We Tried 4 Bizarre Oreo Flavors! Banana Pudding, Chicken & Waffles & More

How far would you go for an Oreo? On Episode 261 of That Don’t Sound Right, hosts Peter and Cecil welcome Margaret “Meg” Wilson for a blind taste test featuring four limited-edition Oreo flavors that sound questionable before you even take the first bite. On the menu: Banana Pudding, Apple Pie à la Mode, Deep-Fried Oreo, and Chicken & Waffles. What starts as a simple taste test quickly turns into exactly the kind of conversation you’d expect from TDSR—surprise, laughter, strong opinions, and a few moments of genuine revulsion. Some flavors bring back familiar desserts. Others leave everyone wondering who decided these should become Oreos in the first place. Along the way, Peter, Cecil, and Meg talk about nostalgia, podcast milestones, weird food experiments, and why our brains sometimes tell us something should taste good… right up until we actually taste it. Then there’s a quick speed round to wrap things up. Four unusual Oreo flavors. Three willing taste testers. One important question: Which Oreo flavor sounds the most wrong—and which one would you actually eat again? This is That Don’t Sound Right—where we talk the way we did before the internet, when you couldn’t immediately prove anybody right or wrong and the expertise lived in the people sitting around the conversation. And sometimes, you just have to take a bite and decide for yourself. If you find yourself thinking, “That Don’t Sound Right”… you’re one of us. Hashtags: #tdsrpodcast #ThatDontSoundRight #Oreo #Oreos #OreoTasteTest #BlindTasteTest #WeirdFood #WeirdFoodChallenge #LimitedEditionOreo #BananaPudding #ApplePie #ChickenAndWaffles #DeepFriedOreo #FoodChallenge #FoodTasteTest #SnackFood #Nostalgia #FunnyPodcast #ComedyPodcast #Podcast #PodcastEpisode #FoodPodcast #TasteTest #Episode261