Listener sentiment
U Up? continues to sharply divide its audience, with a devoted core of longtime listeners who consider the show indispensable dating comfort food and a growing faction of former loyalists who feel it has lost its way. The subscription price increase — justified by an added video tier few listeners asked for — remains the most consequential flashpoint, with the hosts' reportedly dismissive response to complaints driving cancellations among subscribers of five or more years. Jared's on-air conduct is the most discussed topic across reviews of every rating: his constant interruptions, combativeness with guests, and perceived dismissiveness toward women's perspectives draw repeated criticism even from fans who otherwise love the show, while Jordana earns praise for thoughtfulness but also catches flak for being guarded, overly focused on surface-level personal updates, and seemingly reluctant to share the kind of intimate relationship content the subscriber tier promises. The most recent ratings add a new thread — several listeners feel Jared has grown smug and out of touch now that he is in a relationship — but the overall pattern is unchanged: a podcast whose most passionate supporters and most frustrated detractors are often the same people, separated only by how much patience they have left.
Apple4.1 · 829
Summary generated Aug 7, 2026
