Sep 18, 2026 · 1 hr 18 min · 23 segments
Two-time debate champion Bo Seo breaks down why arguments fail: the 4 bad-faith personas that hijack conversations, a four-question framework for picking fights worth having, and the surprising Cold…
Bo SeoGuest
I felt the need to write good arguments because I think our public conversations are in a state of crisis.

And that is the more visible crisis that we see where every disagreement out in media or in the public square is a source of division and pain.

But it's also the hidden crisis of all the people who are driven away from participating in those conversations at all.

because they fear that it's going to be pointless or it's going to be painful and it's not going to be worth their time.

Good arguments is not only what democracies have to do, it's what they on their best days aspire to be, which is a conversation between people who disagree, sometimes over irreconcilable things, to find areas of agreement, to spot points where they need to work across their differences to reach a better solution.

One of the reasons why our arguments are so divisive and painful and present is that we've allowed the skills of disagreeing well to atrophy.

The bad arguments that result, in turn, decrease our confidence in what disagreements can do for us.

And when we lack that faith in what arguments can do, we tend to approach them more defensively.

And as a result, the lack of faith and lack of confidence tends to be self-reinforcing.

And the resulting cascade means that the quality of the conversation further degrades.

The tradition of good argument that I'm trying to advocate for is very much rooted in history.

It goes back all the way to antiquity, where in ancient Greece, the ability to make your point persuasively, to engage other citizens in discussion and debate, was seen as a kind of a requirement of citizenship, that it's what it meant for us to govern ourselves.


And that tradition kind of carries forth in the United States with a lot of the founding fathers starting debate clubs and colleges, viewing part of their role as leaders and as founders of a new country as instilling in the nation that spirit of debate.

So one high-profile debate that comes to mind is the series of debates between the civil rights leader James Farmer and Malcolm X, who had a different view of what racial liberation looked like, what the appropriate response to racism was.

And these were a series of disagreements between people who were ostensibly on the same side, whose objectives were in some sense allied, but they were not shy about voicing their disagreements in really candid, strong, full-throated ways in the view of the public.

knowing that the other side would respond respectfully, that they would be candid about the disagreements, and through that conversation, that they would be able to get somewhere they couldn't on their
own.

Pharma came up under one of the great debate coaches who ever lived, Melvin Tolson, who was memorialized actually by Denzel Washington in that movie, The Great Debaters.

I felt the need to write good arguments because I think our public conversations are in a state of crisis.

And that is the more visible crisis that we see where every disagreement out in media or in the public square is a source of division and pain.

But it's also the hidden crisis of all the people who are driven away from participating in those conversations at all.

because they fear that it's going to be pointless or it's going to be painful and it's not going to be worth their time.

Good arguments is not only what democracies have to do, it's what they on their best days aspire to be, which is a conversation between people who disagree, sometimes over irreconcilable things, to find areas of agreement, to spot points where they need to work across their differences to reach a better solution.

One of the reasons why our arguments are so divisive and painful and present is that we've allowed the skills of disagreeing well to atrophy.

The bad arguments that result, in turn, decrease our confidence in what disagreements can do for us.

And when we lack that faith in what arguments can do, we tend to approach them more defensively.

And as a result, the lack of faith and lack of confidence tends to be self-reinforcing.

And the resulting cascade means that the quality of the conversation further degrades.

The tradition of good argument that I'm trying to advocate for is very much rooted in history.

It goes back all the way to antiquity, where in ancient Greece, the ability to make your point persuasively, to engage other citizens in discussion and debate, was seen as a kind of a requirement of citizenship, that it's what it meant for us to govern ourselves.


And that tradition kind of carries forth in the United States with a lot of the founding fathers starting debate clubs and colleges, viewing part of their role as leaders and as founders of a new country as instilling in the nation that spirit of debate.

So one high-profile debate that comes to mind is the series of debates between the civil rights leader James Farmer and Malcolm X, who had a different view of what racial liberation looked like, what the appropriate response to racism was.

And these were a series of disagreements between people who were ostensibly on the same side, whose objectives were in some sense allied, but they were not shy about voicing their disagreements in really candid, strong, full-throated ways in the view of the public.

knowing that the other side would respond respectfully, that they would be candid about the disagreements, and through that conversation, that they would be able to get somewhere they couldn't on their
own.

Pharma came up under one of the great debate coaches who ever lived, Melvin Tolson, who was memorialized actually by Denzel Washington in that movie, The Great Debaters.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.