Listener sentiment
Listeners are overwhelmingly positive about Slayerfest98, with many calling it the best Buffy podcast available and a genuine comfort listen. The show's signature strengths are its queer, Latinx perspective on the Buffyverse, a rotating cast of diverse guest hosts that keeps every episode feeling fresh, and host Ian Carlos Crawford's warm, welcoming presence — reviewers repeatedly describe the experience as "hanging out with friends." High-profile guests from the Buffy cast and crew are a frequent highlight, and the podcast's expansion beyond Buffy into Marvel, horror, and other genre properties is embraced by most listeners as a feature rather than a distraction, though a small number of early reviewers felt the broader scope came at the expense of dedicated Buffy coverage. The most consistent criticisms across the review history are uneven audio quality — a recurring note given the large rotating guest format — and occasional conversational tangents or guests who talk over others. A couple of low ratings amount to off-topic or troll reviews rather than substantive engagement. Overall, the podcast commands deep listener loyalty, with several reviewers describing years of consistent listening and a sense of having found their fandom community.
Apple4.7 · 64
Summary generated Jul 10, 2026
