Oct 28, 2026 · 23 min · 9 segments
A social media ban for under-16s sounds like a welcome relief for parents. But will it actually make our children safer? In this episode, I'm looking at what Australia's experience can teach us, from…
Much of the pressure on families isn't really about the apps, it's about everyone else.
So each family might give way a little earlier than it would like, and the age just keeps creeping down.
no one person chose that but everybody ends up living with it and a ban changes the starting-point for everyone at once which is something that no single family or even a community of families in a school can do And there's early evidence that this part is working well.
Australia's online safety regulator, eSafety, found that three months in, parents reported feeling less pressure.
The share of children who said that they felt like they were missing out by not having social media fell from just over 43% to just over 36%.
some children are reported better relationships and less pressure to be online too and that's that's real we're not going to wave that away and say it doesn't matter if a law makes it easier for even some families to hold a line that they already believed in then it has some value but i'm hesitating what's my hesitation about well is that a ban tends to move behaviour rather than change it.
A large study from the University of Birmingham published in 2025 compared more than 1,200 secondary pupils in schools that banned phones during the day with pupils in schools that allowed them at breaks and lunch.
But the pupils made up for it outside school, so their overall time on phones and social media was not meaningfully different.
And there was no difference in mental well-being, sleep, behaviour in class or grades.
Now, the lead researcher, Dr Victoria Goodyear, was careful to say that this isn't an argument against school phone bans.
Much of the pressure on families isn't really about the apps, it's about everyone else.
So each family might give way a little earlier than it would like, and the age just keeps creeping down.
no one person chose that but everybody ends up living with it and a ban changes the starting-point for everyone at once which is something that no single family or even a community of families in a school can do And there's early evidence that this part is working well.
Australia's online safety regulator, eSafety, found that three months in, parents reported feeling less pressure.
The share of children who said that they felt like they were missing out by not having social media fell from just over 43% to just over 36%.
some children are reported better relationships and less pressure to be online too and that's that's real we're not going to wave that away and say it doesn't matter if a law makes it easier for even some families to hold a line that they already believed in then it has some value but i'm hesitating what's my hesitation about well is that a ban tends to move behaviour rather than change it.
A large study from the University of Birmingham published in 2025 compared more than 1,200 secondary pupils in schools that banned phones during the day with pupils in schools that allowed them at breaks and lunch.
But the pupils made up for it outside school, so their overall time on phones and social media was not meaningfully different.
And there was no difference in mental well-being, sleep, behaviour in class or grades.
Now, the lead researcher, Dr Victoria Goodyear, was careful to say that this isn't an argument against school phone bans.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.