Skip to main content
Eric Goldman

Eric Goldman

Professor

Nov 16, 2026

3:29
And what is at stake here?
3:32
Well, anomaly at stake might be something quite simple.
3:36
If a service is distributing video and they are also using things like analytics or ad targeting, they could get consumer consent.
3:47
They could simply ask consumers if they're okay with this.
3:51
But really what's happening is that there are many businesses that don't want to do that kind of consent.
3:56
or if they do so, are going to create other issues for themselves.
4:00
And the plaintiff's lawyers want to sue them all.
4:42
Do you think we could see more kind of vintage laws like this spring back up for, you know, fresh modern interpretation? Yeah.
3:29
And what is at stake here?
3:32
Well, anomaly at stake might be something quite simple.
3:36
If a service is distributing video and they are also using things like analytics or ad targeting, they could get consumer consent.
3:47
They could simply ask consumers if they're okay with this.
3:51
But really what's happening is that there are many businesses that don't want to do that kind of consent.
3:56
or if they do so is are going to create other issues for themselves and the plaintiffs lawyers want to sue them all and so at stake here is potentially we could have an entire litigation phenomenon where every website with video is a potential defendant and the plaintiffs will look at ways to weaponize this law from a different era and find a technical violation and then go and ask for the damages specified by the statute so it really becomes like a litigation perpetual motion machine If the court greenlights a broad interpretation of the statute, there are many plans lawyers who are going to try to find a way to cash in.
4:42
Do you think we could see more kind of vintage laws like this spring back up for, you know, fresh modern interpretation? Yeah.
4:51
No doubt the plaintiff's lawyers are looking for a whole variety of tools in their toolkit.
16:15
Why is age gating so problematic for access to generative AI tools?
16:21
So I, I'm gonna answer your question, and that might be the last conversat-- question you get from me, 'cause I have a lot to say on that point.
16:28
But I did wanna make sure that we didn't lose a thought.
16:30
You said that we aren't talking about partisan control over chatbot outputs, and I am, and I think that that is the existential threat to, to the entire generative AI industry, that i-i...
16:42
So long as those outputs aren't protected by the First Amendment, they're not treated like the editorial expression of the people operating the technology, governments can force the chatbots to essentially say whatever they want, and that means that the chatbots become even worse at lying or making up information than they are today.
17:02
If we exclude that problem, then yeah, generative AI looks fine.
17:05
But I c- I don't wanna exclude that problem.

9 MINS LATER

26:29
I'm wondering if you would kind of detail that approach, and is it essentially a market-based approach? Is it that this is a, a form of kind of self-regulation, um, as opposed to anything that would reflect legal requirements or regulatory regimes?
12:28
Um, if you were going to be advising, uh, lawmakers on Capitol Hill on how to create a, a Section 230 equivalent for, for generative AI, what would be the principle that they need to follow?
12:40
So Section 230 says, to summarize very efficiently, websites aren't liable for third-party content.
12:46
And that principle has been the foundation of our modern internet.
12:50
If we go through and evaluate the things that we do online on an hour-by-hour, often minute-by-minute basis, the services that we're using constantly are essentially tools to allow us to talk to each other.
13:04
In fact, take for example this conversation, which is taking place via Riverside.
13:09
Riverside is protected by Section 230 for whatever goes wrong in this conversation.
13:14
I hope not much, but the conversation's just started.
17:01
Uh, we could always say, always talk about all the, uh, long-termist sci-fi, uh, level benefits, uh, later on.
4:09
Do you think those changes are significant?
4:12
The changes are important in part because META has resisted them for quite some time.
4:17
And META has obviously flipped internally and decided that they could live with these particular changes.
4:23
So the state AGs were able to accomplish something that regulators around the globe have had difficulty forcing META to do.
4:31
What's less clear is if these changes are in the best interest of the constituents that the state attorneys general seek to serve.
4:41
We don't know if any of these changes solve the, quote, mental health crisis.
4:47
We don't know if any of these changes materially benefit any population of users.
8:49
Is that what this is really about?
4:40
Do you think those changes are significant?
4:43
The changes are important in part because META has resisted them for quite some time.
4:49
And META has obviously flipped internally and decided that they could live with these particular changes.
4:55
So the state AGs were able to accomplish something that regulators around the globe have had difficulty forcing META to do.
5:03
What's less clear is if these changes are in the best interest of the constituents that the state attorneys general seek to serve.
5:13
We don't know if any of these changes solve the, quote, mental health crisis.
5:18
We don't know if any of these changes materially benefit any population of users.

10 MINS LATER

15:12
Is that what this is really about?
3:55
Is that the argument they're going to make is that these bells and whistles and dings somehow plays with our dopamine and that's what we're addicted to?
4:04
Partially.
4:05
You're on the right track, but there are other ways for social media services to create what you're describing as the bells and whistles that aren't just flashing lights or loud sounds.
4:16
For example, one of the alleged design defects is things like autoplay or infinite scroll, that there's no natural break in the consumption of content.
4:29
And so people are just continuing on autopilot to consume content that maybe they don't want.
4:36
And there's been discussion about things like the number of followers and the count or the number of likes that a particular post receives is another way being what you're describing as bells and whistles, some form of dopamine-inducing reaction that is measurable.
4:55
So those are all part of it.
9:14
And yet they hold TV and radio to a completely different standard.
18:56
The changes to the platforms that the state AGs are asking for, would they change the very essence of the way these companies' social media platforms work?
19:09
Unquestionably, the structural remedies that are being ordered by courts and also mandated by legislatures will change how social media operates.
19:18
What's less clear today is if they're going to change it in a way that will materially affect our willingness to use them.
19:27
And I'm going to give you an example because I think it's so helpful.
19:30
The New Mexico judge set a cap on the number of hours that a user could use the service in a month.
19:37
Now, that cap was pretty generous.
19:39
That's a lot of hours.

5 MINS LATER

25:02
The verdict was six million dollars.
9:23
Are the changes to the platforms that the state AGs are asking for, would they change the very essence of the way these companies' social media platforms work?
9:36
Unquestionably, the structural remedies that are being ordered by courts and also mandated by legislatures will change how social media operates.
9:46
What's less clear today is if they're going to change it in a way that will materially affect our willingness to use them.
9:54
And I'm going to give you an example because I think it's so helpful.
9:57
The New Mexico judge set a cap on the number of hours that a user could use the service in a month.
10:05
Now, that cap was pretty generous.
10:07
That's a lot of hours.

9 MINS LATER

19:06
and worldwide to limit them?
Elizabeth GrossmanMODERATOR
2:44
Just talk about what happened and what those rulings mean.
2:48
Um, hi, everyone.
2:48
Thanks for joining us today.
2:50
Uh, and, um, joining this conversation, which we scheduled immediately after the trials.
2:56
Uh, sorry, am I muted? Am I coming through okay? Um, and, uh, y- when we do that, you never know if it's still gonna be timely or not, but there's so much going on that continues to take place even today that, um, uh, we got lots to talk about from the past, we got lots to talk about in the future.
3:11
So thank you for joining us, um, for exploring this topic.
3:15
Um, let's start with the basic structure, that there are two, uh, consolidated cases moving through the California court systems, one in the federal court and one in state court.

40 MINS LATER

42:59
Um, but this is a new, uh, diagnosis because we've been pumped with so much dopamine over, and over, and over, and over, uh, that, that, uh, that really it, it's, I, I just don't think we fully comprehend the day in and the day out, uh, uh, uh, effect of what, of what the social media companies have, have, have essentially done here.
33:24
So do you think that this will lead social media companies to change the way they operate?
33:30
I think that it would be remarkable if social media doesn't change substantially over the next few years.
33:36
If the final outcome in a few years from now is that social media has retained the status quo it has today, I think that would be remarkable.
33:44
And it's not just because of the litigation, though, if the plaintiffs win any part of the litigation, almost certainly the court will order changes to the service or any settlement agreement would require changes to the services.
33:58
But the reason why I'm so confident that social media is under extraordinary pressure to change is because in addition to the litigation, state legislatures throughout the country are passing laws that are requiring structural and tactical changes to how the services operate.
34:15
And unless the services can also overturn all of those laws, those laws are actually the governing rules that will dictate how social media services operate.
34:25
So as a practical matter, the litigation is only one path towards change.

6 MINS LATER

40:34
Do you see a direct comparison?
35:30
Do you see a direct comparison?
35:32
Yes and no.
35:34
So let me reject the analogy, but then I'll come back to how there's some kernel of truths to it.
35:39
So in general, start with something like tobacco.
35:43
Uh, tobacco has no known health benefits to its consumers.
35:47
It's only either neutral to their health or it's negative.
35:50
Whereas with social media, we know that it has substantial benefits to its users, in addition to some users deriving potentially significant detriments from it.
37:53
Can you tell me more about that?
77:04
Okay.
77:04
Um, and they've been joining these lawsuits.
77:07
Um, the lawyers, of course, are helping them, and each trying to...
77:10
Each lawyer is trying to add to their portfolio of plaintiffs that they, uh, have, that they're representing.
77:15
Um, so but whether they're actually going to get any recognition from the court or money, they'll have to make their case eventually.
77:24
So that's part of why the, the trial was held that, that led to the verdict that came out this week.
77:31
What they did in the California State Court case is they said, "We're gonna pick three plaintiffs, so we're gonna do what are called bellwether trials.

8 MINS LATER

85:57
Mm-hmm.
5:41
One of the things that you're cited as, as looking at is the level of damages awarded in this specific case, and I think we discussed in prior conversations the context that there are other legal proceedings going alongside this in parallel with this case, but why focusing on the damages? Why is that important?
5:58
important?It allows the parties to start to estimate how much money are we even talking about.
6:04
And until we got a data point like the jury verdict, really, the parties couldn't even imagine, uh, any agreement.
6:13
They were so far apart.
6:15
Um, now we can start to quantify the numbers.
6:17
If there's three thousand plaintiffs that are currently pending, we're talking about roughly close to twenty billion dollars.
6:23
Now, those are numbers that are huge, and yet they are numbers that Google and Meta might think that they can afford.
8:18
Eric, what do you make of those arguments?
47:13
Is that a sort of useful strategy towards a solution here?
47:18
I think you need to be careful about using the term solution, because in order for us to talk about that, we have to be very precise about exactly what problem we're trying to fix.
47:26
There are a lot of problems in our society, a lot of problems plaguing kids.
47:30
And there are also problems of over-responding to the content online that looks a lot like censorship.
47:36
And so when we talk about solutions, we can't do that without talking about the problems.
47:41
Having said that, I think that we're going to see a battle of experts in these trials where both sides are going to bring in the best and brightest minds to tell their case to the jury.
47:51
We're going to hear from average Americans essentially plucked off the streets who are going to weigh that evidence and try and tell us whether or not they think there's a problem here that needs to be addressed.
48:02
Professor, in the course of proceedings throughout the trials, those that are kind of trying to come to a decision in them, those presiding over the case, to what degree do they have expertise in the technicalities behind this?
22:43
If the court allows the case to go forward, will the plaintiffs have to prove that Facebook or the other platforms led to the radicalization of the shooter? And how difficult will that be?
22:55
Definitely, they'll have to show that what we call causation when it comes to negligence.
23:01
I believe that that will also be relevant in the context of strict products of liability.
23:06
And it will be difficult.
23:07
And causation was also an issue in the federal appellate court ruling I mentioned from the Fourth Circuit.
23:13
And the court independently said there was not sufficient causation in that case.
23:17
And when we think about what causes someone to radicalize into a white supremacist, and even worse, what causes a white supremacist to then decide to engage in mass murder, There's so many things that contribute to that outcome.
25:01
is the easiest path for the appellate court here to send the case back to the trial court, saying the facts have to be developed more before we can make a decision? So
9:22
If the court allows the case to go forward, will the plaintiffs have to prove that Facebook or the other platforms led to the radicalization of the shooter? And how difficult will that be?
9:35
Definitely, they'll have to show that what we call causation when it comes to negligence, I believe that that will also be relevant in the context of strict products of liability.
9:46
And it will be difficult.
9:47
And causation was also an issue in the federal appellate court ruling I mentioned from the Fourth Circuit.
9:53
And the court independently said there was not sufficient causation in that case.
9:57
And when we think about what causes someone to radicalize into a white supremacist, and even worse, what causes a white supremacist to then decide to engage in mass murder, There's so many things that contribute to that outcome.
10:12
And it's very difficult to pull out one piece and say, that's the cause.

7 MINS LATER

17:20
The easiest path for the appellate division right now in this case is to allow the case to go forward and to say, you know, the facts have to be developed before we can make a decision on whether or not this is subject to the state's product liability law.
Talon StradleyCORRESPONDENT
7:16
Sometimes, the meaning of certain emojis can get pretty dark and even veer into criminal territory.
7:22
Let me give you an example of an emoji that has slang usage.
7:26
The crown emoji has very specific meaning in the sex trafficking context.
7:33
It's basically used to signal the relationship between a pimp and a sex worker, where the sex worker is either admitting to some subordinate relationship or is being offered to take on that subordinate relationship.

8 MINS LATER

Talon StradleyCORRESPONDENT
15:24
They also looked at past contracts that were approved in a similar way, with a brief "Okay" or "Yup" sent over text.
15:31
And so the court says, looking at the emoji in the context of the conversation and with the context of past dealings with each other, it looks like that thumbs up was an assent to the contract, but I think that the court's methodology, not just to look at the emoji in the abstract but to put it in context, was exactly what we would hope the courts would do.
15:54
And I think based on that, to me, it looked like the court got the right outcome.
10:42
So let's move into the harm side of it, starting with the segregation side.
10:48
Yeah.
10:51
So the paper lays out five harms that are going to be embedded in any effort to segregate children from adults.
10:58
It's not a problem unique to age verification versus estimation.
11:04
It's not a problem that's unique to device level authentication versus each publisher doing it for themselves.
11:11
Like this is just endemic in any process.
11:16
You mentioned the privacy problems that in order for us to figure out a person's age, we need to know enough about them to be able to make that judgment.

20 MINS LATER

31:51
I do.
22:44
Santa Clara University law professor Eric Goldman thinks he knows why.
22:49
There's a number of societal-wide changes that have occurred over the course of Section 2.0's life that have taken it from being something that many people thought was a good idea to now being nearly universally disparaged.
23:04
The most obvious one is what you and I would call the tech lash.
23:09
This is the widespread pervasive negative feelings towards the large internet companies, which is a combination of the scope and power they have, which inherently raises suspicion, as well as a number of unforced errors that they've made that over time have diminished our trust

7 MINS LATER

30:13
So I think it would be much more like the traditional media, but on computers.
30:17
In other words, there'll still be content on the Internet, but instead of it looking like social media, it's going to look more like Netflix.
30:24
where there'll be professionally produced content and large databases of it that we will enjoy and value.
30:30
But it won't be us talking to each other.
11:38
Yeah.
11:39
I don't know who pays your bills.
11:41
I'm about to name some names, which might blow up your economic strategy, so sorry about that.
11:48
I think you're referring to Twitter slash X and Facebook slash Instagram, both of which have made concerted efforts in recent times to dial down the amount of content moderation that they're doing.
12:01
And they're really doing that in two ways.
12:03
One is that they're deregulating certain areas.
12:06
They're removing restrictions on user conversations that they had previously implemented.

11 MINS LATER

23:28
Like, how do we navigate all that?
6:20
What was the standard of scrutiny that the court used in analyzing the ban?
6:26
What the court did is that they said that this law was content neutral, not content based.
6:33
And they said that all it does is just dictate who can own TikTok, and that's a content-neutral way of controlling speech.
6:42
To me, that's just mockable.
6:44
That's ridiculous to think that determining the owner of a speech venue has no impact on the speech that will be available on the venue.
6:52
We see that all the time when media companies change ownership.
6:55
New owners come in, the policies of that publication change.

7 MINS LATER

13:32
And what's ironic is that the most popular apps so far for TikTok users looking for an alternative are also Chinese-owned.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.