Skip to main content
Andrew Leach

Andrew Leach

Economist

Oct 2, 2026

Dalton McGuintyMODERATOR
33:44
Can these issues be addressed by a fair-minded federal government that brings an earnest commitment to respect Alberta and Albertans and an earnest commitment to ensure it does not, by way of precedent, ultimately weaken the Federation?
34:05
I think the answer to that is yes.
34:06
It has to be yes.
34:07
And I think we're seeing that.
34:09
I mean, we're seeing bits and pieces of that already.
34:10
Prime Minister Carney, big announcement this morning with respect to energy infrastructure, that for 10 or 12 years in this country, we changed the conversation around economic development in Alberta, energy development in Alberta, from one where Alberta was pushing forward with development that made sense or that they were interested in to Alberta asking permission and that we ended up with long drawn out both administrative and legal processes that were challenging development opportunities in the province and sitting back and feeling like you have to ask permission from Ottawa to do the things that you know you have people banging at your door to say I would like to build something here changes that relationship and you know our major industry became uh really a you know a focal point of a very important debate over climate change but became one that was largely i think outsized and you saw successive governments the harper government the trudeau government and now the carney government with different pieces of legislation to try to respond to that But as you said earlier, it's not just about laws, right? It's about how we talk about these things.
35:24
And I think one of the things you get really down to it, you say, what is it that was in the craw of Albertans and how could you change it? It was the mentality of not we are, you know, making a decision in the best interest of the country.

13 MINS LATER

48:51
Like all my family, even my family in Ontario would say things that were just kind of appalling, really.
10:45
Do you think, do you think that Canada still has an effective climate change policy here, or can we more or less assume that our climate change policy is always gonna be dictated by our incentives?
10:56
I mean, I th- I think we have far less effective climate change policy than we did a couple years ago, and a much lower expectation for effective climate change policy.
11:07
Um, assuming that we see, uh, Prime Minister Carney actually strengthen and put some foundation under the industrial carbon pricing regime, we definitely won't have no carbon pricing.
11:18
We won't, uh, definitely have no climate policy.
11:21
You still got clean fuel regs, which was not my, my favorite policy, but those are still in place.
11:25
You have big, you have the government shifting to bigger spending on climate priorities, uh, electricity, for example.
11:32
So I still think we have it.

31 MINS LATER

42:19
So, like I'm wondering if you can kind of talk about, like, using oil as a lever in that way.
9:02
So if there's pushback, then where do you think that pushback is going to come from? What will the arguments be?
9:07
Well, I think the pushback starts probably on, on, you, you mentioned environmental groups at, at the front end, so opposition to the, the direct environmental effects of the pipeline, and then of course, uh, to the, uh, oil sands development that's going to, going to fill the pipeline.
9:21
So the pipeline has become, I guess, probably since 2010, early 2010s, fights against pipelines have really been proxy battles against the, uh, against the extraction of oil sands.
9:33
And so I think we're gonna see that again with a lot of attention, and you saw it already in the, the proposal from Alberta to say, you know, this will induce new development that will increase greenhouse gas emissions.
9:44
Prime Minister Carney talked about it in his, uh, uh, forward guidance video last week to say, "This is going to put us on a higher greenhouse gas emissions trajectory than we would have otherwise been on." So I think that's probably the, the, the one important front in, in the fight that will follow, and then also coastal impacts.
10:02
So, uh, BC concerns and, and I think broad Canadian concerns about the risks of, of a spill, the, the damage that could be induced by more frequent, larger tanker traffic off Roberts Bank, et cetera.
10:16
So, uh, so I think those will be the two, the two big fronts.
11:29
We're gonna whip up public sentiment." But how can they do that if, as you point out, the atmosphere among Canadians, even the support from opinion polls is completely different now?
111:27
So if the tax shouldn't dissuade an investor, what is the point of it?
111:36
[laughs] So that's...
111:39
The industrial carbon price, essentially what you're trying to do is you're not trying to disadvantage the output, you're trying to make it make financial sense to do, to produce the output at lower emissions.
111:49
Because if all we do is send oil production or steel or, um, petroleum refining or whatever offshore and then re-import the products, it doesn't help the climate, it doesn't help us.
112:01
And so the idea of that price with...
112:04
Essentially what it does is it gives you credits for every unit of output you produce, and you pay a tax on every unit of emissions.
112:11
So yes, the average cost is really low, but if you can hold your output constant and reduce your emissions, you save the full value of the carbon price.

11 MINS LATER

123:20
Is that true?
13:53
Where, where, where does that leave us?
13:55
Well, I think it leaves us rethinking a lot of...
13:58
You know, we are seeing that acceleration on the climate front.
14:01
We are seeing, uh, us moving further away from those global goals on, on the climate front, whether it's 1.5 or 2 degrees C.
14:09
Uh, you know, these were always very, very challenging, and I think some of the, what we're seeing today, so the Strait of Hormuz, uh, disruptions, 1/5 of world oil supply, p- and then add onto that the gas impacts and others, that type of cut just on the oil side is about what we did at the peak of the COVID lockdown, sort of March to May 2020.
14:30
Um, that was about 20 million barrels a day.
14:33
And so think of how much that took out of all of our lives, but we were talking about doing those types of reductions in oil use i- if we were gonna meet the most more aggressive climate change goals, it was that over and over and over and over again.
17:15
Mm.
10:07
And as you noted, they were not all that far apart in the election, you know, and there's still regional differences in the country.
10:15
Yeah, I think when you look at the policies, the divergence isn't as large as people might think.
10:21
But where you really are seeing the differences is the degree to which I think the previous liberal government was blamed for a lack of advancing energy projects across the country, which are primarily of importance, I think, to Alberta and Saskatchewan directly.
10:39
So there's really a feeling here in Alberta where I am and also next door in Saskatchewan that the policies of the Liberal government, number one, really hamstrung the growth in the energy industry, and number two, that there really isn't a recognition of the importance of that industry or particularly the oil and gas industry in the rest of the country, that the Liberal government was focused on whether it was emissions targets or forcing clean electricity and such things, and really not paying attention to what that would mean on the ground in Alberta.
11:12
And you have a very, well, you have in both Alberta and Saskatchewan quite right-of-center governments that have, I think, and this is not new, but have used that strategy conflict with the federal government to essentially preserve and enhance their own popularity on the domestic side.
11:32
So now that's been ratcheting up, and the latest ratchet is very much this question of national unity.
11:39
You saw just this week both premiers in Alberta and Saskatchewan saying, well, you know, we're not really talking about supporting a referendum on separation, but if... residents want to pursue that then you know that's their right and we'll amend the legislation a little bit to make it easier for them and then we'll see where it ends up so there's there really is a little bit of at least nodding and winking towards that uh towards that possibility my hope of course is that it's uh it's going to wane very quickly over time that the premiers will realize there's not a lot of acceptability for that, but the numbers are real.

24 MINS LATER

36:45
And perhaps it may even be ultimately affected in a big way by the trade decisions that the nation, that Ottawa is forced to make.
9:34
How has Canada viewed all this activity in the U.S.?
9:37
Well, I think in Canada's case, there's a number of things going on.
9:41
The tariffs obviously created an economic shockwave.
9:44
The level of uncertainty, they were on again, they were off again.
9:47
Now they're kind of half on because we have aluminum and steel tariffs, which affects us dramatically.
9:52
But then there's also this overriding 51st state sort of Canada can't exist as a viable nation without the U.S. And that's, I think, really shaken people in his Fox interview in advance of the Super Bowl.
10:07
President Trump said the U.S. might not defend Canada in the case of an attack, which is pulling the NATO commitments into question and all of these sorts of things which we haven't really heard before.

6 MINS LATER

16:16
So what do you think, I mean, what does that conversation actually look like?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.