Skip to main content
David Lat

David Lat

American lawyer and author

Nov 6, 2026

22:54
Is this also about a broader change in like the whole economy and the whole culture about money?
23:01
I totally agree.
23:02
I would say, so I've been writing about the law and the world of law firms for a long time, first at this site Above the Law, which I started, and now I have a Substack newsletter, Original Jurisdiction.
23:14
And over the 25, 30 years I've been following this world, there's been a general trend away from law as a profession and more towards law as a business, the businessification of everything, which, again, is a larger trend in the broader economy.
23:28
It's less about the workers.
23:30
It's less about the cultural values.
23:32
It's less about advancing this noble goal of, I don't know, making AI serve humanity or something like that.

16 MINS LATER

39:30
And if you have fewer of those people, if you don't have work for them to do to gain the experience, how do you get to the point where you have a partner in the waiting?
2:11
I know there's so many different ways too, but have there been trends that you've noticed? Oh, definitely, definitely.
2:18
I mean, I think first of all, one thing that has happened, and this is not limited to law, is just the pace of everything has increased.
2:28
The pace at which deals get done by transactional lawyers, the pace at which law firms grow, the pace at which compensation increases, everything is just faster.
2:40
And a lot of that is fueled or lubricated by the spread of information.
2:45
For example, one reason that I think associate pay raises spread faster is because now when something happens in New York, thanks to Above the Law and other sites, associates in other parts of the country instantly know that there's a new going rate for first year associates.
3:00
And so information just travels faster.
3:03
Law firms see what their peers are doing, and they can now jump on that bandwagon faster if they want to, again, because information moves more freely.

9 MINS LATER

11:45
Your post on rankings of the circuit courts, could you walk through what some of the metrics were that you looked at that people were talking about when it comes to that? Maybe what the top three circuit courts would be in your hypothetical rankings?
12:24
So talk a little bit about how you staff things at OJ.
12:28
So I do have a leaner team than SCOTUSblog, and intentionally so, I would say.
12:33
When I was at Above the Law, I actually had a sizable team.
12:37
There were four to five full-time writer-editors.
12:40
We had folks who did technology and who handled ad sales, because Above the Law was part of a larger company called Breaking Media, in which I still have a small stake, but I'm no longer editorially involved.
12:53
We also had dozens of outside columnists, like SCOTUSblog, who would focus on different practice areas or different practice environments.
13:02
We had in-house writers.

10 MINS LATER

23:33
There's a lot of business in there, right? So talk about those skills and, and how you developed those.
25:53
So is civility a value in and of itself, or is it a value that actually feeds judicial independence?
26:01
Well, let me try to answer it this way.
26:02
First of all, um, this relationship that Judge Griffith and I are talking about was not just the two of us.
26:09
Um, during those decades, there were other of our colleagues who approached the job the same way.
26:15
It was an unusually collegial court and composed of judges with very different, uh, political perspectives, but when it came to judging, we were all basically, uh, following the same rules.
26:29
But Sarah, I think you've made a, a good distinction here between civility and, and judicial collegiality.
26:36
Civility is important.

13 MINS LATER

40:04
Will you tell everyone, um, the just basics of this? By the way, I do think it's a really good story, and I, I want you to tell it.
13:36
[laughs] And David, I am sad to say that I threw away the socks a few years ago, and I owe you a nice pair of socks.
13:45
Well, it's, uh, great to be here.
13:47
[laughs] I, uh, am looking for my socks.
13:51
Uh, so a- as, uh, as Vindictive Opinions listeners know, I'm a, I'm a, a frequent guest guest of the show, and I think I am often too agreeable.
14:02
I think I am often agreeing too often with Sarah and David, and so I have come ready to rumble.
14:09
I am going to be the disagreeable person on this panel, so I'm gonna disagree with all of you, uh, even though you're all, uh, quite brilliant.
14:16
So, uh, I'm gonna start with David's point about the culture wars.

49 MINS LATER

63:01
[laughs]
2:09
Where has that all shaken out? Has there been, you know, is there a verdict on whether the right business choice was to fight or fold?
2:16
So I think it depends on what your business is.
2:20
One thing that's been very interesting to see in the world of big law is law firms are sort of sorting themselves into separate buckets.
2:27
There are some firms that are focused more on transactional work, deal work, mergers and acquisitions, and some firms that are focused more on litigation.
2:35
And it seems that for the firms that are focused on transactions and deal work, which were really represented by those nine firms that decided to settle, It's been kind of business as usual for them.
2:46
We saw the American lawyers' statistics or data on profits per partner out of those firms, and it seems that those firms are still continuing to do well.
2:59
Out of the nine firms that settled, seven of the nine saw double-digit revenue growth last year, and only one of the firms saw decline.

32 MINS LATER

34:50
And then there's been the question of, well, where are we going to get the mid-career lawyers if the firms decide it's no longer useful to hire someone who has no experience?
56:54
Text alone."
56:55
Well, in defense of the dif- dissenters, they hang their hat on text, too.
57:00
It's just different text.
57:01
Because they would say, they would say, "Look, Congress created the Sentencing Commission," and this is just from Justice Sotomayor's dissent.
57:09
The first word in her dissent is Congress.
57:12
"Congress directed the US Sentencing Commission, not this court, to define what constitutes extraordinary and compelling reasons for incarcerated individuals to receive a sentence reduction under the Compassionate Release statute." And as you mentioned, the Sentencing Commission did come up with a rule that is not totally, oh, everybody ...
57:33
It's not like Oprah, you get a car, and you get a car.

7 MINS LATER

64:33
Can you imagine typing that up, by the way? "Hi, um, I have reason to believe that my judge has been having sexual intercourse in chambers because I can hear it through the walls."
25:48
So David, your thoughts?
25:51
You mentioned, David, the UN Security Council and the, the five permanent members of it, and you have to recall that w- any one of the five permanent members can block the UN Security Council from adopting a resolution.
26:07
So over the years there have been attempts to, for example, uh, disapprove or condemn some action of the United States, but the United States can just veto that.
26:17
And so if there were some attempt in the UN to express disapproval of this Venezuela operation, well, the United States could just veto it.
26:24
And so y- you raise a very important point, David.
26:27
What happens when one of the five permanent members is the one that is allegedly violating international law? Look at Russia and its incursion into Ukraine.
26:37
You're not going to get a UN resolution condemning that, and so you do end up with this kind of double standard or this sense that a, a certain country might be "above the law." Uh, it's analogous in some ways to what some people claim is happening domestically, where the Trump administration takes certain actions and then dares someone to try and stop them or to punish them after the fact, and you could argue, well, maybe that's kind of a version of what is happening here.

9 MINS LATER

35:49
Your thoughts?
11:02
Do you think, um... how do you think they did and what's your prediction?
11:06
So, I'll actually disagree with you.
11:07
I feel like usually we, uh, agree so let's, uh, mix it up.
11:11
I actually thought this went pretty well for the tariff challengers.
11:15
I think that Solicitor General Sauer got some pretty tough questions and surprisingly tough questions from Justice Gorsuch.
11:22
And so, uh, I actually thought this went pretty well and I will say, um, you know, full disclosure, I'm, I'm, you know, friends with, uh, Neal Katyal, but I think he did an excellent job.
11:31
He is a liberal advocate, but I think he speaks fluent originalese or textualese or whatever you want to call it.

38 MINS LATER

50:08
That- that is just something that happens, you know?
14:16
Basically, they call it the, you know, the anti-Bruen or the un-Bruening of the Second Amendment (laughs) wherein, like, so much is private property that you would never really be able to conceal carry if every single place you'd go into or walk on, you wouldn't be able to private carry unless there's a, conceal carry, sorry, unless there's a posted sign telling you you can, which nobody's gonna do.
14:40
And so this is the question presented: Whether the Ninth Circuit erred in holding that Hawai'i may presumptively prohibit the carry of handguns by licensed concealed carry permit holders on private property open to the public unless the property owner affirmatively gives express permission to the handgun carrier.
15:03
I just wanna highlight the "open to the public" language.
15:06
So, for example, one of the things that came up before the Ninth Circuit is a bank, and whether or not, if you have a concealed carry permit, can you bring your gun into a bank if the bank itself does not want you to do that? Because there is this distinction between, I guess you could call it private-private property, private property not open to the public like my house or something, versus private property that is actually freely open to the public, and maybe a bank is, is stacking the deck against Second Amendment supporters because people just think of bank robberies, but what about a mall, for example? Um, you know, there are, it's, it's very, very public in a mall.
15:48
I believe there is a circuit split on this issue specifically because there was a case out of New York called Antonyak, uh, v. James, Tish James being the attorney general in New York, and New York, like California and Hawai'i, had passed a post-Bruen gun law that did a lot of things, and one of them regulated, uh, carry, concealed carry on private property open to the public, and I believe the Second Circuit actually went the other way, uh, as noted in Judge Graber's opinion in Walford, um, so I guess there is a split on that issue.
16:30
The other thing that's interesting is, um, they seem to be, I guess you could kind of say, taking their time on the Second Amendment stuff in this sense.
16:40
If you look at Walford v. Lopez, the Ninth Circuit opinion, this is a pretty sizable opinion.

32 MINS LATER

49:05
So David, what were some of your fun takeaways from this before we go through a glossary of judicial philosophies that we can maybe assign judges or professors to?
14:18
Basically, they call it the, you know, the anti-Bruen or the un-Bruening of the Second Amendment (laughs) wherein, like, so much is private property that you would never really be able to conceal carry if every single place you'd go into or walk on, you wouldn't be able to private carry unless there's a, conceal carry, sorry, unless there's a posted sign (laughs) telling you can, which nobody's gonna do.
14:43
And so this is the question presented: Whether the Ninth Circuit erred in holding that Hawai'i may presumptively prohibit the carry of handguns by licensed concealed carry permit holders on private property open to the public unless the property owner affirmatively gives express permission to the handgun carrier.
15:05
I just wanna highlight the "open to the public" language.
15:08
So, for example, one of the things that came up before the Ninth Circuit is a bank, and whether or not, if you have a concealed carry permit, can you bring your gun into a bank if the bank itself does not want you to do that? Because there is this distinction between, I guess you could call it private-private property, private property not open to the public, like my house or something, versus private property that is actually freely open to the public, and maybe a bank is, is stacking the deck against Second Amendment supporters because people just think of bank robberies, but what about a mall, for example? Um, you know, there are, it's, it's very, very public in a mall.
15:51
I believe there is a circuit split on this issue specifically because there was a case out of New York called Antonyak, uh, v. James, Tish James being the attorney general in New York, and New York, like California and Hawai'i, had passed a post-Bruen gun law that did a lot of things, and one of them regulated, uh, carry, concealed carry on private property open to the public, and I believe the Second Circuit actually went the other way, uh, as noted in Judge Graber's opinion in Walford, um, so I guess there is a split on that issue.
16:32
The other thing that's interesting is, um, they seem to be, I guess you could kind of say taking their time on the Second Amendment stuff in this sense.
16:42
If you look at Walford v. Lopez, the Ninth Circuit opinion, this is a pretty sizable opinion.

31 MINS LATER

47:37
So David, what were some of your fun takeaways from this before we go through a glossary of judicial philosophies that we can maybe assign judges or professors to?
14:10
So take us through the decision process again to maybe pivot again in your career because with all the things that you mentioned, like that seemed to be like the best fusion of all your core skills and abilities and interests to kind of, you know, start and run above the law.
14:27
Yeah, so it's interesting.
14:28
I think what happens often for folks in their careers is people change, your needs in your life change, your professional aspirations change.
14:38
And so for me, by the time, I guess I would say 2019 rolled around, I had been at Above the Law 13 years.
14:45
And I think part of them was a little burned out on writing.
14:50
One thing to know about Above the Law is the pace is pretty relentless.
14:54
The site publishes 15, 20 stories a day.

17 MINS LATER

31:51
What advice would you give to those that have budding interests or desires to write or to follow a path that's outside of traditional practice of law after having gone to a firm or something like that? I'd love to hear.
24:33
Yes.
24:33
Shurtleff is the case about the flags in front of Boston City Hall, and they wanted to raise a Christian flag.
24:40
And then the Satanists came along and said, "Well, what about the Satanist flag?" And finally, they ended up with a sort of, "This is why we can't have nice things" solution where they said, "Okay.
24:50
Only the Massachusetts or the Boston flags will fly." So here, I agree with you.
24:56
I share your concern.
24:58
If we are now suddenly going to see applications for charter schools from Wiccans, some schools may say, uh, some states may say, "We're not gonna have charter schools at all." And remember, nobody is denying the, uh, uh, power of a state to say, "No charter schools," even the conservatives.
25:15
If a school wants public education to be administered strictly by public schools, that can be done, and I believe there are something like 46 states that have charter schools, but that means there are four that do not.

32 MINS LATER

57:04
it doesn't feel that way, I guess, because I'm not in a vacuum.
15:19
Defend it.
15:19
(laughs) So I just don't think that's the case, and this is partly an empirical question so let's look at some data.
15:28
We have had cameras in the court, in the federal appellate courts, in a number of them at least, including the court where I clerked, the ninth circuit, for years now, and we haven't really seen these types of problems.
15:40
I actually am kind of surprised that we haven't really seen viral clips from these arguments, but we generally haven't.
15:47
So I think that's part of it.
15:49
I think we just don't have any kind of factual basis for thinking this kind of thing would happen.
15:55
Um, and then the other thing I would point out is you need to look at the people who would be involved.
20:05
(laughs)

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.