Skip to main content
Martha Hall Findlay

Martha Hall Findlay

Businesswoman and former Member of the House of Commons of Canada

Nov 2, 2026

11:19
Where could a common statement of principles like we're proposing actually change behavior? And what would give it credibility when a company's deciding what to invest in, for example?
11:31
Well, I think, so first I'm, I just, I just want to say I'm super pleased to have been able to be a part of this.
11:38
Fenn, this really is you to take credit for, for the work into it.
11:44
And I, you know, happy to sign on because it was just such an impressive piece of work, but really we all know who put the, the, the effort into it.
11:52
And so thank you for that.
11:55
I, I think it, people will make decisions about investment based on harder, clear understandings of the rules, right? So people would have been more inclined to invest in Canada under a NAFTA then of course USMCA, KUSMA, with an understanding that there really were rules that would be adhered to in terms of free flow of goods.
12:27
So invest in Canada, invest in Mexico, know that you're going to be able to access the US market.

21 MINS LATER

33:12
And this being the kind of main objective of one of our last papers, so please speak to that if you like.
7:54
What do you infer from that?
7:55
That's very high, Steve.
7:58
It's high, but the Senate one has been around for decades, right? And Albertans have a reason to be concerned.
8:05
Alberta has four seats, right, compared to many, many, many more for other parts of the country.
8:11
One of the things that wasn't on necessarily the ballot, but I think should have been, was can we engage in some discussions on electoral reform? Because in most cases, a general election in Canada is decided before the Albertans have finished voting.
8:25
I mean, this is not a timing of results.
8:28
This is an actual allocation of seats that means that Albertans just don't, or BCers, have that much voice.

6 MINS LATER

14:14
difficulty she finds herself in now is that if she uses the strong support for no in the referendum 10th question as sort of a pretext to kick all the separatists out of her party, because, you know, with the notion that you lost and we're going to continue with a pro-Canada party, can she ever win the premiership again? If they lose and set up their own party, Martha, then what?
6:35
But help us understand how much of a role did Carney have in sort of getting his message delivered to Albertans?
6:41
I agree completely with Jan.
6:43
The biggest role he played was in coming out near the end to just encourage people to get out to vote.
6:48
He actually, I think, appropriately didn't weigh in early.
6:54
He didn't weigh in strongly early.
6:57
I think because there's a view that in Quebec in the 95 referendum, there was an awful lot of outside of Quebec people.
7:03
You know, people going to the rallies, people from different parts of the country going in buses.
9:23
Martha, I'll get you the way in there.
Dalton McGuintyMODERATOR
28:30
I
28:30
know.
28:32
I say that to my Winnipeg friends and they just nod.
28:36
So for those of you, Dalton did mention the report that the School of Public Policy did this summer.
28:42
It was published a couple weeks ago.
28:44
It was done at the behest of the government of Alberta because, frankly, there were a lot of numbers being thrown out, a lot of numbers that were being thrown out based on not much at all.
28:55
And there was a lot of hype.

16 MINS LATER

Dalton McGuintyMODERATOR
44:47
How are we perceived?
12:42
Knowing what you know about Alberta and the rest of Canada, which scenario do you think is more likely?
12:49
So I refrained from that kind of comment while we were doing the report.
12:54
I just felt it was and we all did, actually.
12:57
And we felt it was just really important for the credibility of the report for us to be able to say, look, we're just we want to see what the numbers look like.
13:05
Right.
13:06
But I have to tell you, there is no way this is a nice, quiet, easy divorce.
13:12
And so, yes, now I've seen the numbers.
15:33
So as you're trying to figure out, if, for example, we do divorce, and you've got to figure out, you know, Is 10% of the national debt Alberta's responsibility? Or conversely, does Alberta actually own 10% of every Canadian forces base in the country? Do you have to put all of those different inputs into your calculations to figure out those numbers?
107:22
Why is it in Canada's interest to go down this path of closer relationships with the EU?
107:28
Well, first, I find interesting your commentary about, oh, wonder if the UK should consider this.
107:35
Well, this is still unknown, as you point out.
107:38
So we're really not sure what the details of this are.
107:40
But in a world of such uncertainty, this is honestly about far more than just Trump.
107:47
You know, people have said you're doing this to, you know, Carney's doing this to antagonize Trump.
107:51
Trump doesn't like us anymore regardless.
108:55
that in NATO.
11:00
... trust, you know, that will come back, but trust may come back under a new administration, but something is certainly shaken.
11:07
Well, something has, has certainly been shaken dramatically by Donald Trump, but I would say some, I would say some businesses are recognizing, um, and needing to do what Tom just described, and I totally support the America Plus.
11:21
It, we, we can't change our geography, so we are going to be engaged with the United States whether [laughs] we like it or not, but it's a hugely important part of our economy.
11:29
The plus piece is you don't give up the one, you just enhance and you build and you do even more for Canadian prosperity with other countries, and I, so I totally support that.
11:38
The, some of, some coun- some companies, some businesses, and frankly some politicians too, I think are making the mistake of blaming Trump for this.
11:49
It was Barack Obama who was very loudly doing buy American, right? Um, both Barack Obama and Joe Biden said no to the Keystone Pipeline, right? So this is a problem that is American.
12:04
You all know, you know, our, our colleague and, and my colleague at the school, Carlo Dade, and the new North America Initiative really doing some unprecedented work in trying to determine what Americans on the ground really feel.

28 MINS LATER

40:02
the choices but I thought, you know, again, you, you can't do it all, but if you had to do the priorities.
0:38
Yes.
0:40
How does that happen? Well, I moved schools and I was very fortunate to have attended a school in Toronto that really took curriculum seriously and just did some really amazing stuff.
0:58
And it was also all in French.
1:00
This is before there was French, public French immersion.
1:03
And my mom just thought this is a country of two languages.
1:06
You know, if we have an opportunity, the school had started a couple of years before I was able to attend.
1:11
So I was in the third year of the school.

10 MINS LATER

11:30
Like you hold true to your values.
4:37
No, I know, I know.
4:40
It is a moment.
4:42
I'm a bit worried that there will be, see, we made enough noise.
4:48
Quebec has always, you know, threatened separation and they've gotten better, you know, arrangements from Ottawa.
4:54
I'm a little worried that there's going to be a sense of, The more, you know, angry Albertans have have done that, that that now that's why Ottawa was paying more attention to Alberta and why we're, you know, I don't I actually don't see that.
5:12
What I see is much more related to what's been happening in the United States.
5:18
And the fact that Alberta and Saskatchewan actually are quite different from Ontario and Quebec, for example, in the fact that we have resources that the United States needs.
Doug FordSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
9:31
I feel some days that I'm standing alone protecting Canada, and I need everyone else to get on side.
4:35
No, I know, I know.
4:39
It is a moment.
4:40
I'm a bit worried that there will be, see, we made enough noise.
4:46
Quebec has always, you know, threatened separation and they've gotten better, you know, arrangements from Ottawa.
4:52
I'm a little worried that there's going to be a sense of, The more, you know, angry Albertans have have done that, that that now that's why Ottawa is paying more attention to Alberta and why we're, you know, I don't I actually don't see that.
5:10
What I see is much more related to what's been happening in the United States.
5:17
And the fact that Alberta and Saskatchewan actually are quite different from Ontario and Quebec, for example, in the fact that we have resources that the United States needs.
Doug FordSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
9:29
I feel some days that I'm standing alone protecting Canada, and I need everyone else to get on side.
1:32
First, I want to hear from you, what do you make of the tripartite agreement revealed last week? Because you recently came out and called for Pathways to be postponed.
1:43
Yes, and, and the context there is that, um, I was at Suncor, I was the chief sustainability officer at Suncor when the bright idea of the Pathways Carbon Capture project, uh, was born, and was very much involved as one of the architects of the whole project.
2:00
And I can go into detail about why I felt that that was the right thing to do at the time, 'cause we all did.
2:06
But in recent years, and certainly more recently with, uh, what's happened with Donald Trump, now twice, the, uh, Russian invasion of Ukraine, now twice, obviously a whole lot of other geopolitical challenges going, uh, going on around the world, Canada has finally, it feels, woken up to what we need to do from an economic reality, a national security reality perspective.
2:30
And at the same time, the rest of the world is focused on a whole lot of other things other than climate right now as well.
2:36
And so for me, when we know...
2:39
when we came to realize that Canada needed to spend billions of dollars in terms of our e- you know, economic diversification, in terms of national security, we're not...

7 MINS LATER

10:19
What do you make of that part of the carrot embedded in the imperfect deal you've, you've described?
4:57
Hmm.
4:57
Like, "We actually wanna be part of the United States, right? And if we do that, then there are a whole lot of other factors involved." So I, there's, there's anticipation by some.
5:07
There's worry by some, for sure.
5:10
Um, without question, the uncertainty is a problem for business, one way or the other.
5:14
Like, y- y- when you, we saw that with, with Quebec.
5:18
I mean, we're in the BMO Center.
5:20
It was threats of a Quebec referendum that caused the Bank of Montreal to move its headquarters to Toronto, right? So business, b- there's a lot of uncertainty, regardless of which way the referendum goes, but I, I do think if it's closer than people think, it'll be, it will be hard to heal from that.
10:25
Oh, wow.
Jennifer KeanCORRESPONDENT
27:06
They have large farms producing a record-breaking amount of milk, and Martha Hall Findlay says, you know, Canada is right next door.
27:14
And for American producers, that's really frustrating, [laughs] right? You're, you know, a dairy farmer in Wisconsin, and you have a market right to the north of you that could be lucrative, but you're, you, you can't have any access to that.
Jennifer KeanCORRESPONDENT
28:08
And Martha Hall Findlay is worried that that means we've sort of got one hand tied behind our back, right? If supply management is off the table, what does that mean for everything else?
28:19
It means that everything else is, is negotiable.
28:22
Well, that puts the bee farmers, that puts the auto sector, that puts steel alum- puts everybody.
28:27
Puts the, the, the softwood lumber people.
28:30
It puts them, uh, on their, on their heels because y- y- they are actually, um, on the table.
13:22
Martha, how do you see it?
13:24
Well, look, the MOU was with the province of Alberta, not with a lobby.
13:30
I personally think the MOU is historic.
13:34
I think this is a fantastic development in the relationship between the federal government and Alberta, and frankly, I think all provinces, because it shows a willingness on the part of the federal government to work with provinces.
13:49
You know, I just, I find it, Canada has set goals for a variety of things in the past.
13:56
But, you know, when we set those goals, we were part of what felt like a global consensus, you know, the Paris Accord.
14:07
But I tell you, you know, it's 2026 and the world has changed so dramatically.

7 MINS LATER

21:11
I am curious if that is part and parcel with sort of the conversations that are happening right now.
10:46
Fair
10:46
game.
10:48
For Premier Eby to get up today, I think it was just earlier today, and accuse Mark Carney of catering to, I think the quote was, separatists and a separatist premier, only puts fuel on the fire here.
11:03
That is not at all helpful.
11:06
And for those of us who take real pride in being Canadian and want to make sure we stay together, it was inappropriate, completely inappropriate, not helpful.
11:16
Um, there's some pretty big projects that have benefited and continue to benefit BC TMX Trans Mountain expansion, which by the way, now the premier seems to be supportive of, um, relies on Alberta oil.
11:28
Oh, interesting.

34 MINS LATER

45:44
It's tough, right? If you're sitting in the boardroom, and especially if you're an international company, like many of these are now, and they can say, well, where do we deploy this capital?
2:38
Does this deal that will be signed later today give oil and gas companies the certainty they've been looking for when it comes to carbon policy and therefore potentially signing on to build a pipeline?
2:48
Well, we'll, we'll wait, we'll wait and see.
2:50
I mean, this, this MOU, this arrangement with the federal, uh, government and Alberta is historic.
2:56
Um, it, for a whole lot of reasons, I, it, it's, it's, uh, a really good thing to see move forward for national unity, but also to be able to, uh, to, to do our part in terms of energy security globally.
3:09
Um, but y- y- you know, in, in Canadian history, we've never done a major, as, as they call them [laughs] national built, national, uh, uh, nation-building projects without significant federal-provincial collaboration and without significant private and public financing collaboration.
3:30
Um, there's no question the private sector is very keen to see this go ahead and very keen to see, uh, the options for a pipeline, um, but it's chicken and egg.
3:40
You can't, you, you can't have the p- the, the energy producers go ahead and spend billions of dollars to increase production if they don't know that they can have access to the West Coast.
7:35
If both Ottawa and Alberta are game to make it happen, why hit pause?
20:49
Not discounting the opportunities as well, but the risk.
20:53
They're thinking, sure, better be.
20:54
Like, we have to stop being such Boy Scouts in Canada.
20:58
I mean, we've been so complacent for at least a quarter of a century, I think more, not just because of geopolitics, our economic, our productivity numbers, like, we're just not, we've been complacent.
21:11
And complacent really is the best word.
21:13
And we started to become more aware of some of these challenges on the economic front when Donald Trump got elected and the whole tariff thing.
21:20
But we are a very attractive slice of meat in a sandwich that is bordered by the Russians in the north and the Americans on the south.

10 MINS LATER

31:07
be a backstop.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.