Listener sentiment
The most recent ratings for The Five show sentiment rebounding from the subscription-paywall backlash that dominated mid-2026, with attention returning to the show's panel dynamics and political balance. The single most persistent theme across the entire review window remains sharply divided opinions of Jessica Tarlov: a vocal contingent of conservative listeners find her combative and grating and repeatedly call for Harold Ford Jr. to replace her as the panel's liberal voice, while a smaller but equally passionate group argues she is the show's most essential contributor, bringing researched facts and genuine ideological diversity to an otherwise right-leaning table. Harold Ford Jr. draws near-universal praise for his measured, respectful delivery, and several recent reviewers also single out a newer panelist, Emily, as a welcome addition. Greg Gutfeld and Jesse Watters continue to be fan favorites for their humor and chemistry, and international listeners in the UK, Australia, and Southeast Asia value the show as a window into American political discourse. A handful of one-star reviews reflect blanket ideological opposition to Fox News rather than specific content critiques. Overall, the median listener remains highly satisfied, though the recurring pressure to reshape the liberal chair — and the brief but intense paywall controversy — reveal an audience that feels deeply invested in the show's format and personnel.
Apple3.7 · 530
Summary generated Sep 14, 2026
