a defeat would have been worse? I probably would have made that point in the build up, like there's almost a degree of pressure.
2:26
pressure on the players if you talk too much about the importance of the match and some kind of grudge context because what happens then if they were to lose that's not fair but obviously like you have this sort of um really heavy win um and and Yeah, I say unsettling again because that's obviously something that's existed around the week.
2:47
The event tonight, as you mentioned, the 100, 150 or so Israeli fans, there was some questionable chanting.
2:57
Definitely some sounds and were the subject of discussions afterwards from the Israeli fans who... at the final whistle despite losing 3-0 which is a terrible result for them in their sort of focus on the football context and some pressure for them at home given how hard it is perceived to deliver in this match still treated like heroes afterwards and almost a sort of show of patriotism and as you mentioned a couple of Irish fans in there a couple of odd chants from there as well too I couldn't quite grasp who was aimed at as well at the end but I think yeah like the whole day I mean there's the strangeness of walking up to the stadium I was a bit later up than you guys and I think we'd heard probably in the last couple of weeks you know talks at one point of a couple of thousand people being here and it was deathly quiet and an hour and a half before kickoff and as you said a complete COVID throwback yeah So that was the first part of the evening.
3:56
I'll let Aidan give his opinion on the event for all the years covering the Irish team, how it compares.
8:26
We'll talk about FAI politics and everything else in a minute, but football-wise, and now it's Israel who have to now go and face Kosovo and are potentially, it's now Israel are going to finish bottom of that group.
2:27
Dan, I suppose, as I said 11 hours ago, we got here and we were expecting the Irish press conference to start at 10.15. Of course, as people will know now, we were told 50 minutes before there was a delay to the afternoon.
2:38
Yeah, I'm just going to say for me, this is where we're recording this.
2:40
I think we should timestamp this.
2:41
We're recording this around 8.38 p.m. local time in Hungary.
2:46
That's 7.38 at home.
2:50
And I think it's possible while we're recording this, some people are watching us, some people are listening.
2:54
We might get a statement from Gavin Bozzini.

7 MINS LATER

10:15
Yeah, go on.
16:48
on Friday to discuss how they will proceed around the formalities around that game um but Dan I suppose on the pitch that was not a good night for Ireland at all
16:58
yeah and look it's not a good night at all and like it's hard to avoid like I mean the questions afterwards even for Hamer it's a sense of well do you think um what's going on around this is a is a distraction and I made the point in my written piece it feels like whatever happened tonight was going to be would have been a rapture round the bigger picture if Ireland win it would have been this is the bonding the unity this team has been galvanised by this and then if it's a defeat it's like well is this the reason and I think maybe that's too simplistic a way of looking at it.
17:34
I think it's probably veering into excuse territory because we are led to believe that the focus has been on the game this week.
17:44
Now look, I've no doubt that it's weighing heavily on some players.
17:48
I know I see there's a lot of grief aimed at Fenerbahce.
17:52
I feel a little bit like he is probably one player who must have a lot going on in his head this week.
17:57
I would make that point.
21:50
They look drained to me and I think they're going now to Hungary to try and put to bed, see how they're going to handle the next couple of days because there is another storm coming their way.
44:58
Pats beat them on Friday.
45:00
Yeah, they beat them well.
45:01
And this is the thing, like how has this opened up? We probably, I think maybe we would have spoken about, we definitely did speak about the, the Rovers exit from Europe.
45:10
And there would have been sort of a, like you always maybe can over-diagnose these things, but you're like, "Well, what, what does this mean about the league? What does this mean about the club?" What-- And, and in some ways, like it was, it was so bad at the end, in particular like the, how they played in Albania.
45:25
It was so bad.
45:26
There was that sense of, Jesus, it would have been deflating if they'd come back out at us and they suddenly just started, you know, d-d-dismissing everyone at home.
45:35
And it didn't look like that.
47:12
And what's the biggest issue with Rovers' form, in your opinion?
8:14
Yeah, I think it's a bit of that.
8:16
Yeah, no, I...
8:17
No, I am...
8:19
I think a lot of people acknowledged last week, I think, in the commentary around it, that this was almost like a testimonial to Katie, a thank you for Katie.
8:29
I still remember the judge's verdict in London in 2012.
8:33
I was living in an apartment in town on my own at the time and almost been down on... on my knees on the floor and the window was open to hear cheers from other apartments and stuff.
8:43
So it was a thank you for the national moment.

34 MINS LATER

42:49
So, I mean, if you're, you know, what a strange time if you're Ireland, you're like, oh my God, we've just, can we leave the ethnic cleansing genocide thing? And then you go and your home game is in Serbia of all countries.
8:02
I presume the FAI are extremely confident that one, the game goes ahead as planned, but secondly, the vast, vast majority of Irish players are going to play or are you hearing there may be some withdrawals?
8:15
Yeah, a little bit of an unknown around that second part now.
8:19
I think privately, probably players, a lot of players would have hoped that it, they wouldn't have faced what's coming now.
8:26
And it's inevitable.
8:26
It was always inevitable.
8:27
Unfortunately, once we reach September, that it will start coming to the players and maybe players, and I don't know, I don't want to generalise and there's a tendency of footballers and put them under the same, but there's a real difference of backgrounds with a lot of members of this Ireland squad.
8:40
Some who've, you know, who are from Ireland, as in they've lived all their life here and will be acutely aware of the feelings.

46 MINS LATER

54:47
Yeah, that'd
29:28
Yeah
29:28
... and France.
29:28
Yeah.
29:29
Interesting, Declan Rice also played against France, uh, for Ireland in, in 2018.
29:33
And, look, the parallels are, are there to an extent.
29:35
Obviously, there's different, uh, geographical situations [laughs] and, uh, not, not g- bogged down in that.
29:41
But the parallels are in the sense that he is someone who's been capped at senior level, um, you know, by one, by one team, and there's a situation where another...
31:39
Yeah.
18:26
What's the right question about Rovers? Are they having a, a little dip? Is this, um, something more prolonged? What's g- what's your read on it?
18:33
Yeah.
18:34
Uh, there's a couple of things.
18:35
There's definitely a couple of nuances about it.
18:37
Um- There, there has been a, a feeling all year that they've been vulnerable.
18:43
They're there to be shot in the league, and the reason that they're in control of the league is not because they've been good, it's that, that others have been bad.
18:51
Like, you know, Derry's been chaotic.

24 MINS LATER

42:53
Yeah.
21:48
Absolutely
21:49
... o- operation.
21:49
And, um, so as a result, I mean, and listen, I know this from my dealings, you know, often you will have a player who's with a certain agency, and you might know the agency, and you will, you would chat to people around, and it's a way of getting to him.
22:01
Bellingham's always existed as an i- as an island through his dad, who I think at times has, you know, he's been quite forthright, as I said, in resisting attempts to build any relationship with him and has taken offense and issue with things that have been said.
22:15
Now, there's other he said, she said elements to some of it that I can't speak about 'cause I don't, I don't know about the, the truth of them.
22:22
But certainly, that seems to be a big part of his and why he maybe wouldn't be as, you know, sometimes players w- can be protected by the agency relationships that, that they have.
22:31
And maybe Bellingham is just a little bit more out there, and the, the, the vibe that seems to sometimes exist around him is, seems to exist because of, yeah, the, some spikiness in his camp.

6 MINS LATER

28:31
Ancelotti
43:12
Like, football is so good at the moment.
43:14
Yeah.
43:14
No, I think obviously the hydration breaks have been unpopular and terrible, and we know the cynical reasons why they're there, but some of the other rules have made it better.
43:22
Like, it's moved quicker.
43:23
There hasn't been as much sort of time wasting and it's been like that's helped.
43:27
I also think as well that international football i- is, at the tournament level, is getting better because in a way the, the high end of the club game is so good now, but it's so well scouted and managed and arranged that there's something...
43:45
I know we're ta- there's sometimes a little bit more chaotic about the international game in a way.

11 MINS LATER

55:14
Yeah.
31:31
Is Dan McDonnell, uh, give me, uh, out of five stars, how much are you enjoying this World Cup 2026 experience, Daniel?
31:38
Um, I, I am enjoying it.
31:40
I'm enjoying [laughs] it a lot, actually.
31:41
Um, now I kinda wonder how much was that influenced.
31:44
I mean, I probably, I'd imagine it's heavily influenced by the fact that the, the Pico story, which was probably circled earlier on, um, it was, it was an obvious thing to do in the first week.
31:55
I dunno how you, you couldn't really do that in the first week, you know, to have sort of the ultimate sort of the Irish football angle in it.
32:02
But I mean, and I, and I, I mentioned this in a sort of a YouTube video I was doing.

17 MINS LATER

49:16
Yeah.
22:42
Yeah.
22:42
But in the past, like, it would've been sort of a main revenue driver for the as- the association.
22:47
They would've, when, when all the stuff was happening with the sort of Anthem Club and all of that, they would've been trying to advance some of that money, you know, to give them, you know, to sort of keep the show on the road somewhat.
22:56
Um, so, but, like, I mean, I did see the Simon Harris clip.
22:58
I haven't seen the full interview for context, but I, I saw some of the clips going around.
23:03
I do think a lot the, the government stuff on this has been pretty pathetic, um, because, like, as much as the, the government stance now appears to be that, uh, this is on the FAI to decide, we've had Patrick or Jonathan commenting on this, um, a couple of months back around the time of the draw.
23:20
And the FAI actually, when explaining why they were gonna proceed with the game, they were actually leaning heavily on their interactions with government.

7 MINS LATER

30:25
But do you have any sense, will, will players start pulling out of this game? Are you, what are you hearing on that front, or is it too early for that?
18:18
What's your understanding of where they are in this? Do they feel they've largely weathered the storm? Are they braced for more? Are they loath to even talk about it off the record?
18:26
Ah, they're br- they're braced for more.
18:28
They know, they know it's coming.
18:29
I think it's just something that'sIt's, it's in the distance, but it's obviously getting even closer and, and the World Cup isn't happening for Ireland, so maybe it's a little bit closer.
18:39
I think it's, I think it's a sleeping story at the moment, but I don't think it's gonna sleep.
18:43
I mean, I say it's a sleeping story.
18:44
You're reading out a story, you know, reading out developments that have happened this week.
21:54
Do you mean any fans or away fans or?
20:04
Yeah
20:04
... it's been a dramatic overreaction, um, partly because just racing has lost its confidence, and the Grand National has become the focal point for that.
20:13
Like, the, the modern changes, and there's been changes at various times.
20:17
Like 2012, it, it was a really difficult year where like Synchronized...
20:22
There was two horses, but in particular Synchronized, who was the Gold Cup winner, who before the race was quite distressed.
20:28
And you could see Synchronized was quite distressed.
20:30
Just got loose or, you know, was certainly...

8 MINS LATER

28:04
Big time.
32:36
Yeah.
32:36
They'd had, like, uh, two players leave the camp and all sorts of stuff going on.
32:40
I, I just think on their formation stuff and Hamer, like, I, I think, you know, wing backs are very important, and I think that one of the problems that we have, and just at the time that Gary was playing, like, you know, you list all the Irish full backs of that.
32:54
You know, there was, uh, you know, what was that famously with Steven Kelly? About 100 Premier League appearances or something before he even got a cap.
33:00
I think that's part of the problem now.
33:01
You talk about the Seamus Coleman situation.
33:03
Like, I, I would often think that, like, it's obviously a very demanding role, wing back, and that can often influence, you know, your, your attacking aspect or not.

5 MINS LATER

38:23
Yeah.

Scroll for more appearances

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.