Skip to main content
Jill Rutter

Jill Rutter

Civil servant

Oct 27, 2026

13:12
So what is this actually about, Jill? Does it work or is it headline grabbing?
13:18
Well, it's quite interesting the reaction that you've just had, which is, I think, probably right.
13:23
These are sort of... quite useful, but also quite small.
13:29
I mean, it might matter a bit more to some people.
13:32
I mean, you know, one of the things the government's doing is removing the cliff edge for carers.
13:38
So people who got the carer's allowance, if they earned one patent too much, then they lost the whole lot and stuff like that.
13:47
And the government's saying, no, we'll withdraw it not terribly generously.
18:10
And then if these reports end up being true, then when we hear the budget tomorrow, then that will be a move away from the manifesto.
32:06
We don't really see that so much in the UK.
32:08
Well, the American civil service is always different.
32:10
This has always had loads more political appointments than we have.
32:13
We confine ministers to having very few special advisors.
32:17
And most civil servants, I don't think they're not supposed to be neutral.
32:20
They're non-partisan, which means they will work for a government of whichever persuasion.
32:27
And, you know, and change when the government changes, you know, conservatives go, Labour comes in, you change.

6 MINS LATER

38:48
So can you explain how that name came about and how it's been used?
31:48
Did it?
31:50
So, uh, yes.
31:52
So we've got a very long chapter, as Alex indicated, so I will be relatively brief.
31:58
Um, I think that if you look at Brexit, the Brexit balance sheet on quality of government, I think, yes, to some extent, accountability is a winner from this.
32:08
I mean, the sense that we used to have that you could hide behind the EU and blame the EU for, you know, trade deals, regulations that ministers went and fought, uh, against but were imposed on them, might-- that we couldn't control our borders and our migration policy.
32:28
I do think, you know, in a sense, the promise of Brexit, that repatriating that would mean that we could get rid of the people if we didn't like the decisions we'd been, they'd been making.
32:39
I think, you know, you could say that that's probably a tick in the positive box that people can now, uh, hold domestic politicians to account for those decisions.
34:37
Yeah
29:35
He's also presumably getting some of those briefings that will never be made public, uh, at, at least as far as we're aware, on the sorts of things that prime ministers have to deal with in terms of intelligence, security issues, th- th-- Britain's nuclear posture, all those things, um, which are the moment a lot of people say is, is the sort of the time at which the reality of the, the weight of responsibility of prime minister becomes all too apparent.
30:05
apparent.Yes, I think that's the first thing that happened, so [laughs] I was assuming that had already happened, uh, because he's been inside Number Ten now for a couple of hours.
30:15
Um, so yes, you're absolutely right that the first thing is the security briefings and writing what we call letters of last resort to the commanders of our nuclear submarines, uh, about what they should do if it's impossible to communicate back to a UK that has been the focus of a nuclear attack.
30:34
So that's the first thing we make our prime ministers do.
30:37
I think partly to, partly because it should be their choice, but partly, I think, to impress on them the weight of the office that they now hold.
30:46
Uh, and then they get on with assembling their team, and we expect to see, uh, people walking up and down Downing Street and maybe an announcement-
31:23
What do you think that Andy Burnham could possibly do differently, which will mean that, you know, he's just maybe more effective at governing?
31:32
I think there are two things.
61:59
From your perspective, how has that translated into policymaking in practice?
62:07
I think that that's the Brexit promise that has been fulfilled.
62:11
Government now has much more control.
62:13
One of the things that's very noticeable is that much of that control has gone to the government in Whitehall rather than to Parliament.
62:21
Parliament's been quite willing to let government make laws with relatively little oversight from Parliament.
62:29
We see lots of what's called secondary legislation there.
62:32
There have been some battles with the governments of Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland about their powers.
64:17
How would you describe the relationship that UK has with the European Union today? You think that nature of relationship has settled now or is it still evolving? What's your perspective on
7:13
Just explain, what was the Common Agricultural Policy, which was effectively the framework for farmers when we were part of the European Union?
7:21
So the Common Agricultural Policy was, if you like, this really long-standing heritage policy of the EU Common Market.
7:30
It occupied a giant proportion of the budget when we first joined.
7:34
And we would say that it was designed to provide insurance Income support, production support to inefficient continental farmers.
7:41
That would be the sort of, you know, characterisation you would have seen back in the 1970s.
7:48
We saw sort of in the 1970s and 80s, all those big butter mountains, wine lakes, things like that.
7:54
as a result of production subsidies.
10:55
What impact have they had on British farmers?
31:48
Did it?
31:50
So, uh, yes.
31:52
So we've got a very long chapter, as Alex indicated, so I will be relatively brief.
31:58
Um, I think that if you look at Brexit, the Brexit balance sheet on quality of government, I think, yes, to some extent, accountability is a winner from this.
32:08
I mean, the sense that we used to have that you could hide behind the EU and blame the EU for, you know, trade deals, regulations that ministers went and fought, uh, against but were imposed on them, might...
32:25
That we couldn't control our borders and our migration policy.
32:28
I do think, you know, in a sense, the promise of Brexit, that repatriating that would mean that we could get rid of the people if we didn't like the decisions we'd been, they'd been making.
34:37
Yeah
33:08
Just explain what was the Common Agricultural Policy, which was effectively the framework for farmers when we were part of the European Union.
33:16
So the Common Agricultural Policy was, if you like, the sort of really long-standing heritage policy of the EU common market.
33:25
It occupied a giant proportion of the budget when we first joined, and we would say that it was designed to provide income support, production support to inefficient continental farmers.
33:36
That would be the sort of, you know, characterization you would've seen back in the nineteen seventies.
33:43
We saw sort of in the nineteen seventies to eighties all those big butter mountains, wine lakes, things like that, as a result of production subsidies.
33:51
The scheme was massively reformed in the early two thousands.
33:55
Actually, largely sort of British initiative to decouple payments from production.
36:47
So for example, the trade deals with New Zealand and Australia, what impact have they had on British farmers?
36:47
Why are we, um, burning through our prime ministers here?
36:51
Very interesting question.
36:53
I think it's, uh, it's many of the reasons that Rob was just setting out.
36:57
I mean, it is quite a difficult time to govern.
37:00
Uh, lots of European prime ministers Chancellors, presidents, whatever you like, are quite unpopular at the moment.
37:09
We see quite a lot of change going on, so the UK is not in a different category there.
37:14
I think, uh, Emmanuel Macron's very unpopular.
40:35
But sorry, my question is do you think, do you think the pressure will be on, um, him so much that it will be inevitable that he'll have to?
3:34
Jill, do you remember through the campaign, did you get a sense of the specifics of what the arguments were for why this might be of benefit?
3:42
No, there weren't really specifics there, but you have to remember that the dislike of EU regulation goes a long way back.
3:49
If you remember back to Mrs Thatcher's speech in Bruges back in 1989, she talked about we haven't just rolled back the frontiers of the state in the UK to have them reimposed from Brussels.
4:01
And successive governments, both Conservative and Labour, really didn't like some of the regulation coming out of Brussels.
4:07
They didn't like the fact that the EU European Court of Justice might, after action by the European Commission, find that the UK hadn't implemented EU rules properly, might fine the UK.
4:20
And I think there was a feeling, two sets of feelings.
4:22
One, that the EU did far too much regulation.
6:19
Did that end up happening? Yes,
17:12
... what do you think the wider impact will be of the ousting of Olly Robbins for broader Number 10 Whitehall relations? Is this a comparable low point in, uh, those relations to the tepid bath comments, uh, that Keir Starmer made?
17:27
Well, I think the interesting thing is, uh, you know, whatever, whatever Olly Robbins was doing, he was acting soon after appointment and soon after the Prime Minister had made the tepid bath comments.
17:38
You might think actually, you know, he saw his job then as to try and make this happen.
17:43
He says he was, you know, being pressured.
17:46
He thought he'd managed to prote- uh, retain the integrity of the process and, you know, hadn't come to a pressured judgment.
17:54
But, you know, it was very clear that the Prime Minister wanted them to get on with this, and the Foreign Office did do, did do that.
18:00
I think it is at a low point.

19 MINS LATER

37:26
It's an anonymous question we've had, but, uh, it says, "Is the prime minister ignoring the interests of British security in the way he is handling this matter?" And I guess you could read that either as a question about whether it was right to make the appointment in the first place, or what the consequences will be of the changes that are being made to the processes now, uh, as a result of this, uh, scandal.
12:02
Why do you think politicians find it so hard when they move in to feel like they're getting what they
12:06
want? I do think they have been peculiarly bad at this.
12:10
I mean, I think, you know, outstandingly bad in terms of getting what they want done.
12:16
Because I think if you looked at the coalition coming in 2010, their big top issue was we need to get the public finances back under control.
12:28
They had an emergency budget from George Osborne and they started with their long-term economic plan in 1997.
12:36
Tony Blair might have got quite frustrated, but Gordon Brown was doing lots at the Treasury.
12:42
I think one of the things that's been quite interesting is how...

31 MINS LATER

43:58
you know,
4:49
[chuckles]
4:50
Uh, absolutely not going to, not going to do that to him.
4:53
I mean, she was actually doing a sort of trade job in New York.
4:56
I think she was...
4:57
Was she the envoy to the tech sector? Some slightly weird job, which basically said, "Go out there and push the new sort of Britain," and then she came back and was Permanent Secretary of the Department for International Trade.
5:09
I mean, one thing Antonia does seem to do is to create very good relations with the ministers that she is serving.
5:16
Uh, you could say that, does she become sort of over-invested in their agendas? And some of the things, for example, that, uh, she was tweeting when she was Permanent Secretary of the Department for International Trade, you thought, "Well, really? Should you be tweeting that from an official account, Antonia?" It sort of quite sounds like propaganda.
8:56
And it may just be that Keir Starmer is self-aware enough to know that actually being chivvied along a little bit might not be such a bad thing either.
19:11
Jill, can we just very briefly look at those areas where it might have been regards being in our interest to diverge and whether we are still able to diverge in them, whether this talk is about maintaining that divergence?
19:24
So the big area that wasn't really on the table significantly on the 19th of May was the whole area of services, which is where the UK is very strong.
19:35
Now, the UK did want to make progress in some areas where, frankly, they were rather rebuffed by the EU.
19:41
The issue Peter Foster raised about professional qualifications, where I think they basically said we talk about.
19:48
and the issue of supporting creative artists who travel.
19:52
But it was notable, for example, that financial services, a really important sector, wasn't on the agenda and that is actually where the UK has shown that it wants to do different deals, wants to have a different regime, take a different approach.
20:06
And the UK wasn't trying to argue we should get back in and regain access to the European market.
24:31
Jill, can we look at what are the sticking points on the European side when it comes to cooperating with the UK? What do they really want and what do they really not want?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.