Aug 21, 2026 · 45 min · 12 segments
In this episode of The Responsive Lab, Carly and Scott sit down with Dave Raley, Founder of the Center for Sustainable Giving. Dave spent 18 years in fundraising and marketing before founding the…
It says this, our recurring giving program hasn't gained or lost donors in two years.
It's remained flat.
So what's your suggestion for starting to see it grow again?
I'm glad that you're leading with this one because, frankly, it is a reality for a lot of organizations.
Despite what I've said and what the trends show as far as more donors are choosing recurring giving than at any other time in history, for many organizations, this is the reality that they're facing.
somewhere
and 86 percent after the first year.
which is wonderful, by the way, more than twice the average value retention of a single gift donor, somebody who gives again, which is 42%, which means 68% of the time, the average single gift donor is not going to give again next year, which is a big problem.
However, even with recurring giving, you know, if you take that 78 to 86 percent, that's still 14 percent or more of people that are going to not give again next year.
So you still need to add new people to the program in a way that exceeds the number of people that are leaving the program.
So a couple of things that come to mind when I think about organizations that are flat.
I mean, when we do our assessment, Scott and Carly, we do I mean, we look at 10 different channels and or I'm sorry, 17 different channels and 10 different strategies.
But to kind of make it very simple, one of the most common things we see when organizations are flat is that they say recurring giving is a priority, but they don't show it.
And what I mean is they just simply, if you go to their website, if you look at their communications, they do not talk about recurring giving.
I mean, not intentionally, but it's kind of a, oh, and by the way, P.S., if you'd like to give a monthly gift, you could do that.
It says this, our recurring giving program hasn't gained or lost donors in two years.
It's remained flat.
So what's your suggestion for starting to see it grow again?
I'm glad that you're leading with this one because, frankly, it is a reality for a lot of organizations.
Despite what I've said and what the trends show as far as more donors are choosing recurring giving than at any other time in history, for many organizations, this is the reality that they're facing.
somewhere
and 86 percent after the first year.
which is wonderful, by the way, more than twice the average value retention of a single gift donor, somebody who gives again, which is 42%, which means 68% of the time, the average single gift donor is not going to give again next year, which is a big problem.
However, even with recurring giving, you know, if you take that 78 to 86 percent, that's still 14 percent or more of people that are going to not give again next year.
So you still need to add new people to the program in a way that exceeds the number of people that are leaving the program.
So a couple of things that come to mind when I think about organizations that are flat.
I mean, when we do our assessment, Scott and Carly, we do I mean, we look at 10 different channels and or I'm sorry, 17 different channels and 10 different strategies.
But to kind of make it very simple, one of the most common things we see when organizations are flat is that they say recurring giving is a priority, but they don't show it.
And what I mean is they just simply, if you go to their website, if you look at their communications, they do not talk about recurring giving.
I mean, not intentionally, but it's kind of a, oh, and by the way, P.S., if you'd like to give a monthly gift, you could do that.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.