The Meb Faber Show - Better Investing
Jun 7, 2024 · 47 min · 14 segments
Today’s guest is Eva Shang, co-founder and CEO of Legalist, which is an institutional alternative asset management firm using data-driven technology to invest in credit assets at scale. Eva is a Thiel…
Meb FaberHostJeff RemsburgHost
I imagine Over the past decade-ish, you guys have developed a fair amount of interesting insight into what tends to work and what tends not to.
I do think that when people think about the money ball of litigation, they are simplifying it quite a bit.
So when we first started building the legal analytics product, Christian and I were really excited because we thought that we had figured out which cases, or sorry, which lawyers are better than all the other lawyers.
And then we went in and actually looked at their win rates and what types of cases their win rates were based on.
So they were all getting default judgments against debtors for like a hundred dollars.
And that's where I think the danger really comes in in overgeneralizing with legal analytics.
If you have a lawyer that only takes on the hardest cases, they might be like a doctor that's like a heart surgeon as opposed to a pediatrician or a family doctor, right? Yeah, more of their patients die, but they also take on the very hardest cases.
Not to mention the fact that at the really complex commercial litigation level, most cases settle.
Or if they are moving towards trial to begin with, it means that something has gone really wrong because their job is to settle the case.
There are really three things that we underwrite for in a litigation finance case.
If it's going to be successful, how much is it going to be successful for? And then there is collectability.
So if the case is successful, are you actually going to be able to get the defendant to pay, especially to pay that amount? So you see a lot of these cases that win billion dollar verdicts at trial, but the defendant has no way to pay for it or they're going to file bankruptcy and then get out of paying the vast majority of it.
So collectability is a really big factor and it's actually just as important as the other two.
What our tech is historically really, really good at is it's really good at weeding out the cases that just have no liability to stand on whatsoever.
The next stage, the damages stage, actually has to be done by human underwriters, and it cannot be eliminated from the underwriting process because it's so case specific.
So to go back to our earn out agreement, whether your company or the entrepreneur did the work to earn a $1 million earn out, a $5 million earn out, or a $10 million earn out, it's so fact specific that it really can't be money balled.

I imagine Over the past decade-ish, you guys have developed a fair amount of interesting insight into what tends to work and what tends not to.
I do think that when people think about the money ball of litigation, they are simplifying it quite a bit.
So when we first started building the legal analytics product, Christian and I were really excited because we thought that we had figured out which cases, or sorry, which lawyers are better than all the other lawyers.
And then we went in and actually looked at their win rates and what types of cases their win rates were based on.
So they were all getting default judgments against debtors for like a hundred dollars.
And that's where I think the danger really comes in in overgeneralizing with legal analytics.
If you have a lawyer that only takes on the hardest cases, they might be like a doctor that's like a heart surgeon as opposed to a pediatrician or a family doctor, right? Yeah, more of their patients die, but they also take on the very hardest cases.
Not to mention the fact that at the really complex commercial litigation level, most cases settle.
Or if they are moving towards trial to begin with, it means that something has gone really wrong because their job is to settle the case.
There are really three things that we underwrite for in a litigation finance case.
If it's going to be successful, how much is it going to be successful for? And then there is collectability.
So if the case is successful, are you actually going to be able to get the defendant to pay, especially to pay that amount? So you see a lot of these cases that win billion dollar verdicts at trial, but the defendant has no way to pay for it or they're going to file bankruptcy and then get out of paying the vast majority of it.
So collectability is a really big factor and it's actually just as important as the other two.
What our tech is historically really, really good at is it's really good at weeding out the cases that just have no liability to stand on whatsoever.
The next stage, the damages stage, actually has to be done by human underwriters, and it cannot be eliminated from the underwriting process because it's so case specific.
So to go back to our earn out agreement, whether your company or the entrepreneur did the work to earn a $1 million earn out, a $5 million earn out, or a $10 million earn out, it's so fact specific that it really can't be money balled.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.