Listener sentiment
The Q&A with Jeff Goldsmith commands a devoted, long-term audience who consistently praise the podcast's deep-dive research, guest caliber, and educational value for screenwriters and filmmakers. Listeners frequently cite a decade or more of regular listening, and they appreciate Jeff's thoughtful preparation and willingness to ask tough, specific questions. However, recurring criticism centers on Jeff's hosting approach: multiple reviewers independently note that he talks excessively and frequently interrupts guests mid-answer, undermining the stated appeal of hearing directly from major screenwriters. Additional frustration stems from long, repetitive promotional segments for his magazine Backstory that disrupt episode flow, and recent listeners have flagged audio quality issues. A few reviewers also characterize Jeff as overly eager to pursue "fanboy" tangents that guests aren't interested in exploring. Overall, the podcast's core mission and guest access remain highly valued, but host behavior and production choices present a recurring friction point with the audience.
Apple4.3 · 50
Summary generated May 29, 2026
